Information and take-up of social benefits in France
How to cite
Gurgand, Marc; Castell, Laura; Tochev, Todor; Imbert, Clément. 2017. "Information and take-up of social benefits in France." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001882. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1882-3.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The low take-up of social benefits is one of the major hurdles in designing effective social policies. A proportion of individuals who are entitled to social benefits choose not to claim them. The literature has advanced several possible explanations for this phenomenon: lack of information, transaction costs (such as transport costs), and fear of being stigmatised.
In order to face this problem, the French Welfare Office (CNAF) invites potential beneficiaries to meet with social workers in order to examine their eligibility status with respect to a large range of State and local social benefits. Our project examines the effects of various type of invitations, which address different plausible causes of low take-up, on the presence of people at those meetings and the effect of this presence on the actual take-up of social benefits. We focus our analysis on a population which is likely to require social benefits: people who recently registered as unemployed or for whom unemployment insurance will soon come to an end.
This experimentation has a double goal: evaluating a program which aims at increasing the level of take-up of social benefits and studying the causes of this low take-up (lack of information, cost of contracting social service and stigmatisation) and their relative weight.
Intervention
The intervention consists in a meeting at the Welfare Office, where a social worker examines the financial situation of the subject and explores possible eligibility to a number of social benefits. This mostly provides detailed information on benefits. It also reduces transaction costs (conditional on attending the meeting) as beneficiaires will be helped in the process. A phone version of the meeting is also offered in order to reduce transaction costs.
Experimental design
The experimentation targets unemployed workers who either recently entered unemployment or are about to terminate unemployment insurance in the Public Unemployment Service administrative files. Participants are then randomly allocated to one of the seven groups:
- Group 1 serves as control.
- Group 2 receives an invitation to a meeting with the Welfare Office. Among this group there are six equally size subgroups.They receive different types of invitations and the nature of the meeting to which they have access differs:
1) Subgroup 1 receives a neutral invitation. It urges recipients to call a phone number in order to plan the meeting. Those people are only offered this appointment at the Welfare Office’s premises
2) Subgroup 2 receives an invitation containing examples of hypothetical life situations together with the corresponding benefit. Those people are only offered this appointment at the Welfare Office’s premises
3) Subgroup 3 receives an invitation containing in addition personal tales of people who have improved their social situation thanks to benefits; this is meant to reduce the feeling of stigmatization. Those people are only offered this appointment at the Welfare Office’s premises
4) Subgroup 4 receives a neutral invitation. It urges recipients to call a phone number in order to plan the meeting. Those people are given a choice of an appointment at the Welfare Office’s premises or a phone interview.
5) Subgroup 5 receives an invitation containing examples of hypothetical life situations together with the corresponding benefit. It urges recipients to call a phone number in order to plan the meeting. Those people are given a choice of an appointment at the Welfare Office’s premises or a phone interview.
6) Subgroup 6 receives an invitation containing in addition personal tales of people who have improved their social situation thanks to benefits; this is meant to reduce the feeling of stigmatization. It urges recipients to call a phone number in order to plan the meeting. Those people are given a choice of an appointment at the Welfare Office’s premises or a phone interview.
Then, three and six month after the intervention, we measure the actual take-up of social benefits in our sample.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.