State-card readability under tricolor priming: an equivalence test

How to cite

Duque, Mauricio Fernandez. 2026. "State-card readability under tricolor priming: an equivalence test." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018838. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18838-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mauricio Fernandez Duque*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018838
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18838-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-05-06 – 2026-10-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C93 (Field Experiments); D91 (Behavioral); Z13 (Cultural Economics)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18838

Abstract

We test whether the inclusion of the Mexican flag tricolor (red/white/green) in a visual card depicting a beneficiary state affects participants' subsequent memory of which state the card depicted. The intervention is a 10-second exposure to one of 12 cards (6 Mexican states x 2 versions: tricolor styling vs. teal styling, applied to the card border and to the donor-state name) presented within a brief in-person survey administered on participants' own devices. The hypothesis under test is one of **equivalence**: flag exposure does not impair state retention relative to neutral exposure within a margin of plus-or-minus 10 percentage points. The primary outcome is whether the participant correctly identifies the donor state by either open-ended recall or multiple-choice recognition. The study responds to a referee concern on a manuscript that draws from an earlier study (AEARCTR-0005236). The sample is 200 participants (100 per arm) recruited from undergraduate populations at four Mexico City universities (CIDE, ITAM, Ibero, possibly Anahuac del Sur). Primary inference is by two one-sided test (TOST) for equivalence on the flag-minus-neutral difference of proportions, requiring the Newcombe 90% confidence interval to fall entirely within the plus-or-minus 10 pp band. A small calibration pilot (N approximately 30, May 2026) informed the power calculation; pilot data are not included in the registered analysis.

Intervention

Participants take a brief (approximately 5-minute) survey administered via oTree on their own devices, in person, in a classroom setting at one of four Mexico City universities (CIDE, ITAM, Ibero, possibly Anahuac del Sur).

Experimental design

Two-arm between-subject randomized controlled trial. Individual-level random assignment. No clustering. Fixed-N, no peeking.

Design details

Randomization method
At-individual level, deterministic per participant from the anonymous participation code: the code is hashed to a 64-bit integer and used to seed the choice of arm, the choice of beneficiary state from the 6-state pool, the bonus-question draw, and the per-participant shuffle of the 6-alternative forced choice recognition options. Reproducibility from the saved code is exact.
Randomization unit
University affiliates (students and staff)
Clusters
Not applicable
Observations
200 university affiliates (students and staff) total. Fixed-N, no peeking.
Arms
100 per arm
Primary outcomes
`state_memory_either` -- a binary indicator equal to 1 if the participant correctly identifies the donor state via either open-ended recall (Screen 6) or 6-alternative forced choice recognition (Screen 7), and 0 otherwise.
Secondary outcomes
Primary outcome components (reported alongside the primary) - `recall_state_correct` -- open-ended free recall of the donor state (Screen 6), scored with a fuzzy canonical-name match (Levenshtein-tolerant against the canonical Spanish state name). - `state_recognition_correct` -- 6-alternative forced choice recognition of the donor state from a fixed list of six Mexican states with per-participant shuffle (Screen 7). Additional measured outcomes The below outcome is part of the instrument by design. It is reported descriptively -- per-arm rates and a companion two-proportion test -- for transparency about the data collected. It is not pre-committed gates on H1: the verdict on the readability confound is not conditioned on any of these outcomes. - `org_recall_correct` -- open-ended free recall of the donor organization shown on the card (Screen 5). Also serves as the buffer task between the card exposure and the state-recall question.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords