Governing Intangible Commons: Evidence from the Indonesian Traditional Embroidery Industry

How to cite

Shofia, Naila; Tanaka, Mari; Sawada, Yasuyuki; Nakayama, Hitomi. 2026. "Governing Intangible Commons: Evidence from the Indonesian Traditional Embroidery Industry." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018772. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18772-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Naila Shofia* , Mari Tanaka , Yasuyuki Sawada , Hitomi Nakayama

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018772
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18772-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-04-27 – 2028-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18772

Abstract

In many developing countries, traditional industries are declining rapidly amid broader economic growth and market change. Industries that rely on manual production methods and traditional skills transmitted across generations increasingly struggle to compete with mass-produced goods. This study examines whether identifying and better managing intangible commons—such as cultural heritage, shared identity, and collective values sustained through joint action among producers—can help both preserve and revitalize declining traditional industries. Specifically, we evaluate whether interventions that promote cultural-value-based marketing, encourage cooperation among producers, and connect producers with buyers/intermediaries who have expertise in designing products for broader markets improve outcomes in the traditional embroidery industry in rural Indonesia.
The study population includes embroidery business owners and workers identified through a door-to-door rapid census conducted in Kudus Regency Indonesia. Firms are randomly assigned to one of three groups: (i) a cultural-based marketing intervention, (ii) a cultural-based marketing plus coordination/cooperation intervention, or (iii) a placebo control group receiving training on healthy lifestyle topics. In addition, we cross-randomize a sample-order treatment in which some firms receive an order to produce sample products by buyers/intermediaries within a specified period. A baseline survey of business owners and workers is conducted in April-May 2026. The main outcomes data are collected through short post-workshop follow-up measures and an end-line survey approximately four months after the training. Primary outcomes include subjective cultural valuation of the product, intrinsic motivation, and producer cooperation. Secondary outcomes include business performance, market participation, engagement in follow-up producer activities, and the quality of requested sample products. Planned enrollment is about 600 individuals, half of which are business owners and another half are workers.

Intervention

The study evaluates three main intervention components for the traditional embroidery industry. The first provides information and training on practical strategies for culture-based marketing. It aims to help producers increase the value of embroidery products by positioning them as traditional crafts that embody cultural heritage and regional identity, while also expanding access to market opportunities beyond the local area. The second provides information and nudges aimed at formalizing coordination and cooperation among producers, which may help address common constraints related to production, marketing, and access to broader markets. The third intervention provides sample orders that connect producers with buyers/intermediaries who have expertise in designing products for broader markets. This treatment is intended to reduce information frictions by allowing producers to learn about the role intermediaries can play in accessing broader markets and allowing intermediaries to observe the quality of producers’ work. The main study arms consist of (i) the first component only, (ii) the first and second components together, and (iii) placebo training on healthy lifestyle topics. The third component is cross-randomized across these three arms.

Experimental design

This study is a randomized controlled trial in the traditional embroidery industry in Indonesia. Eligible participants are embroidery business owners and workers identified through a door-to-door census conducted in Kudus Regency. Firms are randomly assigned to one of three main study arms: (i) culture-based marketing treatment only, (ii) culture-based marketing plus coordination/cooperation treatment, or (iii) placebo control training on healthy lifestyle topics. Additionally, we cross-randomize (iv) sample-order treatment across the three main study arms. Baseline data collection takes place in April-May 2026. Additional data collection includes short post-workshop follow-up measures and an end-line survey approximately four months after the training. Planned enrollment is about 600 individuals, half of which are business owners and another half are workers.

Design details

Randomization method
Firms will be assigned to study arms using computerized randomization by the research team prior to intervention delivery.
Randomization unit
Firm.
Clusters
Around 300
Observations
Around 600 individuals, half of which are business owners and another half are workers.
Arms
We plan to assign approximately 100 firms in the culture-based marketing arm, 100 firms in the culture-based marketing plus coordination/cooperation arm, and 100 firms in the placebo control arm. Additionally, around 150 firms will be assigned to receive a sample order and 150 will not receive the sample order. The planned total observed sample is about 600 individuals, half of which are business owners and another half are workers.
Primary outcomes
1. Cultural valuation of embroidery products among business owners and workers. 2. Intrinsic motivation related to embroidery production and work among business owners and workers. 3. Measures of cooperation among producers.
Secondary outcomes
1. Business performance measures, including sales and market expansion. 2. Engagement in follow-up producer activities and study-related group communication. 3. Quality of requested sample products

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords