The Effect of Gendered Language on Perceived Gender Suitability of Occupations: Evidence from an Experiment with Middle School Students

How to cite

Cappelletti, Dominique; Burlacu, Sergiu; Bazzoli, Martina; Russo, Iunio Quarto. 2026. "The Effect of Gendered Language on Perceived Gender Suitability of Occupations: Evidence from an Experiment with Middle School Students." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018653. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18653-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Dominique Cappelletti* , Sergiu Burlacu , Martina Bazzoli , Iunio Quarto Russo

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018653
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18653-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2026-05-01 – 2026-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J16, C90, D91, I24
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18653

Abstract

In many languages, including Italian, masculine grammatical forms are conventionally used to refer to mixed-gender or gender-unspecified groups — a practice known as the generic masculine. A growing body of experimental evidence shows that this convention is not cognitively neutral: exposure to masculine generic forms tends to activate predominantly male mental representations, with consequences for how individuals perceive the gender suitability of specific roles. These effects are particularly relevant when it comes to professions, where linguistic framing may contribute to reinforcing gender stereotypes about who belongs in specific fields. This is especially consequential during early adolescence, when young people are forming their occupational aspirations and making their first educational choices. This study examines how different ways of linguistically presenting occupational titles — generic masculine, pair forms, or professional domain labels — affect middle school students’ perceptions of gender suitability for a set of STEM and non-STEM occupations and sports. We also examine whether participation in an education program, aimed at introducing middle school students to STEM through hands-on laboratory activities and at building awareness of gender stereotypes and self-confidence, moderates the effect of linguistic framing.

Intervention

Participants are presented with a list of 25 occupations and sports and asked to indicate whether each is more suitable for men, for women, or for both. The list includes STEM occupations (e.g., engineer, biologist), non-STEM occupations (e.g., lawyer, photographer), and sports (e.g., skiing, cycling). Items are further classified as grammatically declinable — i.e., occupational titles that have distinct masculine and feminine forms in Italian (e.g., ingegnere/ingegnera) — or grammatically invariable — i.e., titles whose form does not vary by gender (e.g., farmacista). Participants are randomly assigned at the individual level to one of three language conditions in which the items are presented: in Condition 1 (generic masculine), all items are presented using masculine grammatical forms; in Condition 2 (pair form), declinable items are presented with both masculine and feminine forms; in Condition 3 (professional domain), items are replaced by their corresponding disciplinary or professional domain labels. To illustrate how the three language conditions work, consider the item "Engineer": in Condition 1 it appears as ingegnere (generic masculine), in Condition 2 as ingegnere/ingegnera (pair form), and in Condition 3 as ingegneria (professional domain). For invariable items such as "Data analyst", the form is identical across Conditions 1 and 2 (analista dati), while Condition 3 uses the domain label (analisi dati).

Experimental design

This is a three-arm between-subjects experiment embedded in the follow-up questionnaire of the SPARKLE RCT. The primary analytic sample is restricted to the control group of the SPARKLE RCT to obtain an uncontaminated estimate of the effect of linguistic framing. Students are randomly assigned at the individual level to one of three language conditions for a survey question presenting a list of 25 occupations and sports and asking whether each is more suitable for men, for women, or for both. The three conditions differ only in how the occupational items are linguistically framed: generic masculine job title, pair form (both masculine and feminine), or the profession name. Randomization to language condition is independent of prior assignment to the SPARKLE treatment.

Design details

Randomization method
Individual-level randomization using a computer-generated random assignment algorithm (python within oTree) at the time of questionnaire administration.
Randomization unit
Individual student
Clusters
Standard errors are clustered at the individual level to account for the multiple observations per student (one per item). 785 students (assuming no absenteism during the day of the survey).
Observations
19 (professions) x 785 (pupils) = 14,915
Arms
Condition 1 (generic masculine): approx. 261 Condition 2 (pair form): approx. 261 Condition 3 (professional domain): approx. 261
Primary outcomes
A binary indicator (1 = suitable for both genders, 0 otherwise) for each item × student observation, estimated separately for boys and girls. The main model uses the sample of grammatically declinable items (19 items) for hypotheses H1, H2,H3, and H5. A separate model on grammatically invariable items (6 items) tests hypothesis H4.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcome examines whether the effect of linguistic framing on gender suitability perceptions differs between students who participated in the SPARKLE education program and those who did not.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords