The Algorithmic Preference Drift: A General Equilibrium Framework on Endogenous Utility and the Atrophy of Consumer Sovereignty
How to cite
Lopez, Francisco Jacobo Murillo. 2026. "The Algorithmic Preference Drift: A General Equilibrium Framework on Endogenous Utility and the Atrophy of Consumer Sovereignty." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018976. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18976-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates how predictive Artificial Intelligence (AI) and automated financial technologies (Fintech) influence consumer decision-making, price memory, and financial autonomy. While traditional economic theory assumes that consumers possess stable, independent preferences, modern digital platforms utilize sophisticated algorithms that continuously learn from past behaviors to personalize user experiences. This research introduces a framework of "induced endogenous preferences" to examine whether these adaptive systems subtly reshape consumer utility functions and impact financial sovereignty. To empirically evaluate this phenomenon, we will conduct a 6-month, double-blind Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) involving 2,400 active Fintech users in Aguascalientes, Mexico. Participants will interact within a controlled, custom-developed digital marketplace ("Sandboxed Fintech Wallet") where they will be randomly assigned to one of three interaction regimes: (1) a manual control group with high behavioral friction and maximum price salience; (2) a dynamic nudging group exposed to personalized predictive recommendations; or (3) a full automation group where the AI autonomously manages budget allocations and recurring transactions. Throughout the study, high-frequency data will be captured using real-time application telemetry combined with bi-weekly micro-surveys deployed via the Experience Sampling Method (ESM) to track shifts in expenditure patterns, attention intensity, psychological agency, and price memory accuracy. To rigorously test consumer resilience and adaptive capacity under economic stress, two controlled exogenous price shocks (simulated inflation and cost volatility) will be sequentially introduced into the market environment. Finally, an experimental decoupling phase will remove all algorithmic enhancements to assess behavioral hysteresis and long-term cognitive dependency. By deploying advanced econometrics and causal machine learning—including Fixed Effects panel models, Random-Intercept Cross-Lagged Panel Models (RI-CLPM), and Causal Forests—this project seeks to determine whether heavy reliance on algorithmic optimization yields true economic efficiency or, conversely, leads to a systematic erosion of consumer agency and financial self-efficacy. The findings aim to provide critical empirical evidence for the design of consumer protection policies and regulatory frameworks in the rapidly evolving digital economy
Intervention
1. Algorithmic Architecture and Treatment Engineering
The "Sandboxed Fintech Wallet" mobile application interfaces with a centralized secure server (UAA Dedicated Private Cloud) that dynamically modifies the application's API responses based on the individual's block assignment:
* Arm B (Dynamic Predictive Nudging): Operates on a hybrid recommendation system engine. The Content-Based Filtering (CBF) module processes a dynamic text-vector of item features, while the User-Based Collaborative Filtering (UBCF) module calculates cosine similarities across the panel's multi-period transaction lags. It systematically computes the predictive optimization vector $\theta_{it-1}$ to alter the information architecture and display customized behavioral prompts.
* Arm C (Full Automation): Actively implements automated financial routing algorithms. It isolates the agent's cash flow constraints and automatically processes optimal budget allocations, predictive automated savings, and one-click purchase checkouts based on the system's loss-minimization function.
2. High-Frequency Experience Sampling Method (ESM) Sequence
The application forces a strict data capture loop embedded within the user interface at every transaction point or scheduled bi-weekly wave ($T = 48$ measurement points). The data collection flow executes the following sequential steps:
1. Passive Telemetry Extraction: Real-time log capture of transaction values, exact timestamps, account balance visibility status, and the three raw components of the Shadow Liquidity Index ($SLI_{it}$): balance check frequency, screen-time on the budget dashboard, and alert open rates.
2. Psychometric ESM Chatbot Trigger: A micro-survey interface ($<90$ seconds response window) is deployed, enforcing a strict internal question order to eliminate cognitive contamination:
* Block A (Financial Agency - E_{ps}): Captures within-subject variations in internal financial locus of control and perceived self-efficacy utilizing a 2-item quick-response adaptation of the Generalized Self-Efficacy Scale (1–7 Likert Scale).
* Block B (Price Memory - Delta P_{error}): Prompts the user to input the estimated baseline price of a standardized reference market basket without checking current balances.
* Block C (Post-Purchase Regret): Deploys Marquina’s Post-Purchase Regret Scale items to monitor latent post-consumption dissatisfaction.
3. Exogenous Shock Parametrization and Safety Protocols
* Macroeconomic Shock 1 (Week 12): The server modifies the catalog database pricing array, inducing a sudden, forced 20% price increase on all essential non-durable goods (simulated inflation). The database tracks how the household consumption matrix mutates as the budget constraint tightens, evaluating changes in the Kullback–Leibler Divergence index ($D_{KL}$).
* Macroeconomic Shock 2 (Week 20): Introduces real-time price dispersion and artificial search frictions on substitute items to rigorously test the accuracy of the baseline price memory metric $\Delta P_{error}$.
* Hysteresis Decoupling (Weeks 21–24): All machine learning recommendation and automation script executions are terminated on the server for Arms B and C. The application user interface defaults to the unified manual regime (Arm A) to isolate the persistence of cognitive dependencies and evaluate behavioral hysteresis.
4. Data Protection and Anonymization Pipeline
All transaction telemetry and psychometric responses are encrypted in transit and at rest using the AES-256 cryptographic protocol. Direct personal identifiers and device MAC addresses are permanently separated at the registration gateway and replaced by a unique, irreversible alphanumeric hash token. External transactional validation emulates the structure of the Mexican Comprobante Fiscal Digital por Internet (CFDI) to guarantee data validity without storing tax or identity-sensitive information. Upon final data consolidation in December 2026, the master cross-reference identity key will be permanently destroyed under ISO/IEC 27001 compliance guidelines.
Experimental design
This study implements a randomized controlled trial (RCT) with a longitudinal panel design to investigate how different levels of financial technology interaction affect consumer choice, budget allocation, and cognitive financial attention. The experiment is embedded within a customized sandbox mobile fintech application developed in collaboration with the Universidad Autonoma de Aguascalientes (UAA). The sample consists of undergraduate and graduate students who are followed over a multi-week period divided into consecutive measurement waves.
Participants are randomly assigned to one of three balanced parallel experimental arms at the beginning of the study. The first arm, Arm A, serves as the unified manual control group, where users interact with a standard digital wallet interface and must execute all financial planning, expenditure tracking, and transfers manually without any computational assistance or external prompts. The second arm, Arm B, introduces predictive behavioral nudges, where the application platform dynamically modifies the information architecture and deploys personalized, text-based alerts based on the individual's recent multi-period transaction history to guide budgeting decisions. The third arm, Arm C, introduces a high-automation regime, where the application software automatically processes optimal budget allocations, processes pre-scheduled automated savings, and handles micro-purchases based on cash flow constraints, reducing the required manual interaction to a minimum.
The data collection architecture combines high-frequency passive telemetry logged continuously by the application server with primary data from an Experience Sampling Method (ESM) micro-survey infrastructure. The application forces data capture loops at specific transaction points and during scheduled bi-weekly waves. The study incorporates sequential exogenous changes in the application environment to rigorously evaluate consumer resilience, price memory accuracy, and behavioral adjustments. Toward the final stage of the experiment, a decoupling phase is introduced where automated features and nudges are deactivated, reverting all groups to the manual regime. This specific phase isolates the persistence of cognitive dependencies and evaluates whether past interaction with automated financial tools induces behavioral hysteresis once those tools are removed.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.