The Feedback Fallacy: Praise, Criticism, and Regression to the Mean
How to cite
Myachenkova, Yana; Suvorov, Anton; Belianin, Alexis; Ven, Jeroen van de.
2026. "The Feedback Fallacy: Praise, Criticism, and Regression to the Mean." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018837.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18837-1.0
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
Yana Myachenkova*
, Anton Suvorov
, Alexis Belianin
, Jeroen van de Ven
Does positive feedback boost effort, or does it lead to disappointment when performance regresses to the mean? Kahneman and Tversky (1973) argued that feedback providers - managers, teachers, parents - systematically misjudge the effectiveness of praise and criticism because they fail to account for natural mean reversion in performance. We design a laboratory experiment in a principal-agent environment to test how principals' feedback decisions are shaped by accumulated experience with prior feedback outcomes, and how those decisions in turn affect agents' effort.
Intervention
Participants in the role of principal observe an agent's interim performance on a task and may send a verifiable feedback message. Agents subsequently choose effort for a final stage.
Experimental design
Computerized laboratory experiment using a principal-agent design with 20 rounds and stranger matching. Participants are randomly assigned to fixed roles (principal or agent) at the session start. In each round, principals observe an agent's interim performance on a two-stage task and may send a verifiable feedback message before the agent chooses effort for the final stage. Sessions are conducted at the BELA laboratory at NES.
Design details
Randomization method
Random assignment by the z-Tree software at the session start (for role assignment) and at the start of each round (for pair rematching).
Randomization unit
Individual within session for role assignment (principal vs. agent); pair-level for stranger matching across rounds. All participants within a session are exposed to the same procedure.
Clusters
4-6 experimental sessions
Observations
70-100 participants (35-50 principals, 35-50 agents); 20 rounds per participant, generating 1400-2000 round-level observations per role
Arms
Not applicable: the study does not use between-subjects treatment arms. All participants experience the same protocol; variation in feedback received by agents is generated endogenously by principals' decisions conditional on observed outcomes.
Primary outcomes
Principal's binary message choice conditional on a high first-stage outcome (Well Done vs. no message), modeled as a function of cumulative prior disappointing experience with praise.
Secondary outcomes
Agent's second-stage effort, modeled as a function of received feedback message and first-stage effort.
Frequency of performance reversion: proportion of cases in which a high first-stage outcome is followed by a non-high second-stage outcome, and proportion of cases in which a low first-stage outcome is followed by a non-low second-stage outcome.
Principal's binary message choice conditional on a low first-stage outcome (Not Good Enough vs. no message), as a function of cumulative prior encouraging experience with criticism.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.