Expanding Financial Protection through Microfinance: Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation of Bundled Microfinance and Health Insurance in Nigeria

How to cite

Osadolor, Nneka. 2026. "Expanding Financial Protection through Microfinance: Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation of Bundled Microfinance and Health Insurance in Nigeria." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019020. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19020-2.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Nneka Osadolor*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0019020
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19020-2.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-08-20 – 2027-02-01
Countries
Nigeria ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/19020

Abstract

Despite significant gains in financial access across low- and middle-income countries, financial health and resilience remain critically low among informal sector workers, largely due to exposure to uninsured health shocks. In Nigeria, only about 3% of adults aged 15-49 have any form of health insurance, leaving the majority vulnerable to catastrophic out-of-pocket expenditures that undermine business viability and loan repayment. This study provides causal evidence on the impact of bundling health insurance with microfinance loans on the financial outcomes of micro and small informal business owners in Edo State, Nigeria. In partnership with a microfinance institution and the Edo State Health Insurance Commission, eligible clients are offered a voluntary bundled product combining a microfinance loan with subsidised health insurance coverage. We implement a randomised encouragement design at the branch (beat)-week level, where the 24 operational units of the MFI are randomly assigned to encouragement or no-encouragement periods across 16 weeks of recruitment. Clients are free to enrol or not; only those visiting during encouragement weeks can access the bundled product. This design allows estimation of both the intent-to-treat (ITT) effect of the offer and, using two-stage least squares, the local average treatment effect (LATE) among compliers. Primary outcomes include financial health and out-of-pocket health expenditure. Secondary outcomes include business profit, loan default, health-seeking behaviour and the impact of health expenditure on economic activity.

Intervention

Intervention
This study employs a randomised encouragement design in which randomisation applies to the offer of the bundled product rather than to actual enrolment. The unit of randomisation is the beat-week – the 24 operational units of the MFB (each assigned to a dedicated credit and recovery officer) crossed with the 16 weeks of the recruitment period, yielding approximately 384 beat-week clusters. For each beat, weeks during the recruitment period will be randomly assigned to either encouragement (treatment) or no-encouragement (control) conditions. During encouragement weeks, all eligible clients visiting the beats will be offered the bundled product with full product information. During control weeks, no offer will be made, and clients receive the status quo product only. Clients remain free to enrol or not; only those visiting during randomly assigned encouragement weeks can access the bundled product. Randomisation will be stratified by branches of the MFB (4 branches) to ensure balance across study arms.

Experimental design

This study implements a randomised encouragement design to evaluate the causal impact of bundling health insurance with microfinance loans on the financial outcomes of informal micro- and small-business owners in Edo State, Nigeria. The study is conducted in partnership with a microfinance bank (MFB) operating 24 beats across 4 branches and the Edo State Health Insurance Commission.
The unit of randomisation is the beat-week. The 24 operational beats of the MFB are each assigned to encouragement (treatment) or no-encouragement (control) conditions on a week-by-week basis across 16 weeks of recruitment, yielding approximately 384 beat-week clusters. During encouragement weeks, all eligible clients visiting a beat are offered a bundled product comprising a microfinance loan and voluntary health insurance coverage (Bronze plan, ₦18,000 annual premium). During control weeks, clients receive the microfinance loan only. Randomisation is stratified by branch. Clients are never compelled to enrol; take-up is entirely voluntary.
Eligible participants are active loan clients and clients presenting for loan renewal who operate informal micro or small businesses. Two rounds of data collection – baseline and endline – will be conducted via structured surveys. The study will estimate the Intent-to-Treat (ITT) effect of the offer and the Local Average Treatment Effect (LATE) among compliers using Two-Stage Least Squares with the randomised offer as an instrumental variable for actual enrolment.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation will be conducted using a computer-generated random number procedure in Stata. For each of the 24 operational beats, the 16 recruitment weeks will be randomly assigned to either encouragement (treatment) or no-encouragement (control) conditions using a block randomisation procedure, stratified by branch (4 branches). Within each branch stratum, weeks will be assigned with equal probability to treatment and control, ensuring balance across arms within each branch. The assignment will be implemented by the research team and communicated to MFB branch coordinators on a weekly basis to minimise anticipation effects among loan officers and clients.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomisation is the beat-week - the intersection of one of the 24 operational beats of the MFB and one of the 16 weeks of the recruitment period, yielding approximately 384 beat-week clusters. A beat is the smallest operational unit of the MFI, each managed by a dedicated Credit and Recovery Officer (CRO) responsible for a defined client portfolio within a branch. Weeks within each beat are randomly assigned to encouragement or no-encouragement conditions; all eligible clients visiting a beat during an encouragement week are offered the bundled product, while no offer is made during control weeks. The unit of observation and analysis is the individual loan client.
Clusters
384 beat-weeks (24 beats × 16 recruitment weeks)
Observations
Approximately 1152 to 1536 individual loan clients (384 beat-week clusters × 3 to 4 clients per cluster on average), based on MFB administrative data showing an average of 329 combined new and renewal loans per month across 24 beats. The exact number of observations will depend on realised client turnout during encouragement and control weeks over the 16-week recruitment period.
Arms
192 beat-weeks assigned to encouragement (treatment) - approximately 576 to 768 individual loan clients 192 beat-weeks assigned to no-encouragement (control) - approximately 576 to 768 individual loan clients Total: 384 beat-weeks, approximately 1152 to 1536 individual loan clients across both arms
Primary outcomes
Primary outcome: Financial health score, measured using the EFInA Financial Health Index.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes are (1) out-of-pocket health expenditure (₦) in the 30 days prior to the survey; (2) loan default, defined as failure to repay within 30 days of the due date per MFI administrative records; (3) business profit, measured as monthly net revenue minus costs; (4) incidence of catastrophic health spending (OOP expenditure exceeding 10% of household consumption); (5) impact of health expenditure on business activity; and (6) health-seeking behaviour and utilisation of formal health services.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords