Parenting styles, subjective beliefs and skill development

How to cite

Aurino, Elisabetta; Egyir, John; Gauthier, Charles; Wolf, Sharon. 2026. "Parenting styles, subjective beliefs and skill development." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018954. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18954-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Elisabetta Aurino* , John Egyir , Charles Gauthier , Sharon Wolf

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018954
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18954-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-02-12 – 2026-07-31
Countries
Ghana (Sub-Saharan Africa)
JEL codes
C91, C93, I21, I24, I30, I38, J24
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18954

Abstract

This study focuses on eliciting caregivers’ beliefs about the technology of skill formation during childhood and adolescence in Ghana. We combine rich longitudinal data from a sample of children exposed to two randomized interventions in early childhood and early adolescence, with a belief elicitation experiment aimed at uncovering parental beliefs regarding the role and timing of investments and parenting styles on child skills formation. The experiment is designed to recover parents’ subjective beliefs about the returns to different inputs, including monetary investments, parenting style, and child's ability. Our design will enable us to quantify belief heterogeneity across caregivers and compare beliefs against actual returns to investments from our longitudinal dataset. In this pre-analysis plan we describe the belief elicitation experiment.

Intervention

We will read different scenarios to describe a hypothetical family with one child of adolescent age to all study participants. For each respondent, the experimental script will vary three inputs for skill development: (i) child initial skill level (high; low); (ii) parental monetary investments in child’s education during early childhood and early adolescence (high; low); and (iii) the parenting style exerted during the same childhood periods (authoritative vs authoritarian). See below for a complete description.

Experimental design

This study combines a belief elicitation experiment (BEE) with longitudinal data to recover caregivers’ subjective beliefs on returns to investments, and compare them to the objective technology of skill formation. The BEE is designed to elicit caregivers’ beliefs about the returns to key inputs in children’s maths development: educational expenditures, parenting styles, and child skills. In addition, the design allows us to study beliefs about the timing of investments by distinguishing between inputs made in early childhood and early adolescence, as well as to assess whether the perceived returns to investments varies across caregivers.

We will assign respondents to four treatment groups. In each arm, belief scenarios will consist of a short description of a hypothetical adolescent child and her parents, followed by a set of situations that vary along three dimensions: the child’s skills, parental monetary investments, and parenting styles. In two treatment arms, parental monetary investment in the child’s education will be fixed at levels made during early childhood (age 5) and adolescence (age 13) (high or low, depending on the arm), with variations in child initial skills and parenting style (as typically exerted at home during the same periods), one at a time. In the other two treatment arms, parenting style exerted during the different periods of childhood will be fixed (authoritarian or authoritative, depending on the arm), while child initial skill level and parental monetary investments (made during the same childhood periods) will vary, one at a time. For each situation, caregivers will be asked to report the age at which they believe the hypothetical adolescent will be able to correctly master two numeracy questions, an intermediate and a more advanced one, which are our marker of maths skill development in adolescence.

Importantly, we can observe the same maths questions object of the BEE as part of our longitudinal data. Indeed, the two questions were chosen as markers of "intermediate" and "more advanced" maths skills by studying their difficulty levels in previous waves of the longitudinal dataset by using item response theory (IRT). Among a pool of potential maths items in this survey, we then picked item that had the desired level of difficulty and that seemed understandable as "intermediate" and "more advanced" by parents in Ghana. To describe the hypothetical child’s initial skill, we use a similar approach, where we describe "a low skills child " as a child that can only solve easy numeracy items at age 5, and "a high skills child" as one that can solve both easy and medium difficulty items at age 5.

We will use the experimental variation embedded in the scenarios to estimate a subjective skill formation function that summarises parents’ beliefs about how inputs translate into child skill development. The experimental design will identify average perceived returns to each input, as well as differences in perceived returns across the different investment periods. As the sample is embedded in a rich panel data, we will use several available information, including the randomised assignment to both early childhood and adolescence interventions, and socioeconomic characteristics (e.g. parental education level), to explore heterogeneity by these characteristics. We will also explore heterogeneity by sex of the hypothetical child in the scenario.

We also aim to shed light on why parents might differ in their beliefs about the productivity of parental investments and parenting styles made during different child periods. To do so, after the BEE, we will administer survey questions about parental beliefs on the malleability of children’s skills and adaptability of parenting styles across child developmental stages. We will use this information to investigate whether perceived returns vary based on the individual responses.

To compare estimated subjective beliefs against the true skill formation process, we will estimate an objective skill formation technology using multiple waves of longitudinal data. We will use comprehensive information collected over time on actual parenting behaviors (to proxy parenting styles) and parental investments. When recovering the parameters of the objective technology of skill formation, we will address endogeneity of parental investments using an instrumental variable and/or control function method (Attanasio, Meghir & Nix, 2020).

Design details

Randomization method
We will implement the randomization procedure using a Stata do-file to ensure reproducibility
Randomization unit
The unit of randomisation will be the individual parent.
Clusters
~2,400 parents (no clustering).
Observations
~2,400 parents.
Arms
The two hypothetical scenarios, each containing two situations will be randomly assigned across four groups of the total sample. This will result in 600 respondents in each treatment arm as follows: Authoritarian-authoritarian: 600 Authoritative-authoritative: 600 Low-low money investment: 600 High-high money investment: 600
Primary outcomes
Primary outcome includes respondents' perceived age for a hypothetical child to be able to master two numeracy tasks corresponding to medium and high difficulty levels of numeracy skills under each of the hypothetical situations. We will use the log of this age as our primary outcome.
Secondary outcomes
N/A
Sponsors
Name: Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Universities Location: Madrid, Spain Url: https://www.ciencia.gob.es Name: European Research Council Location: Bruxelles Url: https://erc.europa.eu/homepage

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords