The Salience of Rights and Duties in Integration Agreements: Evidence from Jobseekers in France
How to cite
Geuna, Pietro; Uhlendorff, Arne; Rain, Audrey; Breda, Thomas; Briand, Lucie; Berg, Gerard Van den. 2026. "The Salience of Rights and Duties in Integration Agreements: Evidence from Jobseekers in France." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018614. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18614-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Integration agreements between job seekers and public employment services define mutual obligations for labor market integration, including job search requirements, the support provided by the agency, and the conditions under which compliance is monitored and sanctioned. We study how reminding job seekers of different dimensions of these commitments affects their job search behavior, their knowledge of the rules they are subject to, and their labor market outcomes. The study is conducted in the context of the French Contrat d'Engagement (CE), a mandatory integration agreement signed by job seekers and caseworkers upon registration with the French public employment service, France Travail. The CE includes a personalized action plan specifying activities to support labor market integration, the commitments of both the job seeker and the caseworker, and the potential consequences of non-compliance.
We implement a large-scale experiment among newly registered job seekers who have signed a CE. Each week, we sample the inflow of signatories and randomly assign them to one of three groups. About three weeks after signature, the first group (T1) receives an email reminding them of their commitments under the CE, the monitoring procedures used by France Travail, and the sanctions that may apply in case of non-compliance. The second group (T2) receives an email emphasizing the commitments of France Travail and their caseworker, the services available to them, and their rights as job seekers. The third group is the control group and receives no email.
Using administrative data from France Travail and two post-treatment surveys conducted one and six months after CE signature, we measure effects on job search behavior, jobseekers' understanding of their obligations and the associated sanctions, the perceived quality of the caseworker–jobseeker relationship, and labor market outcomes.
Intervention
The intervention consists of informational emails sent to newly registered job seekers who have signed a Contrat d'Engagement (CE) with their caseworker at France Travail. The CE is an integration agreement specifying a personalized action plan, the reciprocal commitments of the job seeker and the caseworker, and the conditions under which compliance is monitored and sanctioned.
Depending on treatment assignment, job seekers in the treated groups receive one of two emails approximately three weeks after they sign the CE. The first email reminds job seekers of their commitments under the CE, the monitoring procedures used by France Travail, and the sanctions that may apply in case of non-compliance. The second email reminds job seekers of the commitments of France Travail and their caseworker under the CE, of their rights as job seekers registered, and of the services available to them.
Jobseekers in the control group receive no email.
Experimental design
The experiment is implemented through emails sent to newly registered jobseekers shortly after they sign a Contrat d'Engagement (CE) with their caseworker at France Travail and based on randomization at the individual level. Each week, we sample the inflow of signatories who meet the inclusion criteria and randomly assign them — with equal probability — to one of three groups.
Treatment Arm 1 (T1): Around three weeks after the signature, job seekers receive an email reminding them of their obligations, the monitoring system, and potential sanctions in case of non-compliance.
Treatment Arm 2 (T2): Around three weeks after the signature, job seekers receive an email emphasizing the commitments of France Travail and their caseworker, the services available to them, and their rights as job seekers.
Control group: this group does not receive an email.
This design allows us to separately estimate the causal effects of the two treatments.
Our sample consists of jobseekers who had no previous contact with France Travail in the six months before their current registration, and who sign a CE in the first four months after their registration. The overall inflow sample consists of weekly cohorts of newly registered jobseekers entering the sample between June 2026 and December 2026.
During the same period, the agency-level randomization registered as AEARCTR-0017471 (Breda et al., 2026) assigns each France Travail agency to one of four arms (target setting, monitoring transparency, combined, control). The two trials are conducted simultaneously and independently, so each individual in the present trial belongs to an agency assigned to one of these four arms. We exploit this cross-randomization in our analyses.
During the experiment, approximately 25,000 job seekers are sampled per week, randomly split in equal proportion across the three experimental arms — yielding approximately 16,700 jobseekers who receive an email each week. We conduct two post-treatment surveys among the sampled population. The first survey is fielded approximately one month after CE signature and the second approximately six months after CE signature. For each survey wave, we target a sample size of around 30,000 completed interviews.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.