Cash in hand and savings decisions

How to cite

Spantig, Lisa. 2017. "Cash in hand and savings decisions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001870. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1870-10.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lisa Spantig*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001870
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1870-10.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2017-02-20 – 2021-05-01
Countries
Philippines (Laguna)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1870

Abstract

Most of the poor receive their income in cash and they seem to readily spend it instead of saving some of it. Offering commitment devices to overcome present bias or sending reminders to tackle inattention and forgetfulness only seem to yield modest improvements. In particular, usage levels of formal savings account usually remain low. What if the act itself, depositing the cash into the account or handing it over to the loan officer is associated with non-monetary costs that prevents individuals from saving? Based on a literature that shows reduced spending levels when cash is the means of transaction, I hypothesize that a "cash-in-hand" effect also exists for savings, i.e. individuals become attached to their cash and are reluctant to 'give it away' to save it. I test this hypothesis in a framed field experiment with rural and semi-urban poor in the Philippines ruling out other explanations for undersavings (part 1). As this bias arises due to mental accounting, a small intervention additionally tries to change how participants think about the cash they could save (part 2).

Experimental design

The study consists of a framed field experiment (part 1) and a field experiment (part 2). The first part tests the 'cash-in-hand' effect on savings decisions. Participants take part in a paid individual survey and decide whether and if so, how much of their participation fee they want to save in their existing savings account. The treatment variation consists of receiving the participation fee at the very beginning of the survey, thus holding on to the cash when making the decision vs. receiving the remainder of the participation fee (everything that is not saved) directly after the savings decision. The second part of the study is a field experiment testing the effect of a combination of mental accounting and reminders on savings.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done in STATA.
Randomization unit
Part 1 will be randomized on the individual level (Cash-in-hand) and on the session level (participation fee amount). Part 2 will be randomized on barangays (smallest administrative unit) to avoid confounding effects from very close centers.
Clusters
Part 1: no cluster for cash-in-hand treatment, 30 clusters for participation fee treatment Part 2: 20 barangays
Observations
Part 1: 300 individuals (microfianance clients) Part 2: 871 individuals (if all active clients attend the meetings)
Arms
Part 1: - 75 individuals control and normal participation fee - 75 individuals cash-in-hand and normal participation fee - 75 individuals control and surprise participation fee - 75 individuals cash-in-hand and surprise participation fee Part 2: - 3 barangays (100 individuals) CONTROL - 10 barangays (447 individuals) REMINDER & LABEL - 7 barangays (324 individuals) REMINDER - all remaining barangays served by the three involved branches of the partner MFI serve as additional control (based on administrative data only)
Primary outcomes
Part 1: decision to save during the survey (amount saved) Part 2: weekly savings deposits into personal savings account in week 1-4 after the intervention, savings balance on this account after week 4 (short run outcomes); reassessment of these outcomes after 6 month (medium rum outcomes)

Papers from this trial

  1. Cash is an important means of transaction, generally assumed to be fungible. However, behavioral economics and consumer research show that ‘cash in hand’, physically holding on to cash and then handing it away, affects purchasing decisions. I study how cash in hand influences decisions in a different, but very important domain: savings. Savings accounts are a promising tool for reducing poverty, but the use of savings accounts is often puzzlingly low. Holding on to cash that needs to be physically deposited into a savings account may increase the psychological costs of saving. This study experimentally identifies the causal effect of cash in hand on savings deposits of female microfinance clients in the Philippines. In contrast to many laboratory and several field studies with similar interventions, I do not find reduced savings deposits due to cash in hand. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jebo.2021.06.008

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords