Present and Future Temporal Framing and Their Effects on Hope, Hopelessness, and Entrepreneurial Outcomes: A Randomized Field Experiment

How to cite

Heales, Kylie; Barin-Cruz, Luciano. 2026. "Present and Future Temporal Framing and Their Effects on Hope, Hopelessness, and Entrepreneurial Outcomes: A Randomized Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018803. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18803-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kylie Heales* , Luciano Barin-Cruz

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018803
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18803-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-06-02 – 2027-01-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18803

Abstract

This study examines whether brief, structured exposure to present- or future-oriented thinking shapes feelings of hope and hopelessness among women entrepreneurs in Haiti, and whether hope and hopelessness in turn affect their resilience, willingness to act, and intention to keep pursuing their business goals.

Participants are women entrepreneurs enrolled in a women's entrepreneurship training program in Haiti. The study embeds a randomized experiment within a two-module training program. All participants receive the first module, a financial literacy and management session with no temporal framing. Participants are then randomly assigned to one of three conditions for the second module, a session on women's leadership and climate resilience: (1) a version framed around their current business situation; (2) a version framed around their future business situation; or (3) a waitlist control condition involving a structured review activity based on the first module, with no temporal framing. Target enrollment is 400 participants. Data collection runs June through August 2026.

Participants complete surveys before and after each module accordingly. We measure their sense of control over past, present, and future business challenges, their current feelings of hope and hopelessness, and their entrepreneurial resilience, action orientation, and forward business intentions.

Intervention

The intervention is a training session on women's leadership and climate resilience, delivered as the second module of a two-module entrepreneurship training program. The session covers the same substantive content across conditions. What varies is how that content is framed throughout the session.

Participants assigned to the "present" condition experience the session through the lens of what they control right now in their business. Cases, examples, and discussions are selected and framed to reflect current business situations and present-focused decision making. Participants assigned to the "future" condition experience the session through the lens of where they are taking their business and what they can do in the future to get there. Cases, examples, and discussions are selected and framed to reflect forward business planning and future-focused decision making. In both conditions, the trainer opens and closes the session by explicitly orienting participants to the relevant temporal frame.

Participants assigned to the control condition do not receive the second training module during the data collection period. Instead, they complete a structured review activity based on the first module. They receive the full training after data collection is complete.

Experimental design

Participants are women entrepreneurs enrolled in a women's entrepreneurship training program. Target enrolment is 400 participants, allocated approximately 40% to the present condition, 40% to the future condition, and 20% to the waitlist control condition. Participants are randomly assigned at the individual level and training is delivered in cohorts of 25 to 30 participants. Data collection runs June through August 2026.

Each training module is a half-day session. Module 1 and Module 2 are not delivered on the same day. The interval between modules varies by cohort but is consistent at approximately two weeks across all cohorts.

Surveys are administered at three points: before Module 1, and before and after Module 2. This produces a pre-training baseline and a post-training exit measure for all outcome variables, allowing within-person change to be assessed across conditions.

Before each survey, participants complete a brief check to identify whether any significant external events have occurred that might affect their responses. This is particularly important given Haiti's chronic crisis context, where exogenous shocks during the study period could confound results.

At the end of Module 2, participants in the two treatment conditions complete a brief manipulation check confirming whether the temporal framing of the session was perceived as intended.

Participants come from a range of industries and venture stages. Demographic and venture characteristics (e.g., age, education, employee number and type, venture age) are collected at baseline and will be used to confirm that randomization produced comparable groups across conditions. Because participants attend training in groups, intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) will be used to detect and account for the possibility that people in the same cohort may respond similarly to one another.

Design details

Randomization method
Participants are randomized to conditions using a computer-generated random number generator in Excel. Each participant is assigned a random number and allocated to a condition based on that number. Participants are assigned individually and then grouped into delivery cohorts of 25 to 30 participants until each cohort is full.
Randomization unit
Individual. Participants are randomized at the individual level and subsequently grouped into delivery cohorts of 25 to 30 participants. Although randomization is individual, training is delivered in cohorts, and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) will be used to account for cohort-level clustering effects in the analysis.
Clusters
Approximately 13 to 16 cohorts of 25 to 30 participants each, for a planned total of 400 participants.
Observations
400 individual participants (women entrepreneurs enrolled in a women's entrepreneurship training program in Haiti).
Arms
160 participants: present temporal framing condition (Treatment A) 160 participants: future temporal framing condition (Treatment B) 80 participants: waitlist control condition
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes of interest are hope and hopelessness, each measured as a change score (post-training minus pre-training): 1. Hope: current feelings of hopefulness about goals and the future, measured using an adapted version of the State Hope Scale (Snyder et al., 1996) 2. Hopelessness: current feelings of hopelessness about goals and the future, measured using an adapted version of the State Hopelessness Scale (Dunn et al., 2014)
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes of interest are three entrepreneurial variables, each measured as a change score (post-training minus pre-training): 1. Entrepreneurial resilience: the capacity to recover and adapt in the face of business adversity, measured using an adapted version of the Connor-Davidson Resilience Scale (Campbell-Sills & Stein, 2007) 2. Entrepreneurial action orientation: the capacity to translate intention into action without rumination or hesitation, measured using an adapted version of the Action-State Orientation Scale (Diefendorff et al., 2000) 3. Entrepreneurial intent: forward commitment to continuing to pursue business goals despite obstacles, measured using a purpose-written scale adapted from the Grit Scale (Duckworth et al., 2007), with intent framing drawn from Sheeran et al. (2005) and obstacle structure from Gollwitzer (1999)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords