The Cost of Grouping: Experimental Evidence on Youth Demand for Individual and Group-Based Seed Capital

How to cite

Gebrekidan, Bisrat Haile; Abate, Gashaw Tadesse; Abay, Kibrom; Chamberlin, Jordan; Mockshell, Jonathan; Nigus, Halefom Yigzaw; Workie, Melkamu. 2026. "The Cost of Grouping: Experimental Evidence on Youth Demand for Individual and Group-Based Seed Capital." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018813. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18813-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Bisrat Haile Gebrekidan* , Gashaw Tadesse Abate , Kibrom Abay , Jordan Chamberlin , Jonathan Mockshell , Halefom Yigzaw Nigus , Melkamu Workie

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018813
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18813-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-06-08 – 2027-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O12 (Microeconomic Analyses of Economic Development); O13 (Agriculture; Natural Resources); D12 (Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis); C93 (Field Experiments); Q12 (Micro Analysis of Farm Firms / Agricultural Markets); J13 (Youth)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18813

Abstract

Youth-employment and entrepreneurship programs in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) routinely deliver programs, including grants and credit, through groups (self-formed or program-assigned). What such grouping creates economies of scale, such grouping and joint ventures can be prone to free-riding while entailing significant coordination costs. The size of this hidden “tax”, what we call the cost of grouping, is currently unknown, as is the cost of assignment (the additional welfare loss when the program, rather than the recipient, picks the partners). This study uses an incentivized double-bounded dichotomous-choice (DBDC) experiment to estimate three demand curves, individual, self-formed group, and program-assigned group, in the same currency as the transfer itself (Ethiopian Birr). The experiment is embedded in a large youth survey covering 16 kebeles (villages) and approximately 2500 youth drawn from 183 Youth Agricultural Innovation Groups (YAIGs) in Oromia Region, Ethiopia. Incentive compatibility is enforced by a public lottery: one youth per kebele (16 primary winners across the 16 kebeles) has one of her incentivized choices implemented for real. The pre-registered primary outcomes are the median compensating premium required to give up individual allocation in favor of (i) a self-formed group and (ii) a program-assigned group, and the partner-choice premium identified directly by the self-formed vs. assigned comparison.

Intervention

This is a survey-embedded, incentivized valuation experiment rather than a programmatic treatment. Every sampled youth completes a dedicated DBDC valuation section in the SurveyCTO CAPI instrument, immediately after the baseline socioeconomic module and a four-question comprehension check. Each respondent is randomly assigned to exactly one of three valuation modules:
• M1: Individual grant (10,000 ETB) vs. self-formed group (group total B) — premium for autonomy when partners are self-chosen.
• M2: Individual grant (10,000 ETB) vs. program-assigned group (group total B) — premium for autonomy and partner choice combined.
• M3: Self-formed group (50,000 ETB) vs. program-assigned group (group total B) — pure value of partner choice, group structure held constant.

Within the assigned module the respondent answers two linked yes/no choices (double-bounded): the follow-up bid moves up after a rejection and down after an acceptance, bracketing the latent willingness-to-accept (WTA). Group amounts are denominated as the total received by a group of five (G = 5, fixed). The parity floor is 50,000 ETB (= 5 × 10,000) and the ceiling is 70,000 ETB (= 5 × 14,000). The starting bid is drawn uniformly from five bid paths in 5,000 ETB steps {50,000; 55,000; 60,000; 65,000; 70,000}.
Incentive compatibility is enforced by a public lottery: after fieldwork closes, one youth per kebele (16 primary winners across 16 kebeles) is drawn; one of each winner’s incentivized DBDC answers is selected at random and the chosen modality is paid for real as seed capital.

Intervention (public) Youth members of agribusiness groups complete an incentivized choice experiment valuing whether they would prefer the same seed-capital grant as an individual, in a group of their own choosing, or in a group assigned by the program. A subset of respondents (one per kebele) has one of their real choices implemented and paid out.

Experimental design

Between-subjects, three-arm valuation experiment embedded in a CAPI survey of the full youth sample. Every respondent completes the experiment; there is no community- or YAIG-level treatment. Randomization operates over (a) which one of the three valuation modules a respondent answers, (b) the starting bid path within that module, and (c) post-fieldwork implementation draws (which youth win and which of their answers is implemented). Each respondent provides two double-bounded yes/no choices that bracket her WTA for the non-preferred modality. Incentive compatibility is secured by a binding, publicly announced lottery.
Experimental Design Details Modules: M1 (individual vs self-formed), M2 (individual vs assigned), M3 (self-formed vs assigned). Group size G = 5 fixed across both group arms, isolating the formation mechanism from group size. Bid paths (group totals, ETB):
Path B1 (start) B_L (lower) B_H (upper) Notes
1 50,000 n/a 55,000 Floor: identifies youth who accept at parity
2 55,000 50,000 60,000
3 60,000 55,000 65,000
4 65,000 60,000 70,000
5 70,000 65,000 n/a Ceiling: rejection ⇒ right-censored
DBDC bracket mapping: yes–yes ⇒ WTA ≤ B_L; yes–no ⇒ (B_L, B1]; no–yes ⇒ (B1, B_H]; no–no ⇒ WTA > B_H (right-censored; at the ceiling path the right censor is 70,000 ETB). After fieldwork, 16 primary winners (one per kebele) each have one randomly drawn incentivized answer implemented and paid.

Design details

Randomization method
1) Bid path: drawn on the fly inside the SurveyCTO instrument at the start of each interview using SurveyCTO’s random() function — uniform at the respondent level, no stratification. (2) Module assignment: pre-generated over the sampling frame by a seeded stata script (seed archived for reproducibility) and preloaded into the instrument (3) Implementation draws (winners; which answer is implemented) are made post-fieldwork by computer
Randomization unit
Module assignment is stratified by YAIG (and therefore by kebele, since each YAIG nests within exactly one kebele); bid-path assignment is unstratified at the individual level.
Clusters
183 YAIGs
Observations
planned number of observations Approximately 2,500 youth (each contributes two DBDC choice rounds within her single assigned module).
Arms
Three modules, individual-level equal-proportion allocation within each YAIG: approximately 833 respondents per module (M1, M2, M3) at N = 2,600.
Primary outcomes
1. pi_M1 — median compensating premium to switch from a 10,000 ETB individual grant to a self-formed group (Module M1). 2. pi_M2 — median compensating premium to switch from a 10,000 ETB individual grant to a program-assigned group (Module M2). 3. pi_M3 — median compensating premium to switch from a self-formed group to a program-assigned group (Module M3); the partner-choice premium / cost of assignment. 4. Acceptance shares at parity— share accepting the group alternative at the 50,000 ETB parity bid, for self-formed and assigned.
Secondary outcomes
Full demand curves at the five bid levels {50,000; 55,000; 60,000; 65,000; 70,000} for each modality; cost of assignment as the residual pi_M2 − pi_M1; heterogeneity of premiums by pre-specified covariates (gender, age, prior business experience, prior group experience, prior group conflict, trust-network size); right-censoring rates at the 70,000 ETB ceiling by modality; validity diagnostics (comprehension-check pass rates, belief elicitation on trust in the draw/payout and subjective win probability, bid-path balance, and module balance).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords