Generative AI and the Restructuring of Workplace Collaboration

How to cite

Oseguera, Mariana; Stefano, Federica De. 2026. "Generative AI and the Restructuring of Workplace Collaboration." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018958. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18958-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mariana Oseguera* , Federica De Stefano

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018958
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18958-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-15 – 2027-02-28
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18958

Abstract

This study examines how access to generative AI changes the way workers undertake collaborative tasks with peers and supervisors, and the downstream consequences for creative output and learning. In a field experiment crossing team structure (Individual vs. Team) with technology access (No AI vs. AI), we will test how AI access changes (1) the frequency with which workers consult teammates and supervisors, capturing whether they reallocate time toward or away from collaboration; (2) the timing of those consultations within their own work process, revealing whether they brainstorm collaboratively up front or work independently first to avoid collaboration's costs; and (3) the content of collaboration — its frictions and its balance of routine and non-routine cognitive tasks — capturing what collaboration is used for. We will also estimate effects on productivity, output quality, and learning.

Intervention

This is a 2×2 design that crosses team structure (Individual vs. Team) with technology access (No AI vs. AI Access), giving four conditions: Individual with no AI, Individual with AI, Team with no AI, and Team with AI. Our main interest is the effect of AI access within the Team conditions. Within those Team conditions we also randomize the basis of the performance bonus, rewarding workers either on expert ratings of their output or on their collaborator's evaluation. Workers are recruited through Upwork's normal hiring process against set skill and eligibility criteria, complete a real deliverable on a platform we built, and can consult a supervisor who holds firm-specific information. We log all communication and AI use, and independent expert raters evaluate the output.
Beyond the main 2×2 contrast, we will run three secondary analyses. First, supervisor consultation across the AI and No AI conditions, which identifies whether AI substitutes for the firm-specific knowledge the supervisor holds or changes the cost of consulting them (H1, H2). Second, the bonus basis within the Team conditions, which examines whether the return to collaboration drives AI's effect on collaborative behavior, comparing pairs rewarded on their collaborator's evaluation to those rewarded on expert ratings (H1). Third, worker status, which investigates whether AI's effect on collaboration differs across the status distribution (H3), using the baseline characteristics on which we stratify. Because Upwork makes worker ratings and experience public, we have a platform-validated measure of status to draw on here.

Experimental design

This is a 2×2 design that crosses team structure (Individual vs. Team) with technology access (No AI vs. AI Access), giving four conditions: Individual with no AI, Individual with AI, Team with no AI, and Team with AI. Our main interest is the effect of AI access within the Team conditions. Within those Team conditions we also randomize the basis of the performance bonus, rewarding workers either on expert ratings of their output or on their collaborator's evaluation. Workers are recruited through Upwork's normal hiring process against set skill and eligibility criteria, complete a real deliverable on a platform we built, and can consult a supervisor who holds firm-specific information. We log all communication and AI use, and independent expert raters evaluate the output.

Design details

Randomization method
. We sort workers into blocks defined by baseline characteristics we observe before assignment — platform tenure, prior work experience, and demographics — and randomize them to conditions within each block.
Randomization unit
The unit assigned to a condition is the individual worker in the Individual conditions and the worker pair in the Team conditions. The bonus-basis treatment is randomized within the Team conditions at the pair level.
Clusters
About 110 individual workers in the Individual conditions plus 110 worker pairs in the Team conditions — roughly 220 randomized units.
Observations
330 workers: 110 in the Individual conditions and 220 in the Team conditions.
Arms
Individual conditions: about 55 workers with no AI and 55 with AI. Team conditions: about 110 workers (55 pairs) with no AI and 110 workers (55 pairs) with AI, with the bonus-basis treatment randomized within each Team arm.
Primary outcomes
Our main outcomes fall into two groups. The first is how workers collaborate: how often a worker consults peers and the supervisor; when in their process those consultations happen, and the content of the collaboration, both its routine versus non-routine cognitive content and its communicative function. The second is the work itself: the quality, novelty, and firm-specific integration of the output, judged by independent expert raters at the component and the full-deliverable level.
Secondary outcomes
How workers use AI, measured the same way as peer collaboration: the frequency, timing, and content of their AI queries. How often workers consult the supervisor across the AI and No AI conditions. Workers' ratings of their teammate after the task. And post-task self-reports on how they used firm-specific information, whether they found the collaboration and the AI useful, whether they would take on a similar project again, and which working arrangement they would prefer.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords