Can Religious Framing Rescue Institutional Signals? Experimental Evidence on Norm Change in a Low-Legitimacy Context
How to cite
Chaudhry, Muaz. 2026. "Can Religious Framing Rescue Institutional Signals? Experimental Evidence on Norm Change in a Low-Legitimacy Context." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0019003. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.19003-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
A growing body of evidence demonstrates that laws and institutions shape social norms — not only through enforcement but through their signalling function: communicating what is socially acceptable and legitimising or delegitimising group identities in the public sphere. This signalling effect is theorised to be especially powerful when institutional signals are reinforced by religious authority, yet causal evidence from low-institutional-legitimacy, high-religious-salience contexts remains scarce. In contexts such as Pakistan, where the credibility of secular state institutions is constrained and Islamic authority operates as the primary mechanism of norm legitimation, understanding how religious framing modulates the effect of institutional signals on public behaviour is both theoretically important and practically urgent.
This study provides the first large-scale randomised experimental test of this mechanism, exploiting the live and unresolved legal context of Pakistan's Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act 2018 — currently under Supreme Court review following its partial annulment by the Federal Shariat Court on Islamic grounds in 2023. Approximately 3,500 adults, drawn from a density-stratified, population-representative sample of urban Lahore, are randomly assigned to one of five conditions: a control condition receiving no institutional signal, or one of four vignette treatments describing an anticipated Supreme Court ruling either upholding or annulling the Act, with or without explicit religious framing drawn from real institutional discourse — the Council of Islamic Ideology's prior endorsement of the Act as consistent with Islamic principles, or the Federal Shariat Court's Quranic jurisprudential reasoning against it.
The study measures whether and how these signals shift: perceived descriptive and injunctive social norms regarding transgender inclusion; personal attitudes toward transgender individuals across social, economic, and educational domains; pluralistic ignorance — the gap between personal attitudes and perceived social norms; labour market perceptions including perceived employability of transgender individuals; and real behavioural outcomes including incentivised donation allocation, voluntary enrolment in transgender-staffed household and tutoring services, and willingness to publicly associate with transgender inclusion through information sharing.
A difference-in-differences/ANCOVA design on pre- and post-treatment institutional trust measures tests whether judicial signals shift the very legitimacy of the institutions sending them, alongside a parallel measure of the gap between personal and perceived-community trust in the Supreme Court, included as a validity check on social desirability bias given the study's implementation through a government-affiliated fieldwork partner. Heterogeneity analysis examines whether religious framing amplifies institutional signals differentially for high-religiosity respondents, whether this amplification is symmetric across inclusive and exclusionary signals, and whether prior knowledge of the Act moderates treatment effects through belief updating.
The study contributes to three literatures: the economics of social norm formation and institutional signalling; the political economy of religion and governance in Muslim-majority societies; and the economics of discrimination and labour market exclusion of stigmatised minorities. Findings have direct policy relevance for the design of judicial communication strategies, civil society advocacy, and inclusion programming in contexts where conventional rights-based institutional legitimacy is weak and religious authority functions as the primary vehicle for norm change.
Intervention
Participants are randomly assigned to one of five experimental conditions with equal probability (0.20 each). All participants first complete a demographics and baseline moderators block measuring institutional trust, religiosity, social norm sensitivity, and prior contact with the transgender community.
The control condition (C) receives no information about the Supreme Court case. Four treatment conditions present participants with a vignette describing an anticipated Supreme Court ruling on the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act 2018:
T1 — Positive institutional signal without religious framing: the Supreme Court is expected to uphold the Act and maintain all existing protections for transgender individuals.
T2 — Negative institutional signal without religious framing: the Supreme Court is expected to strike down the Act and revoke existing protections.
T3 — Positive institutional signal with Islamic religious framing: same as T1, with additional framing citing Islamic principles of justice, compassion, and human dignity, consistent with Islamic teachings in the Holy Quran and Sunnah.
T4 — Negative institutional signal with Islamic religious framing: same as T2, with additional framing citing the Federal Shariat Court's 2023 reasoning that the Act contradicts Quranic injunctions on the divine fixity of gender, drawing on Surah An-Nisa 4:11-12.
All vignettes are read aloud by trained enumerators and are designed to reflect real institutional discourse previously used by Pakistani state and religious bodies. A manipulation check immediately following the vignette measures the perceived likelihood of the ruling to test vignette credibility. Outcome measures follow in the order: social norm perception, personal attitudes, behavioural measures, post-treatment institutional trust.
Experimental design
The study uses a between-subjects randomised vignette experiment embedded in a household survey. The design has five arms — one control and four treatments — with equal probability of assignment (0.20 per arm). Assignment is individual-level, implemented through the KoboToolbox survey instrument administered by trained enumerators on tablets during face-to-face household visits.
The four treatment conditions follow a 2x2 factorial structure crossing two dimensions: policy direction (positive ruling upholding the Transgender Persons Act versus negative ruling striking it down) and religious framing (absent versus present). The control condition receives no information about the Supreme Court case.
The survey flow is: demographics and baseline moderators (including pre-treatment institutional trust, perceived institutional trust, and religiosity measures) → prior knowledge questions → randomisation → vignette or control → manipulation check → outcome measures (social norm perception, personal attitudes, behavioural measures) → post-treatment institutional trust measures.
Household sampling uses a density-stratified sampling frame across 68 Union Councils in urban Lahore. UC-level population density (WorldPop 2025, 100-metre resolution) was used to classify each UC into one of two sampling procedures based on an empirically-derived threshold of 10,900 persons per km². For UCs at or above this threshold (47 of 68), reflecting sufficiently dense residential development, starting points were generated via simple random sampling within the UC boundary polygon. For UCs below this threshold (21 of 68), where administrative "Urban" classification was found to include substantial non-residential land, starting points were generated via constrained random sampling within a 150-metre radius of satellite-imagery-verified residential reference points (three per UC), sampled without replacement to preserve spatial diversity. Five starting points were generated per UC (ten for two double-weighted UCs), for 350 starting points in total. From each starting point, enumerators follow a systematic right-hand-rule walk protocol, approaching every third household, with a defined substitution protocol for non-response and a single callback permitted before substitution. Within each household, one adult is randomly selected using a random draw generated within the survey software.
Independently of treatment assignment, respondents are randomly assigned to one of two response elicitation modes for all scale-based items (10% verbal, 90% non-verbal card-based response), included as a measurement validity check and not crossed with treatment arm in the analysis of primary outcomes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.