Information, Beliefs, and Public Preferences for Higher Education Financing and Reform in Spain: A Survey Experiment

How to cite

Sanz, Ismael; Martínez-Matute, Marta; Ballestar, Maria Teresa; Sainz, Jorge; Goitia, Antonio Cabrales. 2026. "Information, Beliefs, and Public Preferences for Higher Education Financing and Reform in Spain: A Survey Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018656. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18656-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ismael Sanz* , Marta Martínez-Matute , Maria Teresa Ballestar , Jorge Sainz , Antonio Cabrales Goitia

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018656
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18656-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-06-01 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I22, I28, H52, D72, D83
Secondary IDs
PI-ONT-UC3M
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18656

Abstract

This study examines how information shapes Spanish citizens' preferences over the financing and reform of higher education. We run a pre-registered survey experiment with at least 5,000 nationally representative Spanish adults.
Respondents are randomly assigned to one of five conditions: a control group that receives a neutral placebo text about general facts of the Spanish university system, and four treatment arms that each receive a distinct block of factual information before answering policy-preference questions. The four treatments are: (1) information on the labour market earnings premium of a university degree relative to higher vocational training; (2) information on the level of public expenditure on universities in Spain and the fiscal trade-offs of increasing it; (3) information on quality heterogeneity across Spanish public universities; and (4) information on alternative financing systems, including income-contingent loans and means-tested fees in use in the United Kingdom, Australia, Chile and New Zealand.
The two pre-registered primary outcomes are support for higher tuition fees in public universities and support for higher public spending on universities even at the cost of taxes or budget cuts elsewhere, both elicited before and after the information treatment. A separate primary outcome for the quality-heterogeneity treatment captures support for budgetary accountability of public universities and the priority destination of additional public spending. Secondary outcomes include the accuracy of prior beliefs about earnings, public costs and university quality, the perceived fairness of alternative financing systems, and willingness to pay.
The analysis applies the analysis-of-covariance specification described in the pre-analysis plan, conditioning on pre-treatment outcomes and baseline covariates. We pre-specify Bonferroni correction across the four treatment-versus-control comparisons on the primary outcomes, with Romano-Wolf step-down adjusted p-values reported as a complement. Pre-specified heterogeneity analyses examine differences in treatment effects by prior belief accuracy, educational attainment, household income, gender and relation to the university system.
This study replicates and extends Lergetporer and Woessmann (2023, Journal of Public Economics) to the Spanish context, and complements it with three additional informational treatments not previously tested.

Intervention

The intervention is an informational message delivered within an online survey. Participants are randomly assigned to one of five conditions. The control group receives a neutral placebo text describing general facts about the Spanish university system (number of universities, degree structure under the Bologna Process, enrolment figures, Erasmus+ participation), without information relevant to financing preferences or labour-market returns. The four treatment arms each receive a different factual information block of approximately 100 to 150 words, accompanied by source citations: (T1) the labour-market earnings premium of a university degree relative to higher vocational training (FP de Grado Superior); (T2) the level of Spanish public expenditure on universities relative to the OECD average, together with the explicit fiscal trade-offs that an increase in spending would entail; (T3) quality heterogeneity across Spanish public universities in international rankings, graduate employment rates, salaries, and research output; (T4) three alternative financing systems used internationally (means-tested fees, merit-based scholarships, and income-contingent loans), with country examples.

Experimental design

Online survey experiment fielded to a nationally representative sample of Spanish adults (18 years or older). The survey consists of four sequential blocks administered in a single session. Block 1 collects sociodemographic information, the respondent's relation to the university system, self-rated knowledge, and frequency of following news on higher education. Block 2 elicits prior beliefs about labour-market earnings premiums, public financing levels, and quality heterogeneity, as well as pre-treatment versions of the policy preference outcomes. Block 3 contains the randomised information treatment (one of five conditions) and an arm-specific manipulation check for the four treatment arms. Block 4 contains the post-treatment outcomes, the secondary outcomes, an attention check, self-reported survey duration, and an item on perceived demand effects. There is no follow-up wave. The fieldwork uses a representative online panel of Spanish adults provided by a commercial survey supplier. Randomisation is implemented at the individual level by the survey platform prior to Block 2. The analysis follows an analysis-of-covariance specification with the pre-treatment value of the outcome and pre-specified baseline covariates as right-hand side variables, with heteroskedasticity-robust standard errors. Multiple hypothesis testing is addressed via Bonferroni correction for four pre-specified treatment-versus-control comparisons on the primary outcomes, complemented by Romano-Wolf step-down adjusted p-values. Clarification, registered before any author has accessed the outcome data (see forecast lock, Social Science Prediction Platform study sspp-0b2fyx-T, release date 12 August 2026). The data files delivered by the survey firm on 28 July 2026 remain unopened. The PAP defined the primary analysis sample as respondents passing the post-treatment attention check (AC_PASS = 1). Following external review, and because conditioning on a post-treatment variable can compromise randomisation if treatments affect attention (Montgomery, Nyhan and Torres 2018), the primary sample is the full randomised sample; the restriction to attention-check passers becomes a pre-specified robustness check, and we will test whether attention-check pass rates differ by treatment arm. No other element of the PAP changes. (Clarification dated 10 August 2026.)

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation performed by the QuestionPro survey platform at the individual respondent level, immediately before the pre-treatment belief block, using QuestionPro's built-in random assignment functionality with a documented seed.
Randomization unit
Individual respondent. No clustering.
Clusters
Not applicable (individual-level randomisation, no clustering). For form-filling purposes: 5,000 individuals.
Observations
5,000 individual respondents (Spanish adults, 18 years or older).
Arms
Control: 1,000 (20.0%); T1 (labour-market returns): 1,250 (25.0%); T2 (financing and fiscal trade-offs): 915 (18.3%); T3 (university quality heterogeneity): 915 (18.3%); T4 (alternative financing systems): 915 (18.3%). Total: 5,000.
Primary outcomes
Two pre-registered primary outcomes are measured post-treatment on a five-point Likert scale: (Y1) support for raising tuition fees in Spanish public universities; (Y2) support for higher public spending on universities even at the cost of higher taxes or cuts in other public spending categories. For the quality-heterogeneity treatment (T3), two additional pre-registered primary outcomes are: support for budgetary accountability of public universities (binarised from a four-option item), and the priority destination of additional public spending on universities (categorical, with pre-specified binary contrasts).
Secondary outcomes
Pre-registered secondary outcomes include: (S1) accuracy of prior beliefs about the earnings premium of a university degree, and post-treatment numerical earnings beliefs (T1 and Control only); (S2) accuracy of prior beliefs about the share and per-student level of public financing of universities, used as a covariate and moderator; (S3) perceived fairness of five alternative financing systems, and identification of the system perceived as most socially just (mechanism for T4); (S4) for treatment arms other than T3, the accountability and priority-of-spending items also reported as secondary outcomes; (S5) willingness to pay for a year of public university education, as an ordered categorical measure complementing Y1. Exploratory outcomes include opinions on teaching and research quality, perceived university contribution to societal goals on a 0 to 10 scale, comparison with the EU average, and self-reported change in earnings perception.
Sponsors
Name: Universidad Carlos III de Madrid Location: Getafe (Madrid, Spain) Url: https://www.uc3m.es/inicio

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords