The transition from high school to higher education or vocational training is a critical juncture that profoundly shapes individual career trajectories and long-term socio-economic mobility. However, students from low socioeconomic backgrounds are significantly less likely to enroll in higher education. While financial aid programs exist to alleviate these inequalities, many students do not take up aid because of misperceptions. This paper investigates how information frictions within households contribute to these disparities, focusing on misperceptions among both pupils and parents about financial aid eligibility and repayment conditions. Since eligibility depends on parental income, pupils’ post-secondary choices are shaped not only by their own beliefs, but also by the information, constraints, and perceptions of their parents. To examine this, we design a large-scale, school-level randomized controlled trial involving matched student-parent dyads. The intervention leverages a multilingual AI chatbot that proactively provides individualized financial aid guidance. By treating students, parents, or both, we causally identify the impact of resolving member-specific misperceptions on the realized post-secondary pathway, revealing how parental constraints and beliefs shape educational inequalities. We further build on this intervention to study post-secondary decision-making more broadly, estimating the relative influence of pupils and parents in shaping educational choices.
Intervention
We study a 2×2 randomized intervention in which households (high-school students matched to a parent or guardian) are given access to a multilingual AI chatbot delivered through a study smartphone app. All households receive the chatbot. A specialized financial-aid module is activated for the student, the parent, both, or neither, yielding four treatment arms.
Experimental design
2×2 cluster-randomized field experiment with students in their penultimate year of German high school (Abitur) and their parents/guardians. Participants register through a study smartphone app and are followed for 17 months across baseline, midline, and endline surveys plus monthly pulse measurements. Randomization to the four arms is at the school level. The primary analysis is intention-to-treat with standard errors clustered at the school level.
Design details
Randomization method
The chatbot-arm randomization is performed ex ante at the regional school-cluster level over the full population of eligible schools in Germany. Each school ID is mapped to a school site, and sites are grouped into regional clusters based primarily on geographic proximity, using coordinate-based grid cells where latitude/longitude are available, with a postal-code fallback where coordinates are missing. Duplicate or same-location school IDs are grouped before clustering. Randomization is stratified by federal state. Within each state, regional clusters are assigned to the four arms of the 2x2 design (control, student-only access, parent-only access, and access for both student and parent). Rather than an independent uniform draw per cluster, the assignment is optimized to balance the arms within state, with highest priority on the number of clearly Abitur-granting schools and the number of already-registered student/parent-child pairs, and lower priority on likely-Abitur schools and unclear school-like cases. The assigned arm is then mapped back to every school ID in the cluster, so that all schools in the same regional cluster receive the same treatment arm. Each participant from a given school, whether already registered or registering later, inherits that school's arm with no further draw. Realized balance on the stratification and clustering covariates, and on additional covariates including urban vs. rural location and school-mean socioeconomic status, will be reported, and these variables will be included as controls in ITT specifications for robustness.
The "Level-Up" module-order randomization for the three gamified educational modules following the initial fake-news module is performed at the individual student level using a uniform random draw over the six possible orderings, independent of chatbot assignment.
Randomization unit
The chatbot intervention is randomized at the regional school-cluster level. Geographically proximate schools are grouped into clusters, each cluster is assigned to one of the four arms, and the assignment is mapped back to the school IDs within the cluster so that all participants from a given school receive that school's (cluster's) assigned arm.
The module-order randomization is at the individual student level and is orthogonal to the chatbot treatment assignment.
Clusters
The randomization unit is the regional school-cluster, so the relevant cluster count is the number of regional clusters formed across the full population of eligible schools in Germany, not the number of individual schools. Germany has approximately 3,100 Gymnasien at the Abitur level. Grouping geographically proximate schools, and merging duplicate or same-location school IDs, reduces this to a smaller number of regional clusters, which sets the upper bound on the number of randomization units. The number of clusters and schools actually represented in the analysis sample is determined ex post by the set of schools among realized participants, as recruitment is conducted top-down via app sign-ups rather than through pre-recruited schools. Based on realistic uptake assumptions from our recruitment channels, we expect several hundred schools to be represented, corresponding to a somewhat smaller number of regional clusters, with the precise figures depending on sign-up dynamics over the recruitment window.
To improve geographic and demographic coverage, we reserve the right to conduct targeted recruitment campaigns in regions or school types that are underrepresented relative to the national distribution at interim monitoring points. Chatbot-arm assignment is fixed at the cluster level for the full population of eligible schools, so such targeted outreach affects only which pre-randomized clusters and schools become active and does not change the arm assigned to any given school. Any targeted campaigns conducted will be documented and reported.
Observations
19,612 students, each matched to at least one parent or guardian, for a total of approximately 39,000 individual participants. Minimum sample we aim for: 10,000 students (≈20,000 individual participants once parents are matched), corresponding to the floor scenario for our recruitment outreach.
Arms
We target an approximately equal split across the four arms, around one quarter of clusters per arm, within each federal state. Because clusters are assigned through a balancing procedure at the regional school-cluster level rather than an independent uniform draw, cluster counts per arm are close to equal but need not be exactly equal, since the procedure prioritizes balance on the key covariates (the number of clearly Abitur-granting schools and already-registered student/parent-child pairs first, likely-Abitur and unclear school-like cases second). Further deviations from exact equality are expected because (a) sign-ups remain open until the summer break and (b) realized cluster sizes vary across schools. Realized arm sizes will be reported, both in terms of clusters and schools and in terms of participants.
Primary outcomes
1. Realized post-high-school pathway
2. Path–preference match
3. Field quality
4. Distance from parental home
5. Corrected financial-aid beliefs
6. Financial-aid application
Secondary outcomes
1. Chatbot information demand
2. Intra-household decision weights
3. Heterogeneity
4. Intra-household communication
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.