Do Peers Shape Working Hours Preferences? Evidence from an Information Provision Experiment

How to cite

Hauser, Lea; Cicognani, Simona; Meekes, Jordy. 2026. "Do Peers Shape Working Hours Preferences? Evidence from an Information Provision Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018951. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18951-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lea Hauser* , Simona Cicognani , Jordy Meekes

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018951
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18951-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2026-07-06 – 2026-08-25
Countries
Netherlands ()
JEL codes
C93, D91, J01, J16, J22
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18951

Abstract

Do people adjust how much they want to work when they learn how much their peers work? We run an information provision experiment in the Dutch LISS panel to identify the causal effect of peer information on working hour preferences and decisions. Using administrative data from Statistics Netherlands, we construct accurate, personalised information treatments. Treated respondents learn the average weekly working hours of one of two peer groups: people working in their sector or people living in their neighbourhood who share their gender, age group, education level, and whether they have children under the age of 12. We study whether learning peers' working hours pulls respondents' preferred working hours towards those of their peers, and which peer group matters more in this respect. We also examine how preferences depend on the information itself. We analyse the impact of peers’ working hours on preferred working hours and whether this relationship persists when conditioning on respondents’ prior beliefs about peers’ working hours. We measure immediate effects through survey outcomes collected within the experiment, and medium-run effects by tracking respondents' realised labour market outcomes in later LISS waves and in longitudinal administrative records.

Experimental design

We conduct an individualised information provision experiment within the Dutch LISS panel. Respondents are randomly assigned to one of three possible groups: sector peers treatment group (S), neighbourhood peers treatment group (N), or control group (C).

Part 1:
Respondents report their sector of employment and their own current contracted weekly working hours. Respondents who are currently unemployed but actively seeking work (a small share of the sample) are instead asked to report information about their most recent job and sector. People already in retirement, still in schooling, self employed, or who are unable to work were not invited to the survey experiment.
Respondents in the treatment groups (S and N) are first asked to report their beliefs about the average contracted weekly working hours of their assigned peer group, as well as their expectations about that group's average satisfaction with contracted working hours. They also indicate how confident they are in their estimate of peers' working hours.
To avoid priming, respondents in the control group are initially asked only about their own contracted weekly working hours and sector of employment. They receive the questions on their beliefs about the average contracted weekly working hours of one randomly assigned peer group (half are asked about neighbour half are asked about sector), as well as their expectations about that group's average satisfaction with contracted working hours, only at the end of the questionnaire.

Treatment:
Following Part 1, respondents in S and N are informed about the accurate average weekly working hours of either, their sector or neighbourhood peers. The true answers are shown in comparison to their own guesses and the difference is highlighted.
Respondents in the Control Group receive no information.

Part 2:
Following the treatment, respondents are asked a set of questions that are our main outcome variables. All questions are asked to everyone in the same manner. First we ask about the satisfaction with own working hours. This is followed by information that under the Dutch Flexible Working Act (Wet Flexibel Werken, 2016), employees may request adjustments to their working hours to their employers. After receiving this information we ask about respondents' preferences for weekly working hours, the likelihood that their employer would grant a request to both increase and decrease the working hours, and the most important factors when deciding on working hours.

We invite around 3,000 individuals who are part of the LISS sample and expect a response rate of roughly 70%. Approximately 2,100 (~700 per treatment arm) panel members between the ages 18-67 are invited to respond to our experiment. We exclude individuals in early retirement, individuals who are still in school, individuals who are self-employed, and individuals who are disabled or otherwise not fit for work.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation is done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Randomisation is done at the individual level (every respondent is randomly assigned to one of the three groups)
Clusters
We invite around 3,000 individuals who are part of the LISS sample. We expect a response rate of 70% which would leave us with 2,100 individuals.
Observations
2,100 individuals
Arms
Treatment Group 1 (Sector Peers): 700 individuals Treatment Group 2 (Neighbourhood Peers): 700 individuals Control Group (no treatment): 700 individuals
Primary outcomes
Preferences for weekly working hours (elicited in the survey experiment) Preference convergence
Secondary outcomes
Satisfaction with own working hours (elicited in the survey experiment) Most important factors when deciding on working hours (elicited in the survey experiment) Preference for weekly working hours (follow-up waves of LISS) Short-term change in preferences (described below) Medium-term change in preferences (described below) Observed weekly working hours (administrative records and follow-up waves of LISS)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords