Competition, Team Motivation and Generativity: Evidence from a School-Based Field Experiment
How to cite
Badiglio, Stefania; Seta, Luciano; Pipitone, Vito; Becchetti, Leonardo; Salustri, Francesco. 2026. "Competition, Team Motivation and Generativity: Evidence from a School-Based Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018550. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18550-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study investigates how students’ performance changes under different motivational framings: individual effort, individual competition, team responsibility, and generativity through charitable giving. The experiment is conducted in schools and asks students to complete two comparable tasks under four conditions: a running activity to do in the school gym and a skill-based game to play on the computer. In the baseline condition, students perform individually and receive only their personal result. In competitive conditions, each student competes for the school’s individual ranking. In the team condition, each student performs individually but the result contributes to the score of a team or class. In the charity condition, individual performance generates a real donation to one of several charitable causes selected by the student.
The main hypotheses are that performance changes when students move from an individual baseline to competition, to team responsibility, and to a prosocial/generative setting in which effort benefits third parties. The study also tests whether these effects differ by gender and by individual characteristics such as competitiveness, team orientation, social capital, risk attitudes and prosocial preferences. Outcomes include absolute performance, performance improvement relative to baseline, binary improvement indicators and the amount of charitable donation generated. The experiment contributes to evidence on competition aversion, cooperative motivation and prosocial effort in educational settings.
Intervention
The experiment consists of two independent trials, and each trial is repeated under four different conditions. The first trial involves running in the gym, while the second consists of a computer-based skill game. Each student will have to complete eight trials, with four different condidations for each trial. The four conditions are designed to differ only in motivational framing and payoff rule, while keeping the task, duration, setting and measurement as similar as possible. The teacher or experimenter reads standardized instructions before each condition. The four conditions are: individual baseline, individual competition, team competition, and charity/generativity.
T1 — Individual baseline
Students complete the task individually. They are told that the objective is to obtain their best personal result. They are not competing against other students and no individual ranking is publicly disclosed. The outcome is the student’s individual performance.
T2 — Individual competition
Students complete the same task and they are told that the objective is to obtain their best result and try to win the individual challenge. The outcome is individual performance.
T3 — Team condition
Students complete the task individually, but their result contributes to the overall score of a team, preferably the class. Students are told that everyone’s contribution matters and that even a small individual improvement can help the team. The outcome is individual performance and team/class performance.
T4 — Charity/generativity condition
Students complete the task individually, but their performance generates a real charitable donation. Students choose among four charitable causes: Kiva, Treedom, Sightsavers, and distance child sponsorship. The donation is real and the aggregate amount generated for each cause is communicated at the end. There is no private individual prize in this condition; the payoff is the donation generated.
Experimental design
This is a school-based randomized field experiment using a within-subject design. Each student participates in four comparable task conditions: individual baseline, individual competition, team condition, and charity/generativity condition.
Random assignment is implemented through the random allocation of students to different sequences of the four experimental conditions. In other words, students are not assigned to one fixed treatment or control group for the entire experiment. Instead, all students complete all four conditions, but the order in which they are exposed to the conditions is randomly assigned. This randomization of treatment order is designed to address potential order, fatigue, learning, day, and session effects.
The individual baseline condition serves as the control condition. The individual competition, team, and charity/generativity conditions are the treatment conditions. Since each student participates in all conditions, each student serves as his or her own control, and the main empirical strategy compares within-student changes in performance across conditions.
The core design principle is that the four conditions differ only in motivational framing and payoff rule, not in task difficulty, duration, setting, or measurement.
This design is replicated in two different trials: one in the gym, where students take part in a running test, and another on the computer, where students are engaged in a game designed to measure their skills.
In the individual baseline condition, students perform individually and are not ranked publicly. In the individual competition condition, students compete individually, and their results contribute to their school’s ranking list. In the team condition, students work individually, but their results contribute to their class or team’s score. In the charity/generativity condition, students perform individually and their performance generates a real donation to one of four charitable causes selected by the student: Kiva, Treedom, Sightsavers, or distance child sponsorship. The main empirical strategy compares within-student changes in performance across the four conditions. The preferred specification includes individual fixed effects, treatment-condition indicators, and controls for randomized order, day/session effects, fatigue, and learning. Heterogeneity analyses will test whether treatment effects differ by gender and by baseline characteristics measured in a post-experiment questionnaire.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.