Consumer Preferences for Vegetables Grown with Pest Protection Systems and Plastic Use
How to cite
Tong, Jingyi; Zhang, Wendong; Wehner, Jasmin. 2026. "Consumer Preferences for Vegetables Grown with Pest Protection Systems and Plastic Use." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018754. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18754-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Building on a field experiment that measures consumers’ willingness to pay (WTP) for cucumbers produced with and without protective netting by vegetable growers in Kentucky, Iowa, and New York, this study conducts a complementary online survey using a comparable stated valuation setting. Comparing results across the two settings allows us to assess upward hypothetical bias arising from non-binding purchase decisions. We quantify the magnitude of this bias by controlling consumers’ demographics and attitudes and examine the underlying mechanisms driving it. We aim to test if stated WTP is systematically higher due to hypothetical bias well-documented in the existing literature, and whether or not the estimated premiums for protective netting and the direction and significance of information treatments remain consistent across hypothetical and incentive-compatible settings.
The field experiment shows that consumers exhibit strong aversion to the additional plastic use associated with protective netting. This study further investigates the sources of this aversion using a complementary online survey. We examine the role negativity bias plays in the information provided to consumers by observing how it affects their willingness to pay (WTP). We assess whether contextual information about plastics already in use in agriculture, the durability and reusability of protective netting, and plastic residues compared with conventional production systems can mitigate plastic aversion. We also examine how consumers’ knowledge of protective netting, attitudinal variables, and demographic characteristics influence WTP.
Intervention
The intervention consists of randomly assigned information shown to online survey respondents before they make hypothetical cucumber purchase decisions. The information varies what respondents learn about protective netting used in cucumber production, including potential implications for pesticide use and plastic use.
Experimental design
The study is an online survey experiment with random assignment to information conditions. Respondents evaluate cucumber products in a stated purchase setting. The main outcomes are purchase decisions and willingness to pay for cucumbers produced with and without protective netting. The design allows us to estimate how information about production practices affects consumer preferences and tradeoffs between reduced pesticide use and increased plastic use.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.