How does Status Seeking impact Conspicuous consumption choice?

How to cite

Nguyen, Tuan; Kim, Cuong Pham Thi; Stenger, Anne; Hergueux, Jerome. 2026. "How does Status Seeking impact Conspicuous consumption choice?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018602. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18602-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tuan Nguyen* , Cuong Pham Thi Kim , Anne Stenger , Jerome Hergueux

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018602
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18602-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-07-20 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D12 (Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis), Q50 (Environmental Economics: General), D91 (Micro-Based Behavioral Economics), C93 (Field Experiments)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18602

Abstract

This study examines how two competing status-signalling motivations, conspicuous consumption and conspicuous conservation, jointly shape individual product choice behaviour under fully incentivised field conditions. Conspicuous consumption refers to the utility individuals derive from signalling wealth and social standing through the acquisition of luxury or prestige goods. Conspicuous conservation refers to the utility derived from signalling a pro-environmental identity through visibly green choices. Both motivations are rooted in the same underlying desire for social recognition and reputation management, yet they direct individual resources toward fundamentally different ends. Despite their theoretical connection, the two constructs have rarely been analysed within a unified empirical framework, and existing evidence relies predominantly on hypothetical survey measures or laboratory tasks that abstract away from the real costs of status-motivated choice. This study addresses that gap by eliciting revealed product preferences through an incentivised field experiment in which respondents make a genuine choice among physical products they actually receive, under conditions of real monetary stakes, thereby generating behavioural evidence that is free from hypothetical bias and social desirability distortion.The study is conducted as an interviewer-administered field experiment with approximately 300 respondents in Hanoi and selected nearby provinces in Northern Vietnam. The central measurement instrument is the chocolate choice game, in which each respondent selects one of three physical chocolate products priced at approximately equal monetary value: an imported luxury chocolate bar serving as the conspicuous consumption stimulus, an organic-certified chocolate serving as the conspicuous conservation stimulus, and a conventional chocolate serving as the neutral reference category. The product the respondent selects is theirs to keep, making the choice genuinely consequential. Because all three options are priced within approximately five percent of one another, the choice cannot be driven by budget constraints and instead reflects the respondent's preferred mode of self-presentation through consumption. This design feature is critical: it isolates status-signalling motivation from both financial considerations and intrinsic product quality differences, yielding a clean revealed-preference measure of each respondent's dominant status orientation.Before being shown the options, each respondent is randomly assigned to one of three informational conditions in a between-subjects design. The luxury salience condition provides background information on the brand heritage and prestige of the luxury option, activating motivations associated with conspicuous consumption. The organic salience condition provides information on the environmental and social benefits of the organic option, activating motivations associated with conspicuous conservation. The control condition provides no additional attribute information. This randomised informational treatment allows the study to assess whether making a particular status dimension more cognitively accessible at the moment of choice shifts revealed product preferences above and beyond individual attitudinal differences.The attitudinal component of the study measures conspicuous consumption and conspicuous conservation orientations through established and adapted Likert-scale instruments, alongside moderator and control variables including environmental self-identity, status and social comparison orientation, social media visibility, prior green consumption behaviour, and perceived social rewards for green choices. A public good game in which respondents allocate a real monetary endowment of 4 EUR across a personal account, a local environmental project, and a general charity fund is administered as a control variable capturing baseline pro-environmental and prosocial orientation. Both the chocolate choice and the public good game are incentive-compatible through a random incentive system in which one task is selected at random for real payment at the end of the session, ensuring that all decisions reflect genuine preferences rather than cheap talk. Three community observability and reputation items are included as candidate instrumental variables for the endogenous attitudinal regressors.The study advances three primary hypotheses. First, individuals with stronger conspicuous conservation orientation are expected to select the organic chocolate at higher rates, with this effect mediated by perceived social visibility and anticipated reputational rewards within the local community. Second, individuals with stronger conspicuous consumption orientation are expected to select the luxury chocolate at higher rates, reflecting a preference for prestige signalling over green signalling when both are available at equal cost. Third, the informational treatment is expected to amplify the behavioural expression of each orientation: the organic salience condition should increase organic choice rates among respondents with high conspicuous conservation scores, while the luxury salience condition should increase luxury choice rates among respondents with high conspicuous consumption scores, with perceived social visibility moderating both effects. The use of real products and real payment is essential for testing these hypotheses credibly, since status-signalling motivations are known to operate differently under consequential versus hypothetical conditions. A pilot study is scheduled for June 2026 at LEES-Strasbourg to validate the product stimuli and refine the instruments before main fieldwork begins in Vietnam.

Intervention

This study administers a single randomised informational intervention embedded within an incentivised field experiment involving real product choice and real monetary payment. Before being presented with three physical chocolate products, each respondent is randomly assigned to one of three informational conditions. In the luxury salience condition, the enumerator reads aloud a short narrative highlighting the brand heritage, production craftsmanship, and prestige associations of the imported luxury chocolate, making the status dimension of conspicuous consumption more cognitively accessible at the moment of choice. In the organic salience condition, the enumerator reads aloud a narrative highlighting the environmental and social benefits of the organic-certified chocolate, including its production without synthetic pesticides and its contribution to biodiversity and farming communities, making the green signalling dimension of conspicuous conservation more salient. In the control condition, no additional attribute information is provided beyond the product names and prices already visible to the respondent.

Critically, the intervention operates on actual consequential choices. The chocolate product each respondent selects is physically handed to them at the end of the session and is theirs to keep, so the decision carries real material consequences. This distinguishes the study from survey-based or hypothetical experimental designs in which respondents state a preference without bearing any cost. Because all three products are priced within approximately five percent of one another, the informational treatment cannot shift choices by altering perceived value for money. Any treatment effect on product selection must therefore reflect a genuine shift in the salience of status-signalling motivations rather than a reframing of economic trade-offs. A second incentivised task, the public good game, complements the product choice by measuring baseline prosocial and pro-environmental orientation through a real monetary allocation that may also be selected for payment under the random incentive system.

Experimental design

This is a between-subjects field experiment with individual-level randomisation into three informational treatment arms, conducted under fully incentivised conditions involving real physical products and real monetary payment. Approximately 300 respondents are recruited in Hanoi and nearby provinces in Northern Vietnam. Each respondent is randomly assigned to one of three informational conditions before making a consequential product choice in the chocolate choice game: a luxury salience condition, an organic salience condition, or a control condition. The chosen product is physically delivered to the respondent at the end of the session, making the decision genuinely costly and behaviourally meaningful. This design addresses a critical limitation of the existing literature on conspicuous consumption and conspicuous conservation, which has relied predominantly on hypothetical choice tasks, stated-preference surveys, or laboratory experiments with artificial stimuli. By eliciting real product choices with real consequences in a natural field setting, the study generates evidence on status-signalling behaviour that is externally valid and free from hypothetical bias. After the game, all respondents complete an attitudinal questionnaire and a public good game allocation task, both of which are also incentive-compatible through the random incentive system.

Design details

Randomization method
Individual-level randomisation using a computer-generated block randomisation list produced before fieldwork begins, stratified by fieldwork session to ensure approximate balance across the three treatment arms within each day of data collection.
Randomization unit
Individual respondent. Although respondents complete the session in groups of two to three for logistical reasons, all decisions are made individually and treatment assignment is fully independent across respondents. The design is not clustered.
Clusters
300 individuals (the design is not clustered; the unit of randomisation and the unit of observation are identical)
Observations
300 respondents with various occupations
Arms
Potentially 100 respondents in the luxury salience condition, 100 respondents in the organic salience condition, 100 respondents in the control condition.
Primary outcomes
The two co-primary outcome variables are both derived from the incentivised chocolate choice game in which respondents select a real physical product they actually receive. The first is a binary indicator for conspicuous conservation behaviour, taking the value one if the respondent selects the organic-certified chocolate and zero otherwise. The second is a binary indicator for conspicuous consumption behaviour, taking the value one if the respondent selects the imported luxury chocolate and zero otherwise. Because the choice is consequential and involves a real product at real cost, these indicators provide revealed-preference measures of each respondent's dominant status-signalling orientation under field conditions, free from the hypothetical bias that affects attitudinal self-reports and stated-preference measures.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes include the full three-category chocolate choice variable, the amount allocated to the environmental project in the public good game, and the amount allocated to the general charity fund. The public good game allocations serve as control variables in the primary regression specifications, capturing baseline pro-environmental and prosocial orientation independently of the incentivised product choice, but they are also reported as secondary outcomes in their own right to characterise the sample's broader distributional preferences. Additional secondary outcomes are the perceived social visibility score from the post-choice manipulation check and the individual scale scores for green signalling motivation, perceived social rewards for green consumption, and identity alignment via consumption, which are examined as potential mediators of the treatment effects on the primary outcomes.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords