Leadership Turnover and the Stability of Cooperation Standards in Teams
How to cite
Lübke, Simon Maximilian.
2026. "Leadership Turnover and the Stability of Cooperation Standards in Teams." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018574.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18574-2.0
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
This project studies how leadership turnover affects cooperation in teams. Participants take part in a laboratory experiment in groups of four. Three participants make repeated costly effort choices in a team production setting. One participant has a leadership role and observes noisy bracket signals about individual contributor effort as well as the team average effort. The leader can assign rewards or sanctions subject to per person and total consequence limits. The experiment compares teams in which the leader remains in place with teams in which the leader is replaced after an initial phase of interaction. The study tests whether cooperation changes when the person holding consequence authority is replaced while the formal production environment, information structure, and consequence technology remain fixed.
Intervention
Participants take part in a repeated group decision task. Groups consist of three contributors and one leader. Contributors repeatedly choose costly effort in a team production setting. The leader observes noisy information about contributors’ behavior and can assign rewards or sanctions subject to limits. The study varies whether the same leader remains assigned to the group in the second part of the task or whether a different leader is assigned.
Experimental design
The project is a laboratory experiment with a pilot stage followed by a planned main study. Participants interact in groups of four. Three participants repeatedly choose costly effort in a team production task, while one participant acts as leader. The interaction lasts 20 rounds. The study varies whether the same leader remains assigned after round 10 or whether the group receives a different leader. The leader observes noisy bracket signals about individual effort and the team average effort, and can assign rewards or sanctions subject to per person and total consequence limits. Pilot data collected before the main experiment were used only for implementation updates and feasibility checks, including timing checks, interface checks, payoff and consequence calibration, and data export checks, and will not be included in the confirmatory main analysis.
Design details
Randomization method
Computer randomization implemented in oTree during laboratory sessions.
Randomization unit
There are two levels of randomization. First, participants are randomly assigned to groups of four and to roles within groups, with three contributors and one leader per group. Second, treatment assignment is at the group level: each contributor group is assigned to either the turnover condition or the control condition.
Clusters
Planned main study: at least 80 contributor groups, with at least 40 groups assigned to control and at least 40 groups assigned to turnover. If additional chair funding and laboratory capacity are available before confirmatory outcome analysis begins, the sample may be increased up to a prespecified maximum of 160 contributor groups, with equal allocation across treatment arms. The final sample size within this range will be determined by budget and laboratory capacity, not by estimated treatment effects from the main study. This range is based on pilot informed implementation, budget, and power calibration, including sensitivity analyses over lower, pilot based, higher, and high variance scenarios. Pilot groups are used for feasibility and calibration checks only, are excluded from the confirmatory main sample, and will not be used in the confirmatory main analysis.
Observations
Planned main study: at least 320 participants, with four participants per contributor group and at least 80 contributor groups in total. If additional chair funding and laboratory capacity are available before confirmatory outcome analysis begins, the sample may be increased up to a prespecified maximum of 640 participants, corresponding to 160 contributor groups. The final sample size within this range will be determined by budget and laboratory capacity, not by estimated treatment effects from the main study. Pilot participants are excluded from the confirmatory main sample and will not be used in the confirmatory main analysis.
Arms
Planned main study: at least 40 contributor groups assigned to control and at least 40 contributor groups assigned to turnover, corresponding to at least 160 participants per treatment arm under complete groups of four. If additional chair funding and laboratory capacity are available before confirmatory outcome analysis begins, the sample may be increased up to a prespecified maximum of 80 contributor groups per treatment arm, corresponding to 320 participants per treatment arm under complete groups of four. The final sample size within this range will be determined by budget and laboratory capacity, not by estimated treatment effects from the main study. Pilot groups are excluded from the confirmatory main sample and will not be used in the confirmatory main analysis.
Primary outcomes
Pilot:
• Implementation feasibility of the oTree experiment
• Correct group, role, phase, and leader assignment
• Correct payoff calculation and data export
• Session duration, completion rate, and comprehension check performance
Main study:
• Group level change in average contributor effort around the phase boundary
Secondary outcomes
• Full post turnover change in average contributor effort
• Immediate round 11 change in average contributor effort
• Within group dispersion of contributor effort
• Reward and sanctioning intensity
• Reward and sanction targeting by performance signal
• Contributor payoffs
• Post game survey measures on perceived effort standards, perceived reward and sanction thresholds, predictability, fairness, strictness, and clarity of consequence rules
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.