Testing Narrative Models in the Field: Domestic Violence, Donations, and Cross-Cultural Persuasion

How to cite

Hakimov, Rustamdjan; Wang, Stephanie; Mechtenberg, Lydia; Adena, Maja; Hager, Anselm. 2026. "Testing Narrative Models in the Field: Domestic Violence, Donations, and Cross-Cultural Persuasion." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018896. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18896-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Rustamdjan Hakimov* , Stephanie Wang , Lydia Mechtenberg , Maja Adena , Anselm Hager

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018896
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18896-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-09-01 – 2026-11-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18896

Abstract

We study whether different narratives about an NGO’s domestic violence initiative
influence individual and collective decision-making. In a field experiment with 3,060
rural women in Kyrgyzstan and a complementary online experiment with 3,000 U.S.-
based women, participants are randomly assigned to one of three video treatments.
All videos present identical factual content about the NGO’s legal-aid and gendernorm
programs but differ in their interpretation of the same evidence: the baseline
video simply portrays factual evidence without drawing inferences; the optimism-based
“easy-fix” narrative frames gender-norm change as a scalable solution based on crosscountry
correlations (Eliaz and Spiegler, 2020); the data-driven “overfitting” narrative
suggests historical program effectiveness through temporal correlations (Schwartzstein
and Sunderam, 2021). Primary outcomes are individual donations in both experiments
and treatment-congruent narrative endorsement. We additionally record and
code structured group discussions and measure pre- and post-discussion proposals over
group donations. The design provides a first field test of two leading economic theories
of narrative persuasion and examines how local versus external audience context
shapes the effectiveness of alternative narratives.

Intervention

Participants are randomly assigned to one of three video messages about the Solidarity Bus, an NGO initiative in Kyrgyzstan that supports women facing domestic violence through legal assistance and activities aimed at changing gender norms. The videos are approximately four minutes long and are matched in narrator, structure, tone, graphics, music, length, and underlying factual information. All videos describe the NGO’s work since 2016, present information on reported domestic-violence cases in Kyrgyzstan, show cross-country evidence on the association between gender norms and domestic violence, and end with the same donation appeal.
The intervention varies only the interpretive frame used to present the same underlying facts. The Baseline video provides a descriptive informational message about the NGO’s legal-support activities and gender-norm programming, without drawing strong causal conclusions from the evidence. The Easy-Fix video emphasizes the gender-norm component of the NGO’s work and frames changing attitudes toward women’s roles as a relatively simple, scalable, and effective way to reduce domestic violence. The Overfitting video emphasizes the legal-support component and interprets temporal patterns in reported domestic-violence cases as suggestive evidence that expansions and reforms of the NGO’s legal-aid activities have contributed to reductions in reported violence.
In the Kyrgyzstan field experiment, adult women in rural villages first complete a baseline survey and make an incentivized baseline donation decision. They then view one of the three randomly assigned videos and complete a post-video survey including a second incentivized donation decision, questions on their interpretation of the NGO’s work, and a measure of willingness to share a donation appeal. After the individual part of the study, participants are reassigned to small deliberation groups with randomly varied treatment composition. Each participant proposes a group donation before and after a structured discussion, and discussions are recorded for later coding of the arguments used.
In the U.S. online experiment, adult women recruited through Prolific are randomly assigned to view one of the same three video messages. After watching the assigned video, participants make an incentivized donation decision from a bonus payment and answer questions about their interpretation of the NGO’s work. The U.S. study uses the same treatment arms as the Kyrgyzstan field experiment but does not include the group-deliberation component.

Experimental design

The study consists of two parallel randomized experiments evaluating how alternative video messages about an NGO initiative against domestic violence affect support for the organization.

The first experiment is a field experiment with adult women in rural Kyrgyzstan. Community meetings are organized in participating villages. After consent, participants complete a short baseline survey and make an incentivized baseline donation decision. Participants are then individually randomized within village to one of three video messages about the Solidarity Bus, an NGO program that provides legal assistance to women facing domestic violence and conducts activities aimed at changing gender norms. The three videos contain the same underlying factual information and the same donation appeal, but differ in how the evidence is interpreted. After watching the assigned video, participants complete a post-video survey and make a second incentivized donation decision.

The Kyrgyzstan field experiment also includes a group-deliberation component. After the individual post-video survey, participants are reassigned to small discussion groups with randomly varied composition based on the video messages previously viewed by group members. Each participant proposes how much of a group endowment should be donated to the NGO before discussion and again after discussion. Groups then participate in a structured discussion about whether and why to donate. Discussions are recorded and later coded using a pre-specified codebook.

The second experiment is an online experiment with adult women residing in the United States and recruited through Prolific. Participants are individually randomized to one of the same three video messages. After viewing the assigned video, they make an incentivized donation decision from a bonus payment and answer a short survey about their interpretation of the NGO’s work. The U.S. experiment uses the same treatment arms as the Kyrgyzstan individual-level experiment but does not include the group-deliberation component.

The design allows us to compare the effect of alternative interpretations of the same factual information on individual giving, narrative endorsement, diffusion behavior, and, in Kyrgyzstan, collective discussion and proposed group donations.

Design details

Randomization method
In the Kyrgyzstan field experiment, treatment assignment is randomized at the individual level within each village. Upon arrival at the community meeting, eligible consenting participants draw numbered tokens under researcher supervision. The token determines assignment to one of the three video treatments with equal probability: Baseline, Easy-Fix, or Overfitting. Randomization therefore occurs publicly on site within each village. For the group-deliberation phase in Kyrgyzstan, participants are reassigned after the individual post-treatment survey to discussion groups using a pre-specified randomized assignment procedure. Group composition is randomly varied so that some groups are mostly composed of participants previously assigned to Baseline, some mostly of participants previously assigned to Easy-Fix, and some mostly of participants previously assigned to Overfitting. In the U.S. online experiment, participants recruited through Prolific are individually randomized by the survey software to one of the three video treatments with equal probability.
Randomization unit
individual
Clusters
The Kyrgyzstan field experiment will be conducted in approximately 150 villages. Treatment is randomized at the individual level within villages, but standard errors will be clustered at the village level. The U.S. online experiment has no geographic or institutional clusters; treatment is randomized at the individual participant level.
Observations
The planned sample consists of 3,060 adult women in the Kyrgyzstan field experiment and 3,000 adult women in the U.S. online experiment, for a total planned sample of 6,060 individual participants. In Kyrgyzstan, the 3,060 participants will be recruited across approximately 150 rural villages. The group-deliberation phase is expected to generate approximately 300 discussion groups. In the U.S. online experiment, the 3,000 participants will be recruited through Prolific and randomized at the individual level.
Arms
In the Kyrgyzstan field experiment, the planned sample is 3,060 adult women randomized with equal probability across three treatment arms: Baseline: approximately 1,020 participants Easy-Fix: approximately 1,020 participants Overfitting: approximately 1,020 participants These participants will be recruited across approximately 150 rural villages. Treatment is randomized at the individual level within villages. In the U.S. online experiment, the planned sample is 3,000 adult women randomized with equal probability across the same three treatment arms: Baseline: approximately 1,000 participants Easy-Fix: approximately 1,000 participants Overfitting: approximately 1,000 participants Overall planned sample by treatment arm across both experiments: Baseline: approximately 2,020 participants Easy-Fix: approximately 2,020 participants Overfitting: approximately 2,020 participants
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are measured after exposure to the assigned video treatment. In both the Kyrgyzstan field experiment and the U.S. online experiment, the main primary outcomes are: Individual donation amount. In Kyrgyzstan, this is the amount, from 0 to 400 KGS, that the participant chooses to donate to the Solidarity Bus in the post-video incentivized donation decision. In the U.S. online experiment, this is the amount, from £0 to £3, that the participant chooses to donate from her bonus payment. Treatment-congruent narrative endorsement. This is an indicator equal to one if the participant selects the interpretation of the Solidarity Bus that corresponds to the narrative emphasized in her assigned treatment, and zero otherwise. For the Overfitting treatment, the congruent interpretation is that the NGO has shown that legal support can reduce violence. For the Easy-Fix treatment, the congruent interpretation is that the NGO has found a relatively quick way to reduce violence by changing gender norms. For the Baseline treatment, the congruent interpretation is that the NGO is making efforts to reduce violence but that results are still uncertain. In the Kyrgyzstan field experiment, we additionally define the following primary endpoint: Verified WhatsApp sharing of the donation appeal. This is an indicator equal to one if the participant actually posts the donation appeal as a WhatsApp status and the posting is verified by a facilitator, and zero otherwise. These are 3 main outcomes for Kyrgyzstan experiment. For the Kyrgyzstan group-deliberation phase, the primary endpoints are: Individual proposed group donation before and after discussion. Each participant proposes how much of the group endowment should be donated to the Solidarity Bus before the structured group discussion and again after the discussion. Narrative content of group discussions. Video-recorded group discussions are transcribed and coded using a pre-specified codebook. The main group-level endpoints are the share of coded statements aligned with each narrative category—Overfitting, Easy-Fix, or Baseline/uncertainty—and indicators for whether a given narrative category is dominant in the discussion.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords