Student Preferences and School Choice: A Discrete Choice Experiment

How to cite

ARAUJO, DANIEL; Vigor, Gil do; Rosa, Leonardo. 2026. "Student Preferences and School Choice: A Discrete Choice Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018811. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18811-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

DANIEL ARAUJO* , Gil do Vigor , Leonardo Rosa

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018811
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18811-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2021-04-11 – 2022-03-31
Countries
Brazil ()
JEL codes
I21, I28, D83
Secondary IDs
CAAE 45958721.8.0000.5407 (Plataforma Brasil / CEP FFCLRP-USP, ethics approval)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18811

Abstract

Secondary school dropout is high across developing countries, and much of it happens in the transition from lower secondary to upper secondary school. Most policies aimed at keeping students enrolled focus on the supply side, such as building schools, adding instructional time, or offering financial incentives. Far less is known about what students themselves value in a school and whether those preferences can be shifted with information.
This study uses a discrete choice experiment with ninth-grade students in Brazil, who are at the point of choosing a secondary school. Each student completes a series of choice tasks. In each task, the student sees two hypothetical school profiles and an option to leave school. School profiles vary along six attributes: schedule, curriculum, distance from home, school quality, social environment, and scholarship amount. The levels of these attributes are randomly assigned, which allows us to estimate how much each attribute affects the probability that a student chooses a school and to express these preferences in monetary terms.
Before the choice tasks, students are randomly assigned to information conditions. One treatment provides information about the earnings difference between students who finish high school and those who do not, varying the size of the premium and the state of the local labor market. A second treatment asks students to reflect on their career goals and to report whether they believe their desired career requires a high school diploma. We study how stated preferences over school attributes differ across students by gender, race, and socioeconomic status, and whether the information treatments change the value students place on schooling.

Intervention

The study adds two randomized information treatments to an online survey given to ninth grade students who are about to choose a secondary school. The main tool in the survey is a discrete choice experiment, and the treatments change the information students see just before it. Each student was randomly placed in one of three groups: a control group (introduction only), a wage premium group, or a career reflection group.
The discrete choice experiment. Each student completed a set of choice tasks. In each task, the student saw two made-up secondary school profiles and a third option that meant leaving school (not enrolling in high school). The student picked the option they liked most. Each school profile was described by six features, and the level of each feature was chosen at random for each profile: schedule (full-day, part-time, or evening), curriculum (vocational training, life project, higher education exam preparation, a focus on social, hard, or life sciences, or no special curriculum), distance from home (15, 30, or 45 minutes), school quality (an IDEB score of 3, 5, or 7), social environment (whether friends, parents, or teachers recommended the school, or none), and a monthly scholarship (from R$0 to R$150). Each task showed only some of the features, chosen at random (a partial profile design). Because the feature levels are set at random and independently, the design shows how each feature changes the chance that a student picks a school. It also lets us measure how much each feature is worth in money, using the scholarship amount as the money scale.
Treatment 1: Wage premium information. Before the choice tasks, students in this group saw information about how much more people earn when they finish high school, compared to finishing only lower secondary school. This information changed in two ways, shown in all combinations: the size of the wage gain (low, shown as a monthly wage of R$1,300 versus R$1,100; or high, shown as R$1,800 versus R$1,100) and the state of the local job market (described as warm, with many job openings, or cold, with few). As a small design detail, the card was shown in one of two colors (blue or red). This was a minor visual framing change that kept the wage and job market information the same. It is not a focus of the study and is not analyzed here. A control group saw no job market information.

Treatment 2: Career reflection. Before the choice tasks, students in this group answered two questions about their future: which job they would like to have, and whether they think that job needs a high school diploma. This treatment brings the student's own career goals to mind right before they choose. It does not give students any outside information. It only asks for their own goal and their own belief about whether that goal needs a high school diploma.
The treatments test whether bringing the returns to schooling, or one's own career goals, to mind changes how much students value staying in school and the school features they care about.

Experimental design

This is a survey experiment with ninth grade students who are about to choose a secondary school. It has two layers of random assignment.

The first layer is the discrete choice experiment, run within each student. Each student completed six choice tasks. In each task the student saw two made-up school profiles and a third option that meant leaving school, and picked the option they liked most. Each school profile was described by six features (schedule, curriculum, distance, school quality, social environment, and a monthly scholarship), and the level of each feature was set at random and independently for each profile. Because the levels are random, the design shows how each feature affects the chance a student picks a school, and how much each feature is worth in money.

The second layer is between students. Before the choice tasks, each student was randomly placed in a control group (introduction only), a wage premium group (shown the extra earnings from finishing high school), or a career reflection group (asked about their future job and whether they think it needs high school). This lets us test whether the information changes how much students value staying in school and the school features they care about.

The choices are analyzed with a conditional logit model, and feature weights are turned into money values using the scholarship as the money scale.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done automatically by the online survey software (Qualtrics). For each student, the software randomly assigned the information condition and randomly set the feature levels shown in each choice task. No manual or public lottery was used.
Randomization unit
There are two levels of randomization, both handled by the survey software: Information condition (control, wage premium, or career reflection, including the wage premium sub-arms): randomized at the individual student level. Students in the same school were assigned to different conditions. School feature levels in the choice tasks: randomized within each student, at the level of the choice task and the school profile, so the two profiles in a task and the six tasks each student saw varied independently.
Clusters
15,170 students. The treatment was not clustered, so the unit of randomization is the individual student. Students came from 332 schools across the state of Paraiba, but assignment to conditions was made at the student level, not the school level.
Observations
15,170 students were randomized. The analysis sample is 14,588 students who completed at least one choice task. Because each student completed up to six choice tasks, and each task had three alternatives (two school profiles and a leave-school option), this produces 255,021 school-choice observations, which are the observations used in the conditional logit model.
Arms
Control (introduction only): 5,114 students. Wage premium (shown labor market information): 4,972 students. These were randomly split across eight cells crossing wage gain size (low or high), job market state (warm or cold), and card color (blue or red), with about 520 to 595 students per cell. The analysis groups these into four arms by wage gain and job market state, about 1,240 students per arm. Card color is not analyzed. Career reflection (asked about their future job): 5,084 students. Based on the student's own answer about whether that job needs a high school diploma, 4,747 believe it does, 218 believe it does not, and 119 did not answer. The "does not need high school" group is small because most students name jobs that require high school.
Primary outcomes
The main outcome is the choice each student makes in each task: which of the three options they pick, one of the two school profiles or the option to leave school. This is recorded as an indicator for the chosen option. From these choices we estimate how much students value each school feature and how much they value staying in school instead of leaving. We also measure whether the two information treatments change these values, in particular the value of staying in school.
Secondary outcomes
The same choice variable is used to study how preferences differ across groups of students, defined by gender, race, and socioeconomic status, both at baseline and in response to the two treatments.

Papers from this trial

  1. Araujo, Daniel, Gil do Vigor, and Leonardo Rosa. 2026. "School Choice Dynamics: Preferences, Heterogeneity, and Information Treatments in Brazilian Secondary Education." Working Paper. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1uKaGv9bYDdNVb4zGM7El7pXAXpuGxUEk/view?usp=drive_link

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords