The impact of eligibility explanations on satisfaction with cash transfer programs

How to cite

Aiken, Emily. 2026. "The impact of eligibility explanations on satisfaction with cash transfer programs." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018645. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18645-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Emily Aiken*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018645
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18645-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-06-24 – 2026-08-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18645

Abstract

Many cash transfer programs and other anti-poverty interventions target benefits at the individual or household level, with only a subset of community members – typically those identified to be poorest – receiving assistance. Perceptions of the targeting process among both beneficiaries and non-beneficiaries are likely to play an important role in shaping program success, yet many programs do not disclose the criteria used to determine eligibility. This randomized controlled trial examines how providing information about eligibility criteria affects key community outcomes, including program satisfaction, perceived fairness and accuracy, perceived respect, and social cohesion. Using individual-level randomization of eligibility explanations in a GiveDirectly cash transfer program in Rwanda, this study evaluates the impact of both (i) the level of detail included in the explanation and (ii) the mode of communication through which it is delivered (phone call versus text message).

Intervention

The intervention is the delivery of information about eligibility criteria for the cash transfer program. The information will be delivered after eligible households have been (1) visited by a GiveDirectly field officer to collect enrollment details and (2) provided with their first of two monthly cash transfers by GiveDirectly. Explanations will be delivered to both eligible and ineligible households in beneficiary villages. The randomization is individual-level, with a 2x2 design, so there are four versions of the intervention:

Phone vs. text:
Phone call: The phone call is an outbound call from a GiveDirectly field officer to the phone number collected at enrollment (for eligible households) or provided by village leaders (for ineligible households)
Text message: The text message is an outbound message from GiveDirectly to the phone number collected at enrollment (for eligible households) or provided by village leaders (for ineligible households)

Content variants:
Less information: The “less information” version is a short script/message informing the household that they are (or are not) eligible for the GiveDirectly program, and stating that the households eligible for the program were the ones identified to be poorest in the community.
More information: The “more information” version is a longer script/message informing the household that they are (or are not) eligible for the GiveDirectly program, stating that the households eligible for the program were the ones identified to be poorest in the community, and providing some of the criteria used for identifying whether a household is poor, such as the floor material of the household, the level of education of household members, and the primary fuel used for cooking.

666 households will be in the control group. 333 households will be in each of the four treatment arms (phone x less information, phone x more information, text x less information, text x more information).

Experimental design

This RCT is embedded in a GiveDirectly cash transfer program conducted in Rwanda. Eligibility for the program is determined by whether the household is on a pre-identified list provided by the government (and eligibility for this list is based on a proxy means test). The activities in the program (flagged as GD operational activities or research activities) are as follows, in each eligible village:
[GD operational activity] GiveDirectly field officers visit the village and meet with community leaders to sensitize them to the program. During this meeting, they will also collect contact information (names and phone numbers) for households that will not be eligible (households not on the list provided by the government).
[GD operational activity] GiveDirectly field officers visit all households in the village that are on the eligibility list. They collect contact information (names and phone numbers) from these households as well as other information necessary for the standard GiveDirectly enrollment process. This door-to-door enrollment takes 2-5 days per village.
[GD operational activity] Within a week of enrollment, eligible households receive their first cash transfer.
[Research activity] Within a week of payments being delivered to eligible households, the explanation intervention occurs for all eligible or ineligible households with contact information collected by GiveDirectly (intervention details included in "intervention" above).
[Research activity] Within a week of the intervention, all eligible or ineligible households with contact information collected by GiveDirectly receive a phone call from a GiveDirectly field officer with the invitation to conduct a 30 minute phone survey about their impressions of the program. If respondents consent to participating, they proceed with the survey. Respondents will be surveyed in a random order.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
2,000 households
Observations
2,000 households
Arms
666 control households, 333 households in each of the four treatment arms
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are: Understanding of eligibility criteria Satisfaction with program Perceptions of fairness and accuracy of targeting Perceived dignity Social cohesion in community
Secondary outcomes
There are three secondary outcomes which describe specific subsets of the social cohesion outcome: Beneficiary-beneficiary social cohesion Nonbeneficiary-nonbeneficiary social cohesion Beneficiary-nonbeneficiary social cohesion: This outcome will be an index constructed from four variables, normalized to a 0-1 scale and equally weighted. It will be evaluated only for all households.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords