Victim Language Project

How to cite

Prescott, J.J.. 2026. "Victim Language Project." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019054. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19054-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

J.J. Prescott*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019054
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19054-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-23 – 2026-09-30
Countries
United States of America ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19054

Abstract

This pilot survey experiment seeks to replicate and extend Conklin (2020) by examining whether calling a complainant a “victim,” rather than a “complaining witness,” affects how people evaluate an alleged assault case. Participants will read a brief vignette in which a defendant denies that an assault occurred and claims that the complainant fabricated the accusation. The experiment randomly varies the term used to refer to the complainant (“victim” versus “complaining witness”) and the complainant’s gender in the vignette. After reading the vignette, participants will answer questions about whether they believe the defendant punched the complainant, whether they agree that the complainant is a victim, and other questions about the two parties and their claims. The study is intended to help assess whether victim terminology affects mock jurors’ judgments and to inform ongoing legal debates about whether and when courts should allow prosecutors to use the term “victim” when the alleged victim’s status is disputed.

Intervention

Participants will be randomly assigned to read a vignette that refers to the complainant either as the “victim” or as the “complaining witness.” Participants will also be randomly assigned the gender of the complainant in the vignette, so that the complainant is either male or female. After reading the vignette, participants will answer a series of questions about their beliefs regarding the defendant, the complainant, and the alleged incident.

Participants will read one of four versions of the vignette below. Bracketed language indicates the text that varies by treatment condition:

Imagine you are serving on a jury for a case involving a man who allegedly punched [another man/a woman]. At trial, the defendant claimed this never happened and that the [victim/complaining witness], [John/Jane Doe], completely fabricated the entire story to get back at him for a heated argument they had earlier that night. The [victim/complaining witness] says the defendant punched [him/her] after the heated argument. Phone records show that [the victim/complaining witness] texted [his/her] friend that night that the defendant had just punched [him/her] and asked what to do. The friend told [him/her] to call the police. Immediately after receiving this advice, the [victim/complaining witness] called the police, who took [his/her] statement. There were no eyewitnesses or video evidence of the alleged assault. The police report noted no visible injury on the [victim/complaining witness].

After reading the vignette, participants will answer the primary and secondary outcome questions described below using 0–100 slider scales.

Experimental design

The experiment uses a 2x2 factorial design. The experiment randomly varies: (1) the term used to refer to the complainant, either “victim” or “complaining witness”; and (2) the gender of the complainant, either male or female.

Participants will not be informed of the study hypotheses or the treatment assignment during data collection. There is no direct interaction between researchers and participants during data collection. Researchers analyzing the data will not be blinded to treatment assignment because treatment assignment is recorded in the survey data and is necessary for the planned analysis. No human coding of open-ended participant responses is planned. These procedures are intended to reduce unintended influence from participants, researchers, coders, or analysts having knowledge of the study design, treatments, measures, or outcomes during the research process.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be conducted by Qualtrics using computerized random assignment. Participants will be randomly assigned to treatment conditions with equal probability.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual survey participant. There is no clustered randomization.
Clusters
Not applicable. There are no clusters because randomization occurs at the individual-participant level.
Observations
400 survey participants.
Arms
100 participants per treatment arm, for a total planned sample of 400 allocated equally across the four cells of the 2x2 factorial design: • 100 participants: male “victim” • 100 participants: female “victim” • 100 participants: male “complaining witness” • 100 participants: female “complaining witness” Equivalently, 200 participants will be assigned to the “victim” label condition and 200 participants will be assigned to the “complaining witness” label condition; 200 participants will see a male complainant and 200 participants will see a female complainant.
Primary outcomes
The two primary outcomes are (1) the extent to which participants believe that the defendant punched the victim/complaining witness and (2) the extent to which participants agree that the alleged victim is indeed a victim. Both outcomes are measured on a 0–100 slider scale.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include participants’ ratings of: • How violent or aggressive they believe the defendant is. • Whether they believe the defendant will commit crimes in the future. • What share of fault they believe the victim/complaining witness bears for the incident. • What share of fault they believe the defendant bears for the incident. • How severely they believe the defendant should be punished. • How believable they find the victim/complaining witness’s account. • How believable they find the defendant’s account. • How much sympathy they feel for the victim/complaining witness. Each secondary outcome is also measured using the same 0–100 slider scale. Higher values indicate more of the construct described in the corresponding survey question. These outcomes are intended to shed light on potential mechanisms through which victim terminology may influence mock jurors’ judgments.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords