Discretion, Information, and Credit Screening: Evidence from Italian Loan Officers

How to cite

Pandolfi, Lorenzo; Oliviero, Tommaso; Busetta, Giovanni; Zazzaro, Alberto. 2026. "Discretion, Information, and Credit Screening: Evidence from Italian Loan Officers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018988. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18988-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lorenzo Pandolfi* , Tommaso Oliviero , Giovanni Busetta , Alberto Zazzaro

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018988
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18988-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2026-06-23 – 2026-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
G21, C83, C93, D83, J16
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18988

Abstract

This project studies how loan officers and credit professionals evaluate credit applications, and how applicant identity and additional hard information affect credit assessments. We implement an online randomized vignette experiment in Italy with respondents involved in the evaluation of credit applications. Each respondent evaluates three hypothetical credit requests randomly selected from four possible cases: two loans to micro or small firms and two first-home mortgage applications. Within each vignette, we randomize applicant identity using names that jointly signal gender and geographic origin, as well as age, firm age or current employment/self-employment tenure, and the applicant’s relationship with the bank. After an initial assessment, respondents receive additional randomized information on credit exposure or outstanding debt position, financial or debt-service burden, and the presence or absence of a personal or family guarantee, and are asked to update their evaluations.

The main outcomes are the perceived probability that the credit becomes problematic, willingness to let the application proceed beyond initial screening, the share of the requested amount recommended for approval, and the time the respondent would invest in further assessment and support. The design allows us to estimate how applicant identity and other applicant characteristics affect initial credit assessments, how additional hard information changes these assessments, and whether such information attenuates, amplifies, or leaves unchanged differences in assessments associated with gender and geographic origin.

Experimental design

The study is an online survey experiment with randomized credit-application vignettes. Respondents are bank employees or credit professionals. After collecting information on respondents’ demographic profile, professional background, credit-evaluation experience, and institutional context, the survey presents three hypothetical credit applications randomly selected from four possible cases. The four cases consist of two SME working-capital loan applications and two residential mortgage applications.

For each vignette, the respondent first sees an initial case description and a summary table describing the application. The respondent is instructed to evaluate the request as they would in the initial screening or first review of a credit application, assuming that only the information shown at that stage is available. The initial vignette information includes both fixed case attributes and randomized applicant characteristics. The randomized initial characteristics are the applicant’s name, which jointly signals gender and geographic origin, age, firm age or job tenure, and the applicant’s relationship with the bank.

After this initial assessment, the respondent receives additional information about the same application. This second-stage information is randomized and includes credit exposure or outstanding debt position, financial burden, and the presence or absence of an accessory personal guarantee. Respondents then answer the same assessment questions again, allowing us to measure both initial credit evaluations and within-vignette updating after additional hard information is provided. A central part of the analysis will examine whether the effects of randomized applicant identity differ depending on the additional hard information provided. In particular, we will test whether information on credit exposure or outstanding debt, financial burden, and guarantee status attenuates, amplifies, or leaves unchanged differences in credit assessments associated with the applicant’s gender and geographic origin. Finally, respondents report which piece of additional information was most important, if any, in changing their evaluation.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is implemented by the online survey platform. The platform randomizes which three of the four vignettes each respondent sees, the order in which these vignettes are presented, the applicant characteristics shown in the initial vignette, and the additional hard information shown after the initial assessment.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the respondent-vignette. Each respondent evaluates multiple vignettes. Vignette assignment and order are randomized at the respondent level, while applicant characteristics and additional hard information are randomized within each respondent-vignette.
Clusters
Around 300 respondents
Observations
Around 900 hypothetical credit applications
Arms
All respondents will evaluate three vignettes with randomized applicant characteristics and additional hard information
Primary outcomes
For each vignette, the primary outcomes are measured twice: first after the initial case description, and then again after additional hard information is provided. The primary outcomes are: 1. The respondent’s perceived probability that the credit becomes problematic, defined as recording a payment delay of more than 90 days within 12 months. 2. The respondent’s willingness to let the application proceed beyond initial screening, measured on a Likert scale. 3. The share of the requested amount that the respondent would recommend for approval. 4. The time the respondent would invest in further assessing the request and supporting the credit evaluation, measured on a Likert scale relative to the time usually dedicated to a similar application. For each outcome, we will analyze both the initial assessment and the updated assessment after additional information is provided.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include: 1. The additional information reported by the respondent as most important for any change in evaluation: credit-registry or credit-bureau information, financial-burden information, guarantee status, no relevant change, or other. 2. Heterogeneity in treatment effects by respondent characteristics, including professional experience, main area of activity, type of institution, typical client segment, geographic area, and self-reported approval and default experience. 3. Heterogeneity in treatment effects by vignette type, comparing SME loan applications and residential mortgage applications, and by specific case profile. 4. Differences between initial assessments and post-information assessments across randomized applicant characteristics and randomized hard-information treatments.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords