In-group versus Out-group Hardship and Inter-Group Prosociality: A Survey Experiment in Darfur, Sudan

How to cite

Cipa, Timur. 2026. "In-group versus Out-group Hardship and Inter-Group Prosociality: A Survey Experiment in Darfur, Sudan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018762. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18762-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Timur Cipa*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018762
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18762-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-08-12 – 2026-10-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q34, D74, Z13, D71
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18762

Abstract

Armed conflict can increase within-group prosociality while reducing prosociality towards members of other groups (Bauer et al., 2016; Barceló, 2026). Although this pattern is well documented, the mechanisms underlying it remain poorly understood, and interventions targeting intergroup relations are rarely evaluated during active conflict.

This study examines whether brief reflections on hardship experienced by one's own group or members of other groups affect intergroup attitudes and behaviour, and whether effects depend on the target of reflection. Approximately 3,000 adults across 150 villages in North, Central, and South Darfur, Sudan, are randomly assigned during a face-to-face household survey to reflect on (i) an ordinary daily activity (control), (ii) challenges experienced by their own group, (iii) challenges experienced by another group, or (iv) both. All respondents provide a concrete example, holding the task structure constant while varying the content of reflection.

We subsequently measure intergroup behaviour and attitudes, including willingness to commit to joint activities with members of other groups, social distance, beliefs about equitable access to humanitarian assistance, and the belief that one's own group has suffered uniquely. We additionally record perceptions of relative group suffering, and assess the accuracy of beliefs about other groups' suffering by comparing respondents' perceptions with objective measures of local shock exposure and with reports from members of the respective groups.

The design identifies the causal effects of reflecting on own-group and other-group hardship, as well as their combination, and tests for heterogeneous treatment effects by groups' social status and histories of exposure to shocks. The results will provide evidence on the potential of low-cost perspective-taking interventions to influence intergroup relations during active conflict, including potential trade-offs associated with emphasizing own-group suffering.

Intervention

The intervention is a brief reflection prompt administered in Arabic before the outcome module. Two factors are independently randomized, yielding four conditions:

1. Active control: name one ordinary daily activity commonly undertaken in the area.
2. Own-group hardship (T1): name one difficult situation experienced by the respondent and their group over the past year.
3. Other-group hardship (T2): name one difficult situation experienced by members of other groups in the area over the past year; the respondent’s own group is excluded.
4. Both (T3): receive the own-group prompt followed by the other-group prompt, each requiring a separate example.

The four relevant social groups in the context of this study are permanent residents/hosts, displaced people, returnees, and nomads. Respondents’ own-group status is established earlier in the survey and used to tailor the prompts.

All conditions use the same structure, including a request for one concrete example and reassurance that there are no right or wrong answers. The active comparison condition therefore isolates the effect of reflection content rather than reflection itself.

Open-ended responses both facilitate engagement and provide a manipulation check through subsequent coding. Respondents who receive the other-group prompt — that is, those in T2 and in T3 — additionally identify the group they had in mind, allowing verification of the intended treatment and measurement of the specific out-group considered.

The intervention is brief, administered once, and involves no material transfer or programme participation.

Experimental design

The study is an individually randomised survey experiment with four arms, structured as a 2×2 factorial and embedded in a face-to-face survey covering roughly 3,000 respondents in about 150 villages across North, Central and South Darfur (approximately 20 respondents per village).

Two reflection prompts are crossed as independent on/off factors: a prompt making one's own group's hardship salient, and a prompt making other groups' hardship salient. Crossing them produces four cells — neither prompt (an active comparison reflection task), own-group prompt only (T1), other-group prompt only (T2), and both in sequence (T3) — with equal assignment probability, so roughly 750 respondents per cell. Assignment is at the individual respondent level and occurs inside the survey software.

Because the two prompts are expected to move outcomes in opposite directions, they are hence not pooled into a single treatment indicator. The pre-specified estimands are the two factorial main effects — the effect of switching each prompt on, averaged over whether the other prompt is present, each estimated on the full sample — and their interaction, which tests whether receiving both departs from additivity. Cell means, simple effects against the comparison condition, and the contrast between the combined arm and the other-group-only arm are reported as secondary descriptive quantities.

Estimation is by analysis of covariance. Outcomes are regressed on the two treatment factors and their product, a pre-specified vector of covariates measured before treatment, and village and enumerator fixed effects. The two factors are effect-coded (−½ when the prompt is absent, +½ when present), so that the two reported coefficients are the factorial main effects — each the difference between prompt-present and prompt-absent cells, averaged over the other factor and estimated on all 3,000 respondents — and the product coefficient is the difference-in-differences. Enumerator fixed effects are included because prompts are read aloud and delivery may vary. Both adjusted and unadjusted estimates are reported. Standard errors are heteroskedasticity-robust and clustered at the village level in the main specifications; where the social-distance data are analysed in long form at the item-by-target level, standard errors are two-way clustered at the respondent and village levels. False discovery rate is controlled within outcome family using sharpened q-values.

All covariates and moderators are measured before the reflection module. Balance is assessed by reporting covariate means by arm together with an omnibus test.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation is done inside the survey instrument (administered via SurveyCTO on tablets), at the moment of interview. Assignment is generated by hidden calculate fields that are not visible to either the respondent or the enumerator, so neither party knows the arm in advance and the enumerator cannot select it. Each of the two factors — the own-group hardship prompt and the other-group hardship prompt — is switched on independently with probability one-half, which is equivalent to assigning each respondent with equal probability 1:1:1:1 to the four arms.
Randomization unit
The individual respondent. There is a single level of randomisation: within each village, individual respondents are independently assigned to the four arms. Villages and households are sampling units, not units of randomisation — every arm appears within every village. There is no group-, household- or village-level assignment.
Clusters
Randomisation is not clustered, so the units of randomisation are the 3,000 individual respondents themselves. For reference on the sampling structure: respondents are drawn from approximately 150 villages in North, Central and South Darfur, with about 20 households per village. Villages are sampling and standard-error clusters, not randomisation clusters — all four arms are represented within each village.
Observations
3,000 individual respondents (one adult respondent per sampled household), across approximately 150 villages in three Darfur states.
Arms
Equal allocation across four arms, approximately 750 respondents each: 750 respondents — active comparison condition (neither prompt) 750 respondents — own-group hardship prompt only 750 respondents — other-group hardship prompt only 750 respondents — both prompts, administered in sequence Equivalently, by factor: 1,500 respondents receive the own-group prompt and 1,500 do not; 1,500 receive the other-group prompt and 1,500 do not.
Primary outcomes
Commitment to inter-group activity (behavioural, binary). Whether the respondent agrees to sign up for joint activities with members of other groups in the area, recorded as a signature captured on the interviewer's tablet. Coded 1 if the respondent signs, 0 otherwise; reasons are recorded when the respondent declines. Out-group social distance index (continuous). Mean comfort with members of groups other than the respondent's own across five everyday-interaction domains, following Grady et al. (2023). Higher values indicate lower social distance. Humanitarian fairness (5-point scale). Agreement with a statement denying other groups equal claim to humanitarian assistance, following Finseraas and Kotsadam (2017). Recorded as 1 = strongly disagree to 5 = strongly agree and reverse-scored, so that higher values are more prosocial. Competitive victimhood (5-point scale). Agreement with a statement that no other group in the region has suffered as the respondent's own group has, following Bilali and Vollhardt (2013). Recorded as 1 = strongly disagree to 5 = strongly agree and used as recorded, so that higher values indicate more competitive victimhood. Note that this outcome runs in the opposite direction to the three prosociality measures: the treatment effects predicted to be positive for prosociality are predicted to be negative here, and vice versa. The first three measures form a prosociality family. Competitive victimhood constitutes a second family on its own. False-discovery-rate correction is applied within each family separately, never across them, and the two families are never combined into a single index.
Secondary outcomes
Relative hardship comparison. How severely the respondent judges each other group to have been affected by challenges over the past 12 months, relative to their own group; asked for each group other than the respondent's own, on a 5-point scale from much more to much less severely. Accuracy of beliefs about out-group hardship. Whether the other-group prompt improves the correspondence between a respondent's perceptions of other groups' hardship and objective and self-reported exposure of hardship by members of other groups, rather than only shifting attitudes. Group-specific social-distance indices. The four target-group-specific scores underlying the primary index, used to examine which out-groups drive any effect. Cell means, simple effects and pairwise contrasts. Differences of each treatment arm from the active comparison condition, and the contrast between the combined arm and the other-group-only arm. Manipulation-check measures. Share of respondents giving a valid, on-theme example by arm, and which specific out-group respondents receiving the other-group prompt report having in mind. Heterogeneity in the primary outcomes by respondent group status and language group, by exposure to conflict and climate shocks, by reported inter-group disputes over land and natural resources, and by zero-sum beliefs, is pre-specified and reported alongside the primary results.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords