Paternal Relational Valuations and the Construal Asymmetry — Pre-registration of Stage 0

How to cite

Giuntella, Osea; Gihleb, Rania; Tascon-Buchely, Daniel. 2026. "Paternal Relational Valuations and the Construal Asymmetry — Pre-registration of Stage 0." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018576. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18576-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Osea Giuntella* , Rania Gihleb , Daniel Tascon-Buchely

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018576
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18576-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-05-28 – 2027-05-29
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J13, J16, J22, D13, C83, D63
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18576

Abstract

This study surveys older U.S. parents (age 55+) about their experiences and reflections on the work–family trade-offs they made when their children were young. Participants are asked about their work arrangements at the time, how much time they spent with their children day to day, and how satisfied they are today with the decisions they made. They are also asked to consider a hypothetical scenario involving a young parent facing similar trade-offs and to share advice they would give.
The survey is the first wave of a multi-stage research project examining how people value time with their children relative to other goods, especially work and career. The retrospective reflections collected here serve two purposes: to describe how older American parents view their past choices in hindsight, and to inform the design of a follow-up study with younger parents currently making these decisions.
This pre-registration covers only the retrospective survey of older parents (Stage 0) of "The Other Child Penalty" project. Stage 1 and Stage 2 will be pre-registered separately as their designs are finalized. Approximately 450 participants (225 male, 225 female) will complete a 15-minute online survey through the Prolific platform, recruited via Prolific with gender stratification. Data and analysis code will be made publicly available after publication.

Intervention

Stage 0 is a descriptive online survey of older U.S. parents about their retrospective reflections on past work–family decisions. The survey includes one between-subjects experimental component: respondents are randomly assigned to one of two versions of a hypothetical scenario involving a young parent facing a work–family trade-off, which differ only in the gender of the protagonist (male or female). The survey also includes a within-subjects sensitivity check on the order of rows in a price-list elicitation task. Specific details of these randomizations are reserved for the hidden registration to preserve the integrity of the measurement, and will be released in full after data collection is complete

Experimental design

Stage 0 is an online survey of older U.S. parents (age 55+) administered through the Prolific platform, running approximately 15 minutes. Target analytic sample is n = 450 (225 male, 225 female) after pre-registered exclusions, with 240 of each gender recruited to allow for approximately 6 percent Tier 1 plus Tier 2 attrition. Recruitment is stratified 50/50 by gender via two separate Prolific studies.
The survey collects retrospective reflections on past work–family decisions, including satisfaction with past choices, counterfactual reflections on time and work allocation, willingness-to-accept measures for additional time with one's child, and advice in a hypothetical scenario about a young parent. The survey includes one between-subjects randomization: the gender of the protagonist in the hypothetical advice scenario (male vs. female), 50/50. Specific details are reserved for the hidden registration and will be released in full after data collection is complete.
Stage 0 is the first wave of a multi-stage research project on parental valuations of time with children. Subsequent stages (Stage 1, Stage 2) examine forward-looking parental decisions and behavioral anchors, and will be pre-registered separately as their designs are finalized. Stage 0 results will inform the design of subsequent stages.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-based randomization performed server-side at participant entry (oTree 6.x platform).
Randomization unit
Individual respondent (Prolific worker). No clustering or higher-level randomization unit.
Clusters
480 individuals recruited (240 male, 240 female); 450 analytic after pre-registered exclusions (225 male, 225 female). No clustering; randomization at the individual level.
Observations
480 individuals recruited (240 male, 240 female); 450 analytic after pre-registered exclusions (225 male, 225 female).
Arms
Row order of dollar MPL: ~240 ascending / ~240 descending Protagonist gender: ~240 male (Alex) / ~240 female (Anna) Total cells: 2 × 2 = 4 unique combinations, ~120 individuals per cell at recruitment (~112 analytic per cell after pre-registered exclusions). Marginal n per arm at recruitment ~240; ~225 analytic per arm after exclusions.
Primary outcomes
H1. Asymmetric counterfactual regret. Difference between the share reporting B2a = "too little" (wished for more time with their child) and the share reporting B4a = "too much" (wished they had worked less). Test: McNemar's paired test within respondents. H2. Continuous relational-regret magnitude. Median additional shared moments per week (b2b_moments_per_week) among respondents who report "too little" on B2a. Test: one-sample Wilcoxon signed-rank against a null median of zero. H3. Retrospective willingness-to-accept for parental time. Bracket midpoint between the last "Yes" and first "No" in the dollar multiple price list, in dollars per year (mpl_wta), restricted to interior switchers. Primary covariate specification is Tobit right-censored at $200,000. Test: one-sample Wilcoxon signed-rank against a null median of $5,000. H4. Strength of advice to reduce hours by protagonist gender. 1–7 Likert advice-strength item (D2), with the contrast E[D2 | Anna] > E[D2 | Alex]. Test: one-sided t-test. H5. Test of the wording-artifact hypothesis on cross-gender relational regret share. The pre-registered prediction is null: the share reporting B2a = "too little" is statistically indistinguishable between male and female respondents. Test: HC3 logistic regression of I(B2a = "too little") on female_respondent. Rejection criterion: |marginal effect| < 9.2 percentage points (95% CI half-width at n = 225 per gender).
Secondary outcomes
S1–S2. Continuous advice outcomes. Hours recommendation to the protagonist (D1, integer 20–45) and percent-of-income willingness-to-accept (mpl_pct_wta), both analyzed by protagonist gender and respondent gender. S3. Hours-controlled relational regret intensity. Median regression (qreg) of b2b_moments_per_week on A3 (daily interaction hours), A4 (weekly work hours), and demographic controls, restricted to respondents with B2a = "too little." Primary specification updated to median regression per Pilot 3 outlier sensitivity (Change 3). HC3 OLS reported as robustness. S4. Financial slack moderates WTA. Tobit regression of mpl_wta on financial_slack (E9) with demographic controls, right-censored at $200,000 (Change 4). Predicted positive coefficient on financial_slack. S5–S7. Within-gender splits of primary outcomes H1, H2, and H3. McNemar, median regression, and Tobit specifications reported separately for male and female respondents.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords