Enabling Access to Free Higher Education in Bogotá through Personalized Admission Chances on Atenea (2026–2027)

How to cite

Neilson, Christopher; Zarate, Roman. 2026. "Enabling Access to Free Higher Education in Bogotá through Personalized Admission Chances on Atenea (2026–2027)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018833. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18833-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Christopher Neilson* , Roman Zarate

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018833
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18833-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2026-06-03 – 2026-06-10
Countries
Colombia (Bogota)
JEL codes
I23, I24, D83, D47, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18833

Abstract

Bogotá’s Atenea platform centrally assigns applicants to publicly funded higher-education programs: a placement provides tuition-free access, so admission chances reflect access to free college and major options. Each year tens of thousands of applicants rank up to three programs, yet many eligible applicants are not assigned, and many have application portfolios that contain only high-risk options while omitting feasible alternatives. While this might be optimal behavior, it might be a mistake if applicants are not informed of their admissions chances when constructing their application portfolio.

We implement and evaluate a personalized “smart platform” intervention that displays simulated admission probabilities on program pages, portfolio risk warnings before submission, and up to three recommended programs drawn from the applicant’s feasible set. A three-arm individually randomized trial (control, widget only, widget plus pre-submission report) assigns applicants at first login; within the full-treatment arm, a nested experiment varies recommendation algorithms and presentation order. Primary outcomes follow the causal chain from list editing to ex-ante portfolio safety and match quality to realized assignment to the first preference; secondary outcomes include non-assignment and time-to-assignment. The pre-registered analysis uses intent-to-treat regressions with covariate adjustment and Holm–Bonferroni correction across primary outcomes. The study is powered for modest effects on editing, portfolio risk, and first-choice assignment using prior-cycle data from approximately 32,000 applicants. Results will inform whether real-time admission chances on a government assignment platform improve equitable access to free higher education in Bogotá.

Intervention

We implement a personalized information-and-recommendation intervention integrated into Atenea's centralized higher-education assignment platform in Bogotá, Colombia, where applicants submit a rank-ordered list (ROL) of up to three programs and a placement bundles the seat with a full subsidy. The intervention has two components: (i) a risk widget shown on each program page that displays the applicant's estimated admission probability and waitlist/priority position; and (ii) a pre-submission popup that displays personalized admission probabilities for each listed option, message-flag warnings when the portfolio is risky (e.g., no safe option, over-concentration in highly competitive programs), and up to three recommended alternative programs with one-click links to add them. Applicants are randomized into three arms (Control / Widget / Widget+Popup). The goal is to improve the feasibility and quality of submitted lists, reduce non-assignment and improve college persistence at t+1.

Experimental design

A three-arm individual-level randomized controlled trial on Atenea's centralized assignment platform in Bogotá, with 1:1:1 allocation to Control, Widget, and Widget+Popup. Randomization is server-side with rolling (just-in-time) assignment the first time an applicant logs in. The primary estimand is the Intention-to-Treat (ITT) effect, estimated by OLS of each outcome on arm indicators with baseline covariates (ICFES/Saber-11 score and sex) for precision and HC1 robust standard errors; family-wise error across the four primary outcomes is controlled via Holm–Bonferroni. A nested experiment within the Widget+Popup arm independently randomizes the recommendation algorithm (3 sub-arms) and presentation order (2 sub-arms).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by computer. Server-side randomization module assigns each applicant on first login via an independent uniform pseudo-random draw, with equal (1/3) probability across the three arms (rolling/just-in-time assignment; assignment is persisted and never re-drawn). Within the Widget+Popup arm, the recommendation algorithm is assigned by an independent uniform 1/3 draw and the presentation order by an independent 50/50 draw.
Randomization unit
Individual applicant. (Two nested sub-randomizations — recommendation algorithm and presentation order — are also at the individual level, within the Widget+Popup arm.)
Clusters
Not applicable. individual-level randomization (no clusters). Equivalently, the unit count equals the number of individually-randomized applicants (≈ 32,000; see below).
Observations
≈ 32,000 applicants (power calibrated on the JE4 Bogotá applicant cohort, N = 32,306). Enrollment is rolling over the application cycle
Arms
Three arms, equal allocation: ≈ 10,769 Control / ≈ 10,769 Widget / ≈ 10,768 Widget+Popup (Monte Carlo balance design, N = 32,306). Nested experiment within Widget+Popup (n ≈ 10,800): recommendation algorithm ≈ 3,590 per sub-arm (random / heuristic / model); presentation order ≈ 5,385 per sub-arm (probability-ordered / random).
Primary outcomes
Following the intervention's causal chain (behavioral response → ex-ante portfolio quality → realized assignment): P1) Portfolio edited: indicator for any change (add/drop/replace/reorder) between the applicant's first recorded list and final submission (first-stage behavioral response). P2) Δ Portfolio risk: change in probability of non-assignment, risk = ∏ₖ(1−pₖ); negative = safer portfolio. P3) Δ Ex-ante probability of first-choice assignment: change in simulated probability of assignment to the top-ranked program. P4) Assignment to first preference (realized): indicator for being assigned to the first-ranked option at the end of the cycle.
Secondary outcomes
Realized non-assignment and time-to-assignment (days, incl. waitlist dynamics); Δ ex-ante probability of assignment to any listed program and Δ expected rank of the assigned program; portfolio composition/safety (number of feasible options listed [adm. prob. > 10% floor], indicator for listing ≥1 such "safe" option, list size, distance to program, program type); adoption of recommendations (share of recommended programs in the final but not the pre-exposure list); assignment from waitlist vs. directly from the mechanism; program-level aggregates (mean priority index of offered students, rejection rate, waitlist cutoff, unfilled seats); and, among matriculants, dropout at t+1 and match-quality proxies (distance, field affinity, percentile relative to cutoff). Nested-experiment outcomes (within Widget+Popup, separate multiple-testing family): R1, recommendation adopted (indicator for adding ≥1 recommended program to the final list); R2, Δ Portfolio risk (as P2), compared across recommendation algorithms.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords