Clarifying Information and Initial Behavioral Responses: A Cluster-Randomized Field Experiment on Encouraging Sewer Connections

How to cite

Satoh, Eiji. 2026. "Clarifying Information and Initial Behavioral Responses: A Cluster-Randomized Field Experiment on Encouraging Sewer Connections." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018827. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18827-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Eiji Satoh*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018827
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18827-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2026-04-01 – 2027-12-31
Countries
Japan (Date City, Fukushima Prefecture)
JEL codes
C93; L95; H41; D83; Q58
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18827

Abstract

This study evaluates whether a low-cost information-clarification intervention can increase initial behavioral responses among households that remain unconnected to the public sewer system in Date City, Fukushima Prefecture. The intervention consists of a sewer connection encouragement leaflet inserted into the municipal newsletter. The leaflet clarifies where households can seek consultation, what they can learn through consultation, and how they can take the first step without committing immediately to construction. The study is implemented as a phased-in cluster-randomized controlled trial. Constructed clusters of administrative aza units are randomly assigned to either a first-wave group receiving the leaflet through the July 2026 municipal newsletter or a second-wave group receiving the leaflet through the October 2026 municipal newsletter. The primary outcome is whether a household has any sewer-related consultation or inquiry in a household-by-month panel. The primary analysis estimates the intention-to-treat effect using a linear probability model with cluster fixed effects and month fixed effects, with inference clustered at the randomized cluster level.

Intervention

The intervention is an information-clarification leaflet encouraging households to consult the municipal Waterworks and Sewerage Division about connecting to the public sewer system. The leaflet is inserted into the municipal newsletter and distributed through the municipality's ordinary newsletter distribution system. It clarifies that consultation alone is welcome, explains what residents can ask about, provides contact information, and reduces the perceived burden of taking the first step. The intervention does not change monetary incentives, eligibility rules, application procedures, or ordinary administrative services.

Experimental design

The study is a phased-in cluster-randomized controlled trial. The unit of randomization is a constructed geographic cluster based on administrative aza units. The final cluster configuration was determined before formal assignment using pre-specified staged clustering rules applied to the frozen roster. The formal assignment was conducted once using the frozen assignment input and a pre-specified constrained-randomization procedure.

The final design consists of 42 clusters. Twenty-one clusters were assigned to the first-wave group and 21 clusters were assigned to the second-wave group. District-level balance is exact: 6 versus 6 in district 1, 6 versus 6 in district 2, and 9 versus 9 in district 3. First-wave clusters receive the leaflet through the July 2026 municipal newsletter, while second-wave clusters receive the leaflet through the October 2026 municipal newsletter. The primary identification window compares first-wave and second-wave clusters during July–September 2026, before the second-wave group receives the leaflet.

The municipal newsletter is distributed through the ordinary administrative distribution route. Delivery areas of local community representatives responsible for newsletter distribution may not perfectly coincide with administrative aza units or the constructed research clusters. Where feasible, known route-level overlap, off-target delivery risk, delay, or implementation exceptions will be recorded as implementation-fidelity information. The primary analysis remains based on the ex ante randomized assignment and the ITT framework. Restricted GIS files, municipality-provided administrative data, household-level records, detailed assignment files, and distribution-route records are not uploaded because they are subject to data-use restrictions and municipal confidentiality requirements.

A separate combined-septic-tank conversion encouragement experiment may be implemented in Date City under a separate PAP and separate registration. The present trial does not use data from a previously conducted RCT. Although some administrative recording procedures or consultation-log formats may be shared in practice, this registration concerns only the sewer connection encouragement RCT, with a separate assignment frame, intervention, target population, outcomes, and analysis plan.

Design details

Randomization method
The formal assignment used covariate-constrained randomization. Candidate assignments were generated under hard constraints requiring overall and district-level balance in the number of clusters assigned to each wave. Balance was evaluated using pre-specified cluster-level variables, including the number of unconnected households, household count, area composition, wastewater-treatment composition, and availability of prior outreach information. Soft geographic constraints were used as a preferred filter within SMD-admissible allocations. The selected allocation has no soft-constraint violations and all absolute standardized mean differences are below the selected threshold. The selected allocation was finalized before the first intervention wave and before inspection of any post-intervention outcome data.
Randomization unit
Constructed geographic cluster
Clusters
42 constructed geographic clusters
Observations
2,377 unconnected households in sewer service areas, nested in 42 randomized geographic clusters. The primary analysis uses a household-by-month panel constructed from administrative records.
Arms
21 constructed geographic clusters in the first-wave group and 21 constructed geographic clusters in the second-wave group.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome is Any Consult_it, a household-by-month indicator equal to one if household i has at least one sewer-related consultation or inquiry recorded in month t, and zero otherwise.
Secondary outcomes
Key secondary outcomes are whether a household requests a cost estimate, submits an application for connection, or contacts a contractor. Additional supplementary and mechanism-related outcomes include consultation level, consultation content, concern after consultation, clarity of the consultation pathway, number of contacts, leaflet recognition, understanding of where to seek consultation, and reasons for not consulting, based on consultation logs and, if implemented, a follow-up survey.
Partners
Name: Waterworks and Sewerage Division, Construction Department, Date City Partner_type: municipality

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords