Can Household Engagement Shift Care Burdens? A Randomized Experiment with Unpaid Caregivers in Antioquia, Colombia
How to cite
Echeverri, Manuel Felipe Rojas; Rodríguez-Valencia, Amalia; Abril, Veronica; Verbel, Yuliet. 2026. "Can Household Engagement Shift Care Burdens? A Randomized Experiment with Unpaid Caregivers in Antioquia, Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018586. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18586-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study uses a randomized controlled trial to evaluate whether involving other household members in the training process of Antioquia's Departmental Care System (SCA) shifts the distribution of unpaid care work and related outcomes among women caregivers in Colombia. The experiment is embedded in the 2026 cohort of the SCA's formative program across 51 prioritized municipalities. Using a 2x2 factorial design, we evaluate two household-inclusive interventions: a WhatsApp-based information campaign delivering content for each thematic component of the formative program, in which both the participating woman and a co-resident adult household member she nominates receive an infogram and audio message summarizing that component's main learning and prompting household conversation on care responsibilities (Component B, individual-level randomization); and a family closing session at program end, to which women invite a household member to attend jointly (Component C, municipality-level randomization). Primary outcomes are hours of unpaid care work per day, hours of paid work per day, an index of gender norms, and disposition to engage in paid work, all measured at endline.
Intervention
The experiment is embedded in the apuesta formativa (formative program) of the Sistema Departamental del Cuidado de Antioquia (SCA),
an initiative of the Governorate of Antioquia designed to strengthen the autonomy, leadership, and well-being of women caregivers. The
formative program started in 2025 and has an ongoing 2026 cohort. It is organized into three thematic schools: Del pasado, presente y
futuro (identity, life planning, and productive projects), Del amor propio (self-care and economic autonomy), and De las autonomías
(gender rights, labor autonomy, and civic participation). Each school comprises several modules delivered through in-person group sessions
at the municipal level. The 2026 stage, on which this study focuses, covers nine modules across several sessions and emphasizes deepening
the reflections from 2025 into concrete tools for leadership, economic autonomy, and rights-based participation. The program is directed at
women identified by municipal administrations and Governorate databases as unpaid caregivers of children, the elderly, or persons
with disabilities or illness. Participation is voluntary, and the program does not involve the women's household members in any of its
standard activities.
The two interventions evaluated in this study are designed to extend the program's reach into the household by involving a co-resident
adult member alongside the participating woman. Both are additions to the standard program and do not modify its content or delivery.
Component B — WhatsApp-based information campaign
Component B consists of a WhatsApp-based information campaign that delivers content for each thematic component of the formative program. The intervention has three arms, with women assigned in a 2:1:1 ratio to control, individual-delivery treatment, and household-delivery treatment respectively.
For each thematic component, treated women receive two pieces of content: an infographic and an audio message. The infographic is a
didactic image that summarizes the main learning of that component and includes conversation-opener questions intended to prompt
discussion between the woman and her household member about the topics covered in the session, including care responsibilities,
gender roles, and time use. The audio message covers the same content in spoken form. The two formats carry identical information and are
always delivered together, so that all participants have an accessible way to engage with the material regardless of reading proficiency or
visual limitations.
The three arms differ only in whom receives the content:
Arm 0 (Control, N ≈ 703): Women receive no infographic or audio message. The research team does not contact them or any household
member through this campaign.
Arm 1 (Individual delivery, N ≈ 351): The infographic and audio message are delivered only to the woman herself.
Arm 2 (Household delivery, N ≈ 352): The infographic and audio message are delivered to both the woman and a co-resident adult
household member she nominated at baseline. Both recipients receive identical content simultaneously.
This three-arm design allows us to separately identify: (i) the effect of the information campaign itself, comparing individual
delivery to control; (ii) the incremental effect of involving a household member, comparing household delivery to individual delivery;
and (iii) the total effect of the household-inclusive intervention, comparing household delivery to control.
The study universe for Component B is 1,406 women, corresponding to those who completed the baseline survey (LB26) among the 2,063
attendees of the 2026 formative program cohort who were reachable by mobile phone. Women who did not complete the baseline survey are
not included in Component B but remain eligible for Component C.
Component C — Family closing session
Component C consists of a family closing session held at the end of the formative program. Women attending the program in treatment
municipalities are invited to bring a co-resident adult household member or close family contact to a final program session. The
session is facilitated by program staff and focuses on the themes covered throughout the formative program, with particular emphasis
on care co-responsibility, time use, and household task distribution. Women in control municipalities receive the standard program closing
without this session. To avoid anticipatory effects or changes in behavior prior to the session, women are not informed about the
existence of Component C until the invitation is issued at program closure.
Experimental design
Experimental Design
The experiment evaluates two household-inclusive components of a
public caregiver training program (Sistema Departamental del Cuidado
de Antioquia, SCA) in Colombia: (1) a WhatsApp-based information
campaign delivering content to the woman and a co-resident adult
household member throughout the program (Component B), and (2) a
family closing session attended jointly by the woman and a household
member at the end of the program (Component C). These two components
are co-primary and form a 3x2 factorial design.
Study Population
The experimental universe consists of women attending the 2026
cohort of the SCA's formative program (apuesta formativa) across
46 prioritized municipalities in Antioquia (following exclusion of
five municipalities with persistent operational issues: Santo Domingo,
Vigía del Fuerte, San Juan de Urabá, Jericó, and Murindó). All
women who have attended at least one program session in 2026 in
these municipalities are eligible for Component C. Women who also
completed the baseline survey (LB26) are eligible for Component B.
Design Overview
The experiment combines two independent randomizations:
Component B — WhatsApp-based information campaign (co-primary):
At the individual level, 1,406 women who completed the baseline
survey are randomized to one of three arms in a 2:1:1 ratio:
- Arm 0 (Control, N ≈ 703): no information campaign
- Arm 1 (Individual delivery, N ≈ 351): infographic and audio
message delivered only to the woman
- Arm 2 (Household delivery, N ≈ 352): infographic and audio
message delivered to both the woman and a co-resident adult
household member she nominated at baseline
Randomization is stratified by municipality × sub-region × number
of prior attendance sessions (categorized as 0, 1–2, 3+), using
blocks of 4.
The information campaign is delivered via WhatsApp throughout the
treatment period (May to October 2026), with one delivery per
thematic component of the formative program. Each delivery consists
of an infographic and an audio message. The infographic is a
didactic image summarizing the main learning from that component
and including conversation-opener questions designed to prompt
discussion between household members. The audio message covers the
same content in spoken form. The two formats carry identical
information and are delivered together to ensure all participants
have an accessible way to engage with the material, regardless of
reading proficiency or visual limitations.
The three-arm design allows separate identification of: (i) the
effect of the information campaign delivered to the woman alone
(Arm 1 vs Arm 0); (ii) the incremental effect of extending the
delivery to a household member (Arm 2 vs Arm 1); and (iii) the
total effect of the household-inclusive intervention (Arm 2 vs
Arm 0).
Component C — Family closing session (co-primary):
At the cluster level, all 46 prioritized municipalities are
randomized 1:1 to treatment (approximately 23 municipalities) or
control (approximately 23 municipalities), stratified by sub-region
and municipality operational status. Women attending the program
in treatment municipalities are invited to a final program session
together with a co-resident adult household member or close family
contact. Women in control municipalities receive the standard
program closing without this session. Women are not informed about
the existence of Component C until the session takes place at
program closure.
Factorial Structure
Components B and C are crossed, generating six cells based on the
three-arm Component B design and the two-arm Component C design:
| | C=0 (no family session) | C=1 (family session) |
| B=0 (Control) | ~352 | ~351 |
| B=1 (Individual) | ~176 | ~175 |
| B=2 (Household) | ~176 | ~176 |
The main effects of each component and pairwise contrasts within
Component B (Arm 1 vs Arm 0, Arm 2 vs Arm 0, Arm 2 vs Arm 1) will
be estimated as pre-specified analyses. Interaction effects between
Components B and C are treated as exploratory. Cell sizes assume
proportional allocation to Component C treatment and control
municipalities.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.