Prompting Democracy: A Field Experiment on Generative AI and Participatory Politics

How to cite

Castellanos, Saul Martinez; Galasso, Vincenzo; Giugovaz, Matteo; Muntoni, Matteo; Nannicini, Tommaso. 2026. "Prompting Democracy: A Field Experiment on Generative AI and Participatory Politics." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018990. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18990-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Saul Martinez Castellanos* , Vincenzo Galasso , Matteo Giugovaz , Matteo Muntoni , Tommaso Nannicini

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018990
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18990-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-04-11 – 2026-10-05
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18990

Abstract

Generative AI can now be used to help citizens move from a mere social concern to a concrete, structured policy proposal. This creates a question for participatory politics: what changes when part of the work of generating a proposal can be supported by AI? AI may matter on the formulation side, by shaping the clarity, structure, feasibility, and appeal of the proposals citizens formulate. It may also matter on the reception side, by shaping how other citizens react to those proposals, especially when they know that AI was involved in producing them.

We study these questions in the context of Le Primarie delle Idee, an Italian participatory platform launched in April 2026. The platform allows registered users to develop policy proposals either with the support of a generative AI assistant or on their own. In the AI-assisted route, users interact with a multi-turn conversational facilitator based on a generative AI model, called AIdea and designed to help them turn an initial concern into a more concrete proposal. In the self-authored route, users draft their proposal directly using a template. Once submitted, proposals can be read, discussed, supported, and voted on by the user community.

The experiment therefore studies both the formulation and reception of policy proposals in an online political platform. On the formulation side, we ask whether AI-assisted proposals differ from self-authored proposals in quality, structure, and electoral appeal. Among users who receive AI assistance, we also ask whether the design of that assistance matters, by comparing a procedural, scaffolded version of the assistant with a more open-ended version and measuring effects on users' policy-reasoning skills. On the reception side, we ask whether disclosure matters: do users engage differently with a proposal when they are told whether it was AI-assisted or self-authored?

We answer these questions through two main randomizations: one over the proposal-development route and one over whether proposals display an authorship tag indicating that they were either AI-assisted or self-authored, plus a nested randomization over the version of the assistant assigned to users.

Intervention

The platform offers two routes for developing a policy proposal: an AI-assisted route, in which users develop their proposal through a multi-turn conversation with a generative AI facilitator, and a self-authored route, in which users draft their proposal directly using a template. Within the AI-assisted route, the facilitator operates in one of two modes: a procedural, scaffolded style that guides the conversation through a structured sequence, or an open-ended style without a fixed sequence. Separately, the platform interface either displays or does not display a tag disclosing whether each proposal was AI-assisted or self-authored. Users are randomized over the proposal-development route, over the facilitator mode, and over whether the authorship-disclosure tag is shown.

Experimental design

Registered users are randomized at the individual level along three orthogonal dimensions. The first assigns users to one of two proposal-development routes: an AI-assisted route, in which they develop a proposal through conversation with a generative AI facilitator, or a self-authored route, in which they draft directly using a template. Nested within this, a second assignment sets the AI facilitator to one of two modes: a procedural, scaffolded style or an open-ended style, and applies to all users, becoming operative only for those who use the facilitator. A third, independent assignment determines whether the platform interface displays a tag disclosing each proposal's mode of authorship (AI-assisted or self-authored). The three assignments are orthogonal by design. Analysis is primarily by intent-to-treat. The study runs on a live participatory platform from June to October 2026, concluding with a final platform vote among the most-supported proposals. Because the realized sample depends on platform adoption over the experimental window, the partition of outcomes and some specifications are preliminary and will be finalized in an updated plan. Further design detail is provided in the uploaded pre-analysis plan.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by computer. For users registered before the experimental start, assignment is performed by the research team, stratified by registration phase, with balanced allocation across the eight experimental cells within each stratum. For users registering during the experimental period, assignment is made on a rolling basis using a deterministic eight-registration cycle that preserves the same target proportions. All three randomized dimensions are assigned at the user level and remain fixed throughout the experimental period.
Randomization unit
Individual (user). All three randomized dimensions, proposal-development route, AI-facilitator mode, and authorship-disclosure tag, are assigned at the individual user level. For users registered before the experimental start, randomization is stratified by registration phase. Note: the realized sample size is not yet known, as it depends on platform adoption over the experimental window; the figures below are planned targets derived from ex-ante power calculations and will be updated once the realized sample is known.
Clusters
The realized number is not yet known, as it depends on platform adoption over the experimental window (June–October 2026); this field will be updated once the realized sample is known.
Observations
The realized number of individuals, proposals, and conversations is not yet known, as it depends on platform adoption over the experimental window; these figures will be updated once the realized sample is known.
Arms
The three randomizations are orthogonal, so each user contributes to all three contrasts simultaneously; the arm sizes above are not additive across randomizations. Realized arm sizes are not yet known and depend on platform adoption; these are planned targets and will be updated once the realized sample is known.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes, grouped by randomization, are: (1) For the proposal-development route: proposal quality (a blind-evaluated rubric score), proposal-level engagement on the platform (supports, comments, event participation, and sharing), and individual-level submission behavior (whether a user submits any proposal, and the number of proposals submitted). (2) For the facilitator mode (procedural vs. open-ended): proposal quality, and characteristics of the development conversation, including its length and how it concludes, the breadth of policy-reasoning components covered, and the extent of post-generation editing of the proposal. (3) For the authorship-disclosure tag: engagement with proposals on the platform (supports, comments, event participation, sharing, and final voting), and whether users open or submit a proposal via the AI-assisted or self-authored route. The partition of outcomes into primary and secondary is preliminary and depends on the statistical power available given platform adoption; it will be finalized in an updated plan once the realized sample is known.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes, by randomization: (1) Proposal-development route: self-assessed expected impact and approval of the proposal; off-platform mobilization (whether a user organizes at least one event); a platform engagement index based on login frequency; and the conversation-level outcomes listed below. (2) Facilitator mode (procedural vs. open-ended): satisfaction with the AI-assisted experience and an open-text report of what the assistant was most useful for (collected from AI-assisted users at submission). (3) Conversation-level (analyzed where applicable): conversation length and how it concludes; breadth of policy-reasoning components covered and user initiative; and the extent of post-generation editing of the generated proposal. We additionally report secondary estimands alongside the primary intent-to-treat analyses, including a complier-average (instrumental-variables) effect for the proposal-development route. The primary/secondary partition is preliminary and will be finalized once the realized sample is known. Secondary Outcomes (Explanation)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords