Encouraging switching in the telecommunications market

How to cite

Akesson, Jesper. 2026. "Encouraging switching in the telecommunications market." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018749. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18749-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jesper Akesson*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018749
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18749-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-10-01 – 2019-02-01
Countries
United States of America (Unable to disclose country due to anonymity of collaborating firm)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18749

Abstract

This study tests whether letters from a telecommunications provider can help landline customers review their calling plan and switch when another plan may suit them better. Many customers remain on old plans for years, even when other options are available from the same provider. We study a large group of landline customers whose existing plans charged a low monthly fee plus prices for many calls.

Customers were randomly assigned either to receive no letter or to receive one of four letters. One letter reminded customers that better deals might be available. A second letter added that changing plan was usually easy. A third letter showed customers what they had been spending each month. A fourth letter described a specific alternative plan and stated its monthly price.

We use company records to measure whether customers contacted the firm, changed plan, adopted the advertised plan, or left the provider. We also use billing and usage data to estimate which customers appeared likely to save money by switching. The study is designed to understand which kinds of information help customers act on better available options, and what continued non-switching implies about the barriers that keep customers on old plans.

Intervention

The intervention consisted of mailed letters sent by the telecommunications provider to landline customers. Customers in the control group did not receive an experimental letter. Customers assigned to treatment received one of four letters.

The first letter told customers that better value options might be available and encouraged them to review their current plan. The second letter contained the same message and added that changing plan was usually quick and that customers could normally keep their existing telephone number. The third letter reported the customer’s average monthly spending over the previous year. The fourth letter described a specific flat price calling plan offered by the same provider and stated its monthly price.

The letters were designed to test whether customers respond more to a general reminder, reassurance about the ease of switching, information about what they currently spend, or information about the price of a specific alternative plan.

Experimental design

The study is a natural field experiment conducted with a telecommunications provider. Eligible landline customers were randomly assigned either to a control group that received no experimental letter or to one of several letter treatments sent by the provider.

The letters varied the information given to customers about reviewing or changing their calling plan. Some letters provided a general prompt to review the plan, while others provided more specific information about current spending or an alternative plan. The design allows us to compare the effect of different types of customer communication on plan review and switching behavior.

Outcomes are measured using administrative records from the provider, including customer contact, plan changes, adoption of the advertised plan, and provider exit during the study period.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer randomization
Randomization unit
Customer
Clusters
132,636
Observations
132,636
Arms
Control group, 69,778 customers Notification letter, 24,512 customers Switching Ease letter, 9,907 customers Average Spend letter, 11,186 customers Pricing Information letter, 17,253 customers Total, 132,636 customers The design used layered eligibility rules, so the control and Notification groups are shared comparison groups across the treatment arms. Each treatment is compared with the control and Notification customers from the same eligible comparison set. So some observations are "re-used".
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome is whether the customer made a substantive change to their landline service during the study period. We define this as changing the base calling plan within the provider or leaving the provider. We also examine related outcomes that help interpret this primary outcome, including whether the customer changed to the specific flat price plan described in one of the letters, whether the customer contacted the provider, and whether the customer changed a calling plan add on.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include whether the customer contacted the provider after receiving the letter, whether the customer adopted the specific flat price calling plan described in the pricing information letter, whether the customer changed a calling plan add on, and whether the customer left the provider. We also use billing and usage records to construct predicted savings from switching to the advertised flat price plan. These measures allow us to study whether the letters were more effective for customers who appeared likely to save money by switching.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords