GPs' beliefs and decision making: is the message or the messenger more important?

How to cite

Prometti, Ilaria; Pertile, Paolo; Bertoli, Paola; Levati, Maria Vittoria. 2026. "GPs' beliefs and decision making: is the message or the messenger more important?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018989. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18989-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ilaria Prometti* , Paolo Pertile , Paola Bertoli , Maria Vittoria Levati

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018989
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18989-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-01 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Italy ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18989

Abstract

The aim of this study is to examine how general practitioners make decisions when evaluating ambiguous clinical scenarios. In particular, the research focuses on how information provided by third-party sources may influence clinical judgment and decision-making. The study involves approximately 500 general practitioners in Italy and uses a controlled experimental design based on standardized clinical vignettes. Participants are presented with a series of clinical cases that vary in terms of contextual information and the presence of additional decision-support material. Clinical decisions are assessed through probabilistic judgments and behavioral choices, such as requests for further investigations or referrals. Overall, the study aims to better understand the factors that shape clinical reasoning under uncertainty and the potential role of supportive informational tools.

Intervention

Participants are presented with a series of standardized clinical vignettes describing ambiguous patient cases. The scenarios vary in contextual information and are used to study clinical decision-making under uncertainty. In some conditions, participants receive additional informational support alongside the clinical cases, designed to provide relevant clinical cues to assist decision-making. Participants are asked to evaluate each case by providing probabilistic judgments and indicating potential clinical actions, such as diagnostic testing or referral decisions. The order and type of information presented are systematically varied across participants as part of an experimental design.

Experimental design

This study uses a randomized controlled experimental design based on standardized clinical vignettes to examine clinical decision-making under conditions of uncertainty among general practitioners. Participants are recruited and complete an online survey consisting of multiple sections, including demographic and professional background questions, attitudinal measures, and clinical decision-making tasks based on hypothetical cases.

In the experimental component, participants are randomly assigned to different versions of clinical scenarios that vary in how clinical information is presented. Participants evaluate a series of vignette-based cases and provide clinical judgments and management decisions.

The order of scenarios and study conditions is randomized. The design includes both between-subject and within-subject components to compare decision patterns across different informational conditions and within individuals over multiple cases.

At the end of the survey, participants complete additional questions on clinical practice patterns, attitudes toward decision-making processes, and professional characteristics.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was implemented at the individual participant level. The software randomly assigned participants to one of the experimental conditions, randomly selected a balanced set of four clinical vignettes (according to AI support, clinical complexity, and diagnostic uncertainty), and randomized the order in which the selected vignettes were presented.
Randomization unit
Individual participant. Each participant was randomly assigned to one of the three reporter-frame conditions. Within participants, the clinical vignettes, AI support condition, and vignette presentation order were randomized according to the pre-specified balancing constraints.
Clusters
Individual participant. Randomization was not clustered.
Observations
500 general practitioner participants
Arms
200 participants – Female reporter (100 male patient, 100 female patient); 200 participants – Male reporter (100 male patient, 100 female patient); 100 participants – Neutral reporter (control group)
Primary outcomes
Primary outcomes are clinicians’ diagnostic and management decisions in response to clinical vignettes. These include diagnostic probability estimates, perceived clinical severity ratings, and clinical management decisions (testing, referral, and disposition choices). Diagnostic uncertainty is derived from the distribution of probabilistic responses across alternative clinical options.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include measures of clinical reasoning processes, decision-making patterns, and attitudes toward information sources and decision-support tools. These include probability allocations across alternative management options, self-reported frequency of encountering similar clinical cases, perceived usefulness and trust in decision-support information, and responses to questions regarding clinical practice patterns. Additional secondary outcomes include performance differences across experimental conditions and within-subject variation in responses to vignette-based scenarios.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords