Public Preferences for Pandemic Response Strategies: A Discrete Choice Experiment on Vaccination, Restrictions, and Risk Communication in a Hypothetical Hantavirus Outbreak

How to cite

Maggio, Giuseppe; Battisti, Michele; Dardanoni, Valentino; Amodio, Emanuele. 2026. "Public Preferences for Pandemic Response Strategies: A Discrete Choice Experiment on Vaccination, Restrictions, and Risk Communication in a Hypothetical Hantavirus Outbreak." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019055. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19055-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Giuseppe Maggio* , Michele Battisti , Valentino Dardanoni , Emanuele Amodio

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019055
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19055-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-06-29 – 2026-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C25, D81, D91, I12, I18
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19055

Abstract

Public acceptance of public health interventions is critical for the effective management of future infectious disease outbreaks. This study investigates individual preferences for alternative pandemic response strategies using a discrete choice experiment (DCE) embedded in a large-scale online survey conducted in Italy and the United States. Respondents complete eight hypothetical choice tasks set in the context of a future hantavirus epidemic, selecting among three policy options: a vaccination program, non-pharmaceutical restrictions, or no additional public health measures. Alternatives vary in vaccine efficacy, risk of serious adverse events, regulatory approval status, recommending authority, type and duration of restrictions, economic and social burden, and projected hospitalizations and deaths. In addition to stated preferences, the survey collects information on respondents' experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic, vaccine attitudes, trust in institutions and information sources, risk literacy, political orientation, health status, and sociodemographic characteristics. Preference heterogeneity is analyzed using mixed logit models, with interaction terms examining how trust, prior pandemic experiences, and individual characteristics moderate policy preferences. The study also compares preference structures between Italian and U.S. respondents and estimates trade-offs individuals are willing to make between health outcomes and the social and economic costs of public health interventions. By identifying the factors that shape public support for vaccination, restrictions, and risk communication strategies, this research provides evidence to inform the design of pandemic preparedness policies that are both effective and socially acceptable.

Intervention

Participants are presented with a hypothetical future hantavirus outbreak and complete a discrete choice experiment (DCE) consisting of eight randomized choice tasks. In each task, respondents choose their preferred public health response among three alternatives: (1) a vaccination strategy, (2) a restriction-based strategy, or (3) no new public health measures. The vaccination option varies in vaccine efficacy, risk of serious side effects, regulatory approval status, and recommending authority. The restriction option varies in the type, duration, and economic/social burden of non-pharmaceutical interventions. All alternatives are accompanied by projected numbers of hospitalizations and deaths per 100,000 population over the following six months. The order of the choice tasks is randomized across participants. The intervention is embedded within a broader online survey that also collects information on COVID-19 experiences, vaccine attitudes, trust in institutions, risk literacy, and sociodemographic characteristics.

Experimental design

This study employs a randomized, within-subject discrete choice experiment (DCE) embedded within a cross-sectional online survey administered to adult participants residing in Italy and the United States. The objective is to elicit stated preferences for alternative public health response strategies during a hypothetical future hantavirus outbreak.
Each participant completes eight discrete choice tasks. In every task, respondents are presented with three mutually exclusive public health strategies and are asked to select the option they would most prefer. The three alternatives consist of: (1) a vaccination strategy, (2) a restriction-based strategy, and (3) a no-new-measures strategy. The "no new measures" alternative serves as a constant reference option across all tasks, while the vaccination and restriction alternatives vary according to experimentally assigned attribute levels.
The vaccination strategy is characterized by vaccine efficacy, the probability of serious side effects, regulatory approval status, and the authority recommending vaccination. The restriction strategy varies according to the type of restriction implemented, its duration, and the associated economic and social burden. In every choice task, each alternative is also accompanied by projected numbers of hospitalizations and deaths per 100,000 population over the following six months. Attribute combinations are generated using an efficient fractional factorial design to maximize statistical efficiency while avoiding implausible or dominant profiles.

The order of the eight choice tasks is randomized across respondents to reduce potential order and fatigue effects. All participants receive the same overall survey structure, but the randomized presentation of the experimental tasks ensures variation in exposure to the choice scenarios.
The DCE is embedded within a broader questionnaire collecting information on demographic characteristics, health status, previous experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic, vaccine attitudes, trust in institutions and information sources, political orientation, and risk literacy. These variables are measured observationally and are not experimentally manipulated.
Each respondent contributes up to eight observations, one for each completed choice task, allowing estimation of preferences for alternative policy attributes and investigation of heterogeneity in preferences across individuals and between the Italian and U.S. samples.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was implemented automatically through the Qualtrics survey platform. Qualtrics randomized the order of presentation of the eight discrete choice experiment (DCE) tasks for each respondent using its built-in randomization functionality. The allocation of attribute combinations to choice tasks was predetermined by the experimental design, while the sequence in which the tasks were presented was randomized independently for every participant.
Randomization unit
Individual respondent. Randomization occurs at the individual level through the Qualtrics platform, with each participant receiving a randomized order of the discrete choice experiment (DCE) tasks.
Clusters
5,000 individual respondents (2,500 in Italy and 2,500 in the United States).
Observations
5,000 individual respondents (2,500 in Italy and 2,500 in the United States).
Arms
1250 by arm in each country
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome is the respondent's stated choice in each discrete choice experiment (DCE) task. Each participant completes eight choice tasks and, in each task, selects one of three alternative public health response strategies: Vaccination strategy Restriction-based strategy No new public health measures The outcome is recorded as a categorical choice variable at the respondent–choice task level (up to eight observations per participant). These repeated choices are used to estimate the marginal utility (preference weights) of the experimental attributes—including vaccine efficacy, side-effect risk, regulatory approval status, recommending authority, restriction type, restriction duration, economic/social burden, and projected hospitalizations and deaths—using mixed logit (random-parameters logit) models.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords