Market-based approaches to promoting cool roofs in India: The effects of demonstration roofs and household education-entertainment on willingness-to-pay for cool roofs
How to cite
Grimm, Michael; Fritz, Manuela. 2026. "Market-based approaches to promoting cool roofs in India: The effects of demonstration roofs and household education-entertainment on willingness-to-pay for cool roofs." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018897. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18897-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Climate change is increasing the frequency and intensity of heatwaves. In India, where temperatures and levels of humidity reach extreme levels during the summer, heatwaves pose significant threats to physical and mental health. Low-income urban neighborhoods are particularly vulnerable, as residents have limited access to active cooling such as air conditioning or well-ventilated housing. Cool roofs, i.e. roofs coated with a white, sunlight-reflective paint, have been shown to reduce indoor temperatures by up to 4-5°C and represent a promising low-cost solution to reduce indoor heat exposure.
This study measures the willingness-to-pay (WTP) for cool roofs among households in poor urban neighborhoods in Ahmedabad, India, using an incentive-compatible elicitation method in a context where the technology is offered at a subsidized market price. We additionally test the effect of three randomized treatments on WTP: an education-entertainment video explaining the benefits and functioning of cool roofs, a demonstration cool roof installed in the study wards, and a combination of both. The study is designed to inform local authorities about the subsidy levels required for broader scaling of cool roofs and about the most effective measures for increasing their uptake. The findings are expected to have relevance beyond the study location, particularly for similarly hot and low-income urban settings, and to contribute to an academic and policy literature in which cool roof adoption behavior remains understudied.
Intervention
This study investigates the potential for market-based scaling of cool roof technology in low-income urban neighborhoods in Ahmedabad. We combine an incentive-compatible WTP elicitation with three randomized treatment arms to assess whether providing additional interventions about cool roofs can increase households’ WTP.
Cool roofs are roofs that are coated with a white, sunlight-reflective paint that has been shown to reduce indoor building temperatures by up to 4-5°C (Kolokotroni et al., 2018). Unlike active cooling solutions such as air conditioning, cool roofs require no sustained energy input and only minimal maintenance, making them particularly suitable for low-income households facing unreliable electricity supply and financial constraints. Beyond direct thermal comfort and health benefits, cool roofs can reduce building energy consumption and contribute to mitigating the urban heat island effect (Broadbent et al., 2022; Santamouris, 2014). Despite their potential for reducing indoor ambient temperature, residential adoption in Indian cities relies primarily on NGO-led programs providing the coating free of charge (Akbari et al., 2011; Bunker et al., 2024; Natural Resources Defense Council, 2019, 2022; Mahila Housing Trust, 2024). This study examines whether and under what conditions households are willing to invest in the technology.
To measure household WTP, we employ the Becker-DeGroot-Marschak (BDM) mechanism, an incentive-compatible elicitation method in which respondents state their maximum willingness to pay for the cool roof coating offered at a subsidized price. A binding price is then drawn randomly from a pre-specified distribution: if the stated WTP equals or exceeds the drawn price, the household receives the product at that price; otherwise, no transaction takes place. The BDM mechanism incentivizes truthful revelation of preferences, as strategic misreporting cannot improve the respondent’s outcome. Within our study, the technology is offered at a subsidized market price, reflecting the study’s goal of informing realistic subsidy policies rather than measuring demand at full cost.
To test whether scalable, low-cost interventions can increase household WTP, participants are randomly assigned to one of four conditions: a control group and three treatment arms.
Participants in all four groups will first be invited to participate in a standardized community-based information session, in which the cool roof technology will be introduced. These sessions will focus on the basic functioning of cool roofs. Conducting such an information session before the actual WTP experiment is essential in a context where many participants might have never heard before of the product and would hence not be able to make an informed bid within the context of a WTP experiment.
In addition to the community-based information session, individuals are assigned to one of three treatment arms, thus receiving one of the following interventions:
Treatment 1 – Household education-entertainment video: Households in this arm are shown a short animated video of approximately 1.5 minutes. The video will be shown to the participants on tablets during the information session. The video explains the functioning of cool roofs and communicates the associated health and co-benefits. The video is also designed to be easily replicable and scalable. Informational interventions of this type have been shown to change behavior in similar contexts and might also be able to shift technology adoption (Grady, 2021).
Treatment 2 – Community Demonstration: In selected wards, a demonstration cool roof is installed on a building accessible to the local community. Residents are able to visit the site, observe the coating directly, touch the surface, and enter the building to experience the temperature difference firsthand. This experiential exposure addresses a key barrier to adoption identified in the literature, namely limited familiarity with and trust in new building technologies. The demonstration roof thus provides tangible, locally anchored evidence of the technology’s performance.
Treatment 3 – Combined Intervention: A third group of households receives both the household education-entertainment video and community demonstration. This arm allows us to test whether the two interventions are complementary and whether their combined effect on WTP exceeds that of either component alone.
Surrounding the quantitative experiment, an extensive qualitative research program explores both demand- and supply-side factors shaping cool roof adoption. This includes stakeholder interviews with government officials, community leaders, and cool roof producers/vendors, and focus group discussion to investigate household perceptions, decision-making processes, and barriers to adoption. The qualitative findings informed the design of the interventions and will be used to interpret the quantitative results, enabling a comprehensive assessment of the conditions under which market-based scaling of cool roof technology is feasible in Ahmedabad and comparable urban settings.
Experimental design
The study consists of a cluster-randomized controlled trial (cRCT) with a factorial design aiming to elicit households’ WTP for sunlight-reflective cool roof coatings. The trial encompasses a total of 1,200 households residing across four administrative zones in Ahmedabad (Central, North, East, and South). In each zone, two wards are selected through non-random sampling. Within each ward, three information sessions will be held with approximately 50 households attending each session, yielding 300 households per zone. Information sessions will be widely advertised. In cases where fewer than 50 households attend, additional households residing in the same ward are recruited via a simple random-walk procedure.
Within each of the zones, we will randomly select one of the two wards for the installation of the demonstration roofs. All community demonstration cool roofs are installed prior to or shortly after the information sessions. Within wards, assignment to the education-entertainment video treatment is randomized at the information-session level, such that each zone contains three sessions with and three sessions without the education-entertainment video treatment. Across zones, randomization is stratified such that a total of six sessions receive both the education-entertainment video treatment and a community demonstration of cool roof in the corresponding ward. This design ensures that each treatment arm comprises two wards, six sessions, and 300 households.
All 1,200 households will be invited to participate in the WTP experiment approximately 1-2 weeks after the information session. The timing between the information session and the actual WTP experiment allows households to reflect on their WTP and, where applicable, to discuss it with other decision-makers in the household prior to the experiment. This preparatory step is intended to promote informed decision-making and to reduce the likelihood that participants submit bids they subsequently regret or are unable to honor.
Due to local governmental restrictions aiming to mitigate social tensions, prices will be drawn from a narrow distribution, and the same price will be drawn for all households participating in the study. Prices do, however, vary by roof size, with three categories distinguished: small, medium, and large. The pricing structure will be explained both during the information session and again immediately before participants are invited to submit their bids. Participants will also complete a practice round to ensure comprehension of the procedure, using an umbrella as the trial product. To fulfil the government restriction while simultaneously ensuring study integrity (i.e. that the drawn price remains unknown to all study participants), the random price will be drawn once the data collection is completed across all wards. Hence, about 3-4 weeks after the WTP elicitation, the study team will revisit all households and announce the final price. At this stage, households that successfully complete the WTP experiment will sign a contract and make an advance payment of INR 100. The remaining balance will be due upon completion of the roof coating and paid directly to the painting agency. The final roof coating will take place immediately after the monsoon period ends (October, November 2026).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.