Mental Models and Learning in Complex Environments

How to cite

Yu, Shen; Dong, Lu; Huang, Lingbo. 2026. "Mental Models and Learning in Complex Environments." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018767. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18767-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Shen Yu* , Lu Dong , Lingbo Huang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018767
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18767-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-04-20 – 2026-06-28
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D83, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18767

Abstract

Standard economic theories suggest that providing more information should improve subjective probability judgments. However, Esponda et al. (2024) found in a binary-state belief-updating experiment that providing the underlying primitives of the data-generating process actually hinders participants’ learning from sequential feedback.
Furthermore, Ba et al. (2025) documented that increasing the complexity of the information environment may “have a striking effect on belief updating”: people underreact to information in simple two-state uniform-prior environments, but overreact in three-state uniform-prior environments.
Our experiment investigates whether the learning ineffffciency induced by providing primitives, as documented by Esponda et al. (2024), generalizes to a three-state information environment with asymmetric priors.

Intervention

The experiment employs a 2 × 2 between-subjects design with four treatments that differ in the information environment. The first two treatments are replications of the binary-states experiment by Esponda et al. (2024), while the last two are their analogues with an additional state.

Experimental design

In the main task, subjects in the CP and CNP treatments will be asked to assess the probabilities that a project is a Success, a Neutral, or a Failure for each possible test result (Positive or Negative); subjects in the SP and SNP treatments will be asked to assess the probabilities that a project is a Success or a Failure for each possible test result (Positive or Negative). In Stage 5, we will ask subjectsto recall the feedback they received during rounds 1–200 of the main task.
· Stage 1, round 001: Tutorial. Introduce the BDM method and strategy method using simple examples.
· Stage 2, round 001: The Main task.
· Stage 3, round 002–100: Learning: Repetition of the main task. Beliefelicited at every single round.
· Stage 4, round 101–200: Learning: Repetition of the main task. Beliefelicited at every 10th round.
· Stage 5, round 201: Recollection of feedback.
· Stage 6, round 202: Summary tables. True feedback statistics revealed. Main task.
· Stage 7, round 203: Summary tables. 1000-round statistics (200 real+ 800 simulated) revealed. Main task.
· Stage 8, round 204: Summary tables. Frequency derived from the1000-round statistics revealed. Main task.
· Stage 9, round 205: Transfer of learning. Primitives changed. Main task.
· Survey.

Design details

Randomization method
by a computer
Randomization unit
Treatment assignment occurs at the session level (between-subjects).
Clusters
We will run 3 sessions per treatment with 20 subjects per session, yielding 60 subjects per treatment and a total sample size of 240.
Observations
With 205 rounds per session, this generates 12,300 subject-round observations per treatment.
Arms
60 subjects SP (Simple environment with Primitives), 60 subjects SNP (Simple environment without Primitives), 60 subjects CP (Complex environment with Primitives), 60 subjects CNP (Complex environment without Primitives).
Primary outcomes
Bpossuc: Belief elicited in each round, Pr(Success | Positive) Bposneu: Belief elicited in each round, Pr(Neutral | Positive) Bposfail: Belief elicited in each round, Pr(Failure | Positive) Bnegsuc Belief elicited in each round, Pr(Success | Negative) Bnegneu Belief elicited in each round, Pr(Neutral | Negative) Bnegfail Belief elicited in each round, Pr(Failure | Negative)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords