Government Scheme Overload: Take-Up and Targeting in a Multi-Scheme Context
How to cite
Mathur, Mitali. 2026. "Government Scheme Overload: Take-Up and Targeting in a Multi-Scheme Context." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018937. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18937-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Developing countries are often faced with a dilemma: governments offer a variety of social protection policies to people in need, but the rates at which individuals take-up these programs are low. While researchers have studied interventions meant to improve the take-up of specific welfare programs, little is known about how individuals navigate the entire basket of welfare policies and decide how many and which ones to apply to. I implement a randomized controlled trial that experimentally varies the quantity and quality of information about benefits offered to informal workers who are eligible for multiple programs. I vary quantity through different presentation formats (information load) by varying whether or not citizens learn about one scheme at a time with opt-in continuation versus all eligible schemes at once. I vary quality through sharing information about random or recommended schemes. My research emphasizes the importance of studying social protection schemes more comprehensively and highlights that one major bottleneck to take-up is not simply a lack of awareness, but a complexity in navigating the quantity of potential schemes.
Intervention
I implement a randomized experiment that varies the quantity and quality of information shared to potential beneficiaries about up to 15 priority social protection schemes. In the status quo, frontline workers approach individuals in communities, ask a series of demographic questions to understand their scheme eligibility, then provide individuals with information on the programs they are eligible for. This process is currently ad hoc and varies by frontline worker. My intervention involves testing different information sharing protocols frontline workers follow in the information sharing stage.
I vary quantity through the sequencing and presentation of information. Specifically, I vary whether or not citizens learn about one scheme at a time with opt-in continuation versus all eligible schemes at once. I vary quality by sharing information about random or recommended schemes. Taken together, I define three intervention arms: a single-random scheme arm, a single-recommended scheme arm, and a multiple scheme arm.
Experimental design
- Arm 1: Single-random scheme - Frontline workers approach a citizen, introduce themselves, introduce Haqdarshak, and offer to help connect citizens with social protection schemes. Once citizens consent, frontline workers ask citizens a series of demographic questions and fill out a mobile application. The mobile application then identifies which schemes the citizen is eligible for. For each citizen interaction, frontline workers receive the list of schemes in a randomized order. Frontline workers share information about the first scheme on the list the citizen is eligible for: the scheme's benefits, the documentation required to apply, and the steps required. If the citizen is interested in the scheme, the frontline worker assists them in their application. The citizen can apply ``on-the-spot'' if they have the relevant documentation with them, or they can coordinate another time to meet with the frontline worker and apply. After applying for the first scheme, frontline workers ask the citizen if they would like to learn about another scheme. If citizens are interested, the frontline worker shares information about the next eligible scheme. In this way, frontline workers share information on eligible schemes sequentially instead of all at once.
- Arm 2: Single-recommended scheme - Frontline workers follow similar protocols to Arm 1, except instead of providing information on a random scheme, they provide information on a scheme they recommend. Frontline workers leverage their expertise and have autonomy to provide information on the single ``best'' scheme per interaction.
- Arm 3: Multiple schemes - Frontline workers approach and interact with citizens in a similar manner as in other arms. However, instead of sharing information on schemes sequentially, they share information on all 15 priority schemes the citizen is eligible for at once. This means citizens may receive information on up to 15 schemes. The order of the schemes shared is random for each citizen.
Across Arm 1 and Arm 2, the quantity of schemes shared is fixed (one scheme per interaction), but the quality of the scheme shared differs. Differences between these groups in terms of the quantity of schemes applied to highlight the effect of availing schemes with a high net value. Across Arm 1 and Arm 3, the quality of schemes shared is fixed via random ordering, but the quantity of schemes shared differs. Differences between these groups in terms of the quality of schemes applied to highlight how complexity (proxied by information quantity) impacts take-up.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.