Pessimistic Labor Market Expectations and Educational Investment: Evidence from a Migration Shock

How to cite

Quintana-Barrera, Alejandra. 2026. "Pessimistic Labor Market Expectations and Educational Investment: Evidence from a Migration Shock." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018743. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18743-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alejandra Quintana-Barrera*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018743
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18743-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2026-05-26 – 2026-06-10
Countries
Colombia ()
JEL codes
J24; I26; F22; D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18743

Abstract

Large and unexpected migration shocks can shape educational investment decisions not only through labor market competition, but also by altering perceptions about the returns to higher education. This project combines two complementary components linking belief formation to realized educational choices.

First, quasi-experimental evidence from Colombia shows that exposure to the large inflow of Venezuelan migrants between 2016 and 2018 reduced native students’ enrollment in bachelor’s degree programs. These effects cannot be explained by changes in academic performance, native student mobility, or increased competition for university slots. Instead, the declines are concentrated in fields where migrants face fewer labor market barriers, suggesting that perceived and/or real labor market conditions may shape students’ educational decisions.

Building on this evidence, the second component directly examines the process of belief formation. I will implement a large-scale survey experiment in Colombia with recent high school graduates to test whether making migration salient affects perceived returns to higher education and and whether attending university is worth it. Respondents are randomly assigned to one of two conditions that vary the order of two survey blocks: (i) a migration-information block presenting factual statements about Venezuelan migration, and (ii) a block eliciting beliefs about the returns to education and perceptions of whether attending university is worth it. In the treatment condition, respondents receive the migration-information block before reporting their beliefs and perceptions; in the control condition, the order is reversed. All remaining survey content is identical across conditions.

This design is motivated by pilot evidence showing that individuals randomly exposed to migration-related prompts report expected returns to a bachelor’s degree that are approximately 15 percent lower relative to the control group. The experiment tests whether migration salience causally shapes belief formation regarding the economic value of higher education and, in turn, intended educational investment decisions.

Intervention

The intervention consists of a light-touch salience and information treatment. Respondents are exposed to information about Venezuelan migration to Colombia before reporting their beliefs about the returns to higher education and perceptions of whether attending university is worth it. Specifically, respondents receive a brief module presenting factual statements about the scale of Venezuelan migration and migrants’ labor market participation, followed by a short comprehension check. They are then asked about their expectations regarding wages and labor market opportunities associated with obtaining a bachelor’s degree, as their assessment of whether attending university is worth it, elicited through a peer-advice framing to reduce social desirability bias.

Experimental design

The experiment consists of a randomized survey module embedded at the end of a larger follow-up survey designed to measure post-program trajectories and postsecondary educational expectations. Respondents are randomly assigned to one of two survey sequences that vary the timing of exposure to migration-related information relative to questions about educational expectations and intended investments.

All respondents complete the same two core blocks. The first is a migration-information block that presents factual statements about the scale of Venezuelan migration to Colombia and migrants’ labor market participation, followed by a brief comprehension check. The second is a returns-to-education block that elicits beliefs about wages, labor market opportunities, perceived social mobility associated with obtaining a bachelor’s degree, and postsecondary enrollment intentions.

In the treatment condition, respondents complete the migration-information block before answering questions about educational expectations and intended investments, making migration salient at the moment beliefs are formed and reported. In the control condition, respondents complete the returns-to-education block before encountering any migration-related content. Because respondents cannot revise earlier answers, differences across conditions identify the causal effect of migration salience on perceived returns to higher education and intended postsecondary enrollment decisions.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization procedure is implemented in a computer program and is replicable.
Randomization unit
3271 graduates students where cluster randomize in 4 municipalities, Barranquilla, Bogotá, Pensilvaina and Tolima.
Clusters
4 municipalities Barranquilla, Bogotá, Pensilvaina and Tolima
Observations
The survey is administered to the full sample of 3,271 graduating students across four municipalities, Barranquilla, Bogotá, Pensilvania, and Tolima, which constitute the study clusters. However, the effective sample used in the analysis will depend on survey response rates.
Arms
Each treatment arm will have 50% of the sample 1635 in treatment and 1636 in the control
Primary outcomes
Assessment of whether attending university is worth it, elicited through a peer-advice framing to reduce social desirability bias; and expected returns and labor market opportunities associated with obtaining a bachelor’s degree.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords