Testing Lean & Green Corporate Incentives: Experimental Evidence

How to cite

Erdmann, Maximilian Vincent; Walkowitz, Gari. 2026. "Testing Lean & Green Corporate Incentives: Experimental Evidence." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018696. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18696-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maximilian Vincent Erdmann* , Gari Walkowitz

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018696
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18696-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-12 – 2026-09-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C91, D91, M54, Q56, L23
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18696

Abstract

Lean & Green combines lean management practices with environmental sustainability goals to align efficiency improvements with systematic reductions in resource use and environmental externalities across production and organizational processes. The success of corporate Lean & Green initiatives critically depends on bottom-up implementation, as employee involvement in continuous improvement processes enables the consistent realization of both efficiency and environmental gains. Companies employ a variety of financial and non-financial incentive strategies to motivate employee engagement in Lean & Green initiatives; yet causal empirical evidence on the effectiveness of such strategies remains limited. Using a large-scale behavioral experiment with industry professionals, we systematically examine under controlled conditions the effectiveness of different Lean & Green incentive strategies in shaping employees’ willingness to actively engage in such initiatives and their implications for corporate efficiency and environmental outcomes. To better understand the psychological mechanisms underlying participants’ decisions to engage in Lean & Green initiatives, we measure motivational orientations using the Multidimensional Work Motivation Scale (MWMS), as well as individual risk and environmental preferences. The study thus contributes novel causal empirical evidence that enables companies to assess which incentive strategies are financially viable while simultaneously delivering environmental benefits, and offers actionable implications for managers.

Intervention

In an online behavioral experiment, participants take on the role of production workers and make a binary decision between working business-as-usual (BAU) and investing in continuous improvement processes (CIP).

In all treatment conditions, a Lean and Green measure is introduced. In the baseline treatment (T1), no additional corporate incentive scheme is implemented. In treatments 2-5, we additionally introduce and test different types of corporate interventions:

T1: Baseline – Basic Lean & Green setting without corporate intervention
T2: Corporate intervention – Fixed monetary reward
T3: Corporate intervention – Fixed social reward
T4: Corporate intervention – Variable monetary reward
T5: Corporate intervention – Variable social reward

The reward is granted if participants invest in continuous improvement processes and achieve an efficiency improvement. In the monetary reward treatments (T2 and T4), the reward is implemented as an additional monetary payment. In the social reward treatments, the reward is implemented as non-monetary recognition. In the fixed reward treatments, the reward is of the same size regardless of the magnitude of the efficiency improvement. In the variable reward treatments, the reward increases with the magnitude of the efficiency improvement.

In T3, participants who invest in continuous improvement processes and achieve an efficiency improvement are listed on the Lean & Green Recognition Board. The recognition board displays the participant’s self-chosen display name, the change in the company’s efficiency score, and the associated reduction in CO₂ emissions. The recognition board is made available only after the experiment has been completed and is visible only to participants assigned to the respective treatment.

In addition, in T5, participants who achieve a substantial efficiency improvement receive a certificate of recognition. The certificate includes the participant’s self-chosen display name, the achieved change in the company’s efficiency score, and the associated reduction in CO₂ emissions. The certificate is issued privately after completion of the experiment via Prolific and is accessible only to the respective participant.

Experimental design

Participants will be randomly allocated to one of several treatments by the experimental software. Each participant will take part in only one treatment. To comply with ethical principles, participants will be informed about their rights, the voluntary nature of participation, the possibility to withdraw from the study, and the processing of their data. By continuing with the study, participants provide their consent to voluntary participation and data processing.

After providing consent, participants will read the experimental instructions. They will then answer four comprehension check questions to ensure that they understand the experiment and the decision situation. Participants can only proceed if they answer all comprehension check questions correctly and do not provide a wrong answer twice for the same question. Participants who fail the comprehension checks will not be able to continue with the experiment.

Participants will then make their main decision, choosing between business-as-usual (BAU) and investing in continuous improvement processes (CIP). The outcome of this decision is determined probabilistically: for BAU, either no efficiency change, a small efficiency deterioration, or a substantial efficiency deterioration may occur; for CIP, either no efficiency improvement, a small efficiency improvement, or a substantial efficiency improvement may occur. To avoid biasing subsequent responses, participants will only learn the specific outcome of their decision, their corresponding monetary and non-monetary rewards, and the amount of CO₂ reduction at the end of the experiment. After the main decision, participants will complete several questionnaires.

In contrast to the basic treatment, participants in treatments 2-5 make the main decision additionally under incentives induced by corporate intervention schemes.

The experiment will be conducted online.

Design details

Randomization method
The experiment will be conducted online. Treatment assignment is randomized at the individual level using a computer-based lottery procedure implemented in the experimental software.
Randomization unit
We randomize at the level of the individual. Each participant is assigned to one of the five treatment conditions (Treatment 1– Treatment 5).
Clusters
500 English-fluent individuals from European countries with non-managerial work experience in industry sectors or occupational areas relevant to Lean and Green practices.
Observations
500 English-fluent individuals from European countries with non-managerial work experience in industry sectors or occupational areas relevant to Lean and Green practices.
Arms
Each treatment will include 100 participants, i.e., we will collect 100 observations per treatment. In total, we will collect 5 x 100 = 500 observations.
Primary outcomes
The study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of different corporate incentive strategies in shaping employees’ decisions between continuing business-as-usual (BAU) and investing in continuous improvement processes (CIP).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords