A National Survey of State Legislators' Views on Health Infrastructure
How to cite
Huynh, Johnny.
2026. "A National Survey of State Legislators' Views on Health Infrastructure." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018876.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18876-1.0
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
This study will develop and administer a survey of state legislators about health infrastructure, rural health care access, and related policy issues. The study will describe legislators’ views and test how incentives, follow-up efforts, and question framing affect survey responses. It will also examine how legislators' responses relate to health-related characteristics of the districts they represent.
Intervention
Legislators will be assigned to different compensation amounts for completing the survey and to different follow-up protocols, ranging from no reminder to multiple reminder emails and, for some, a phone call. Respondents will also be assigned to one of four messages about health infrastructure that vary the argument presented and the information source. These interventions will be used to study survey participation, nonresponse bias, and how message framing affects legislators' views.
Experimental design
This study is a randomized survey experiment of U.S. state legislators. Legislators will be randomly assigned to different survey outreach strategies that vary compensation and follow-up intensity. Respondents will also be randomly assigned to brief informational messages about rural hospital challenges. The study will estimate how outreach strategies affect survey participation, whether harder-to-reach respondents differ from other respondents, and how different messages affect views on rural health infrastructure.
Design details
Randomization method
Randomization will be conducted by computer using reproducible Stata code. Compensation amount and follow-up intensity will be randomized separately within state-party strata. The vignette experiment will be randomized by computer within the survey platform or pre-assigned in the contact-level randomization file.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual state legislator. Compensation amount and follow-up intensity are randomized at the individual-legislator level. Among survey respondents, vignette assignment is also randomized at the individual level.
Clusters
Approximately 7,000 individual state legislators. Because treatment is not clustered, the number of randomized units is the same as the number of planned observations.
Observations
Approximately 7,000 state legislators.
Arms
Approximately 7,000 state legislators will be randomized.
Compensation arms:
$0: approximately 1,400 legislators
$25: approximately 1,400 legislators
$50: approximately 1,400 legislators
$75: approximately 1,400 legislators
$100: approximately 1,400 legislators
Follow-up arms:
No follow-up email: approximately 1,680 legislators
One follow-up email: approximately 1,680 legislators
Two follow-up emails: approximately 1,680 legislators
Three follow-up emails: approximately 1,680 legislators
Three follow-up emails plus one phone call: approximately 280 legislators
Vignette arms among respondents:
Access argument from a news source: approximately 25% of respondents
Access argument from a university source: approximately 25% of respondents
Economic argument from a news source: approximately 25% of respondents
Economic argument from a university source: approximately 25% of respondents
The survey will be fielded in three waves: an initial pilot wave of approximately 100 legislators, a second wave of approximately 2,000 legislators, and a final wave consisting of the remaining sampled legislators, subject to financial constraints.
Primary outcomes
Survey completion.
Priority assigned to subsidizing struggling rural hospitals relative to other state priorities.
Support for subsidizing struggling rural hospitals if doing so required raising taxes.
Preferred targeting of rural hospital subsidies.
Perceived persuasiveness of arguments for and against subsidies for rural hospitals.
Secondary outcomes
Partial survey completion.
Time to response.
Item nonresponse.
Survey completion time.
Ranking of health care, state budget deficits, public safety, economic opportunities, and rural quality of life as state priorities.
Perceived health of district residents relative to the nation.
Perceived adequacy of district health infrastructure.
Beliefs about hospital financial challenges in the district.
Familiarity with the Rural Health Transformation Program.
Rural health infrastructure funding priorities.
Views of Medicaid and state responses to potential federal Medicaid cuts.
Trust in and reliance on different information sources.
Preferred types of evidence for health infrastructure decisions.
Nonresponse-adjusted estimates of survey means and vignette treatment effects.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.