Rules versus Discretion in Eerly Childhood Development Programs.

How to cite

Cossio, Diego Vera; Berlinski, Samuel; Celhay, Pablo. 2026. "Rules versus Discretion in Eerly Childhood Development Programs.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018542. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18542-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Diego Vera Cossio* , Samuel Berlinski , Pablo Celhay

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018542
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18542-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-02-01 – 2027-06-30
Countries
El Salvador (Country wide)
JEL codes
I25, I30, J13, O15, O55
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18542

Abstract

This study analyzes the impacts of different criteria to target beneficiaries of \emph{Círculos de Familias}, a government parenting program in El Salvador aimed at improving caregiving practices and early childhood development among vulnerable households. The program consists of facilitated group sessions providing guidance on responsive parenting, socio-emotional development, and early stimulation.

A randomized controlled trial embedded in routine implementation varies beneficiary recruitment mechanisms across communities: business-as-usual selection (recruitment made by local agents in charge of conducting \emph{Círculos de Familias} sessions) , needs-based targeting (based on an statistical score), and random-order recruitment. Program content remains identical across arms.

Intervention

The study experimentally varies beneficiary selection mechanisms while holding program content constant. Randomization occurs at the district level, with each community served by one ATPI.

Baseline census data identified all eligible households prior to implementation.

Eligible districts are randomly assigned to one of three groups:

Group 1: Business-as-Usual Recruitment. Local agents in charge of program sessions---Asistente Técnico de Primera Infancia (ATPI)---recruit participants using standard discretionary practices.
Group 2: Needs-Based Recruitment. ATPIs receive a ranked list of households based on a proxy measure of parental investments and invite families sequentially.
Group 3: Random-Order Recruitment. ATPIs receive a randomly ordered list of eligible households and invite sequentially.

All other program aspects, including content, frequency, and monitoring, remain identical across arms.

Experimental design

Thirty nine districts are randomly assigned to three different recruitment mechanisms. Recruitment continues until class capacity is reached, following arm-specific rules. Program implementation is otherwise identical across experimental arms.

Within districts assigned to groups 2 and 3, individuals were assigned to priority lists given to implementing agents (ATPIs):

Group 2: Within each district, households are grouped in pairs based on a neediness score. WIthin each pair, households are randomized to the short list given to ATPIs.

Group 3: Within each district, households are randomized to the short list given to ATPIs.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
Districts level for main analysis. Individual level, within a district for secondary analyses.
Clusters
39 districts
Observations
6,000 households
Arms
13 districts (control) 13 districts (needs-based targeting) 13 districts (random order)
Primary outcomes
Program Participation: Invitation to Círculos de Familias Attendance intensity Session completion Differential Selection into Invitation, Attendance and program completion: \item Demographic characteristics of caregiver: education, age, sex, employment status, time use. \item Household characteristics: probability of being in poverty, index of dwelling quality, household size. \item Baseline child development outcomes. \item Baseline parenting practices and investments. \item Engagement with other families. \item Distance to Circulos de Familia sessions. Child Development Outcomes: Standardized child development indexes (EDIN II) Parenting Practices: \item Early stimulation activities \item Variety of play materials. \item Parenting behavior indexes
Secondary outcomes
Class Quality and Conflict: \item Engagement and participation \item Friction and anger between participants \item Interactions with other families in the district. Recruitment costs: \item Monetary costs. \item Time. \item Number of attempts to reach target children.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords