Orinoquia Climate smart livestock and Climate

How to cite

Sanchez-Saldarriaga, Andres; Muñoz-Mora, Juan Carlos; Ramirez, Mariangela. 2026. "Orinoquia Climate smart livestock and Climate." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018562. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18562-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Andres Sanchez-Saldarriaga* , Juan Carlos Muñoz-Mora , Mariangela Ramirez

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018562
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18562-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2024-06-05 – 2025-09-30
Countries
Colombia (Orinoquia)
JEL codes
Q10
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18562

Abstract

The Orinoquia region of eastern Colombia (comprising Meta, Arauca, Casanare, and Vichada) is one of the country’s most important livestock frontiers and a landscape of high ecological value, characterized by savannas, wetlands, riparian forests, and floodplains that provide essential ecosystem services. While cattle ranching remains central to rural livelihoods, employment, income generation, and food security, continued agricultural expansion and climate variability pose increasing risks to the sustainability of livestock systems. Extensive production practices, pasture degradation, limited tree integration, and growing exposure to droughts and floods threaten both ecosystem resilience and the long-term viability of livestock-based livelihoods.

Within this context, the Orinoquia Climate-Smart Livestock and Climate Project (OGSC) was implemented as part of the World Bank and BioCarbon Fund–ISFL agenda, in partnership with FEDEGAN, CIPAV, CIAT, and Universidad EAFIT. The project aimed to evaluate whether structured rural advisory services could support a transition from extensive livestock production toward climate-smart livestock systems. The intervention was grounded in the premise that adoption of climate-smart practices depends not only on information provision, but also on participatory learning, experimentation, repeated reinforcement, and producers’ perceptions of feasibility, risk, costs, and expected benefits.

The OGSC intervention delivered a Rural Advisory model over a 12-month period, combining collective learning spaces (such as participatory planning, technical workshops, field days, and group discussions) with individualized on-farm advisory visits. Demonstration farms and producer-to-producer learning mechanisms were used to reduce perceived adoption risks and provide visible local evidence of practice feasibility. The advisory strategy prioritized management-based and incrementally adoptable practices with potential co-benefits for productivity, pasture condition, tree cover, water protection, forage availability, conservation, and farm-level decision-making.
To generate credible evidence, the project used a counterfactual evaluation design with treatment and control groups, drawing on 2,133 observations that combine baseline and endline measurements from more than 1,000 livestock producers. This design allowed the analysis to distinguish changes attributable to the intervention from broader regional trends. The empirical findings show that OGSC generated meaningful increases in the adoption of climate-smart livestock practices, particularly those related to pasture–tree integration, live fences, forage management, conservation-oriented behaviors, and managerial capacity.

The results indicate that treatment farms were more likely to increase tree cover in grazing areas, with estimated effects of approximately 7.4 percentage points in the most complete model specification. They also showed a substantial increase in live fence adoption, with effects of approximately 12.7 percentage points. These practices contribute to improved microclimatic conditions, biodiversity, landscape connectivity, and ecosystem service provision while maintaining productive capacity. The intervention also improved producers’ capacity to manage forage scarcity: treatment farms were more likely to establish forage banks, with an estimated effect of 7.4 percentage points, and those with forage banks were more likely to report that these effectively covered feed requirements during scarcity periods, with an estimated effect of 8.1 percentage points.
Beyond specific production and conservation practices, OGSC strengthened managerial resilience. Among producers who kept farm records, those in the treatment group were more likely to analyze this information and use it for decision-making, with an estimated effect of 4.8 percentage points. The project also increased the likelihood of allocating specific farm areas to conservation by approximately 5.1 percentage points, reinforcing the environmental co-benefits of climate-smart livestock systems. However, effects on credit access and credit approval were limited or statistically insignificant, suggesting that advisory services alone may be insufficient to overcome structural barriers related to finance, market access, and institutional support.
Overall, the findings demonstrate that well-designed rural advisory systems can play a central role in shifting extensive livestock landscapes toward climate-smart trajectories, especially when they combine peer learning, individualized technical support, demonstration-based evidence, and continuous monitoring. The results also suggest that low-cost, management-based practices are particularly responsive to advisory-driven behavior change, making them strategic entry points for scaling. Sustaining and expanding these gains will require deeper analysis of heterogeneity across departments and production systems, continued follow-up, and stronger linkages between advisory services and enabling conditions such as finance, institutional support, and market incentives. In this sense, OGSC provides practical and evidence-based lessons for advancing productivity, climate resilience, and environmental sustainability in one of Colombia’s most important cattle-ranching regions

Intervention

The Orinoquia Climate-Smart Cattle Ranching program (OGSC — Orinoquia: Ganadería Sostenible y Clima) delivers a 12-month structured Rural Advisory (RA) package to cattle ranchers in Colombia's Orinoquia region (departments of Meta, Arauca, Casanare, and Vichada). Farms in the treatment group receive technical advisory and capacity-building services designed to promote the adoption of context-specific climate-smart cattle ranching (CSCR) technologies and practices — including silvopastoral systems, improved pastures with rotational grazing, forage banks, live fences, protection of water sources, and improved record-keeping for farm decision-making.
The advisory package is delivered through six sequential and cumulative cycles, each combining collective learning activities (technical workshops and field days) with individualized on-farm visits: (1) Participatory Farm Planning and Diagnostic Assessment; (2) Forage and Nutritional Management; (3) Pasture Diversification and Improvement; (4) Conservation of Natural Resources and Landscape Management; (5) Sustainable Management of Natural Resources and Climate Adaptation; and (6) Animal Management and Herd Administration. Demonstration farms and producer-to-producer exchange are used as catalysts for diffusion, and a complementary digital extension and monitoring layer reinforces continuity of contact and feedback. Farms in the control group do not receive OGSC advisory services during the evaluation period and continue operating under prevailing conditions.

Experimental design

The evaluation employs a randomized controlled trial with a clustered design and pre-/post-intervention measurement, supporting a Difference-in-Differences (DiD) estimation strategy. Cattle farms in the Orinoquia region are organized into a treatment group, which receives the full 12-month OGSC Rural Advisory model (collective learning, individualized farm visits, demonstration farms, and digital extension/monitoring), and a control group, which does not receive OGSC services during the evaluation period. Sampling follows a three-stage stratified design: (i) Orinoquia eco-regions (Piedmont, Altillanura, and floodplain) serve as strata / primary sampling units; (ii) veredas (rural communities) within each eco-region serve as clusters and are assigned to treatment or control; (iii) farms within each selected vereda constitute the ultimate sampling units. Standardized farm-level surveys are administered at baseline (prior to exposure) and endline (after completion of the six advisory cycles) to enable within-farm and between-group comparisons over time.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization at the cluster (vereda) level was complemented by genetic matching to select control veredas from candidate municipalities in the Orinoquia using covariates on livestock production characteristics, agroecological conditions, and geographical features. Within selected treatment veredas, eligible farms were drawn from FEDEGÁN's national vaccination database following predefined inclusion criteria and operational feasibility constraints.
Randomization unit
The vereda (rural community / cluster) is the unit of randomization. Eco-regions (Piedmont, Altillanura, floodplain) are used as strata. Within each treatment or control vereda, a sample of farms is drawn as the ultimate observational unit.
Clusters
22 veredas / clusters (11 treatment + 11 comparison), distributed across the three Orinoquia eco-regions (Piedmont, Altillanura, and floodplain). The treatment clusters were drawn from six municipalities (La Macarena, Cubarral, El Dorado, La Primavera, Paz de Ariporo, and Arauca).
Observations
1,100 cattle farms (550 treatment + 550 control), with an average of 50 farms per cluster.
Arms
Planned: 11 treatment veredas (550 farms) vs. 11 control veredas (550 farms) → 22 veredas / 1,100 farms total.
Primary outcomes
Adoption of climate-smart cattle ranching (CSCR) practices, measured at the farm level via binary and ordinal indicators in the baseline–endline household survey. The pre-specified primary outcomes are: Tree-based pasture integration — increased tree cover in grazing areas in the past year; increased vegetation islands / wooded patches in paddocks; tree/shrub corridors connecting conservation areas. Live-fence adoption — increased live fences in paddocks (barbed wire on live stakes/trees; electric fence on live stakes/trees), and corresponding reduction in fencing configurations based on dead posts. Feed resilience — presence of cut-and-carry forage banks, and producer-reported sufficiency of forage banks during dry-season / scarcity periods. Conservation behavior — allocation of areas dedicated to on-farm conservation and willingness to undertake ecological restoration. Managerial capacity — keeping livestock-system records and using recorded information as an input for decision-making. Microclimate-management perception — producer-reported sufficiency of shade in paddocks (diagnostic/perception outcome)
Secondary outcomes
(i) Knowledge and awareness of CSCR practices and their relative advantage over traditional management; (ii) producer motivation, capability, and perceived opportunity to adopt CSCR (COM-B dimensions, captured in qualitative work and structured survey items); (iii) household and farm-level socioeconomic indicators — share of income from livestock activities, access to and approval of credit for cattle activities, use of mineral salt, vaccination, and animal identification; (iv) heterogeneity of impacts by ecoregion (Piedmont, Altillanura, floodplain), farm size, herd size, and gender of the household head; and (v) community-level outcomes related to participation in farmer-to-farmer information exchange and peer learning forums.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords