Nudges and the Malleability of Identity: Evidence from Religiosity 2026

How to cite

Sartori, Tommaso; Megalokonomou, Rigissa; Dioikitopoulos, Evangelos. 2026. "Nudges and the Malleability of Identity: Evidence from Religiosity 2026." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018442. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18442-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tommaso Sartori* , Rigissa Megalokonomou , Evangelos Dioikitopoulos

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018442
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18442-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-04-22 – 2027-04-22
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Z12, D83, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18442

Abstract

We study whether brief prosocial messages framed in religious or scientific language influence how adults report their religiosity. Participants are randomly assigned to receive either a religiously framed message, a scientifically framed message, or no message. Following exposure, we measure self-reported religiosity using two primary outcomes: the perceived importance of God in life (0–10 scale) and the desired frequency of prayer. We compare average responses across groups to estimate the causal effect of framing on religious self-identification and practice. The study is conducted anonymously and involves minimal risk to participants. It aims to provide evidence on whether subtle variations in everyday language can shape how individuals express aspects of personal identity, such as religiosity.

Intervention

After collecting information on participants' demographic characteristics and beliefs, we randomly assigned them to view a brief text message accompanied by an image. The text promotes prosocial behavior and reflection on relationships with others. Different versions of the message use different types of language (e.g., referencing religious or scientific perspectives), while conveying a similar underlying theme. A control group proceeds directly to the survey without seeing any message.

All participants then complete a set of questions about their attitudes and beliefs. The intervention is brief, non-coercive, and involves no deception.

Experimental design

Design:
Parallel-arm, between-subjects randomized controlled trial conducted online. Participants are randomly assigned (1:1:1) to one of three arms at the start of the survey:
(A) a brief prosocial message framed in religious language;
(B) a closely matched prosocial message framed in scientific/psychology language; or
(C) no message (control).

Messages are similar in length and readability; only the framing differs. No deception is used.

Eligibility & setting:
Adults (18+) completing a single session on a standard online survey platform. Participation is anonymous and voluntary; respondents may skip questions.

Timing & flow:
After providing consent, participants are randomly assigned to one of the three conditions. The assigned message (or no message) is displayed on its own screen. Immediately afterward, participants complete the outcome measures within the same session.

Primary outcomes (confirmatory):
Self-reported religiosity measured immediately after the intervention using two outcomes:

Importance of God in life (0–10 scale; 0 = not at all important, 10 = very important);
Desire to pray often, constructed as a binary indicator equal to one if respondents report praying at least once per day.

Secondary outcomes (public summary):
A broader set of attitudinal and behavioral measures, including:

religious beliefs (e.g., belief in God, afterlife);
religious attitudes (e.g., views on religion vs. science);
religious behavior (e.g., church attendance);
moral and social attitudes (e.g., abortion, homosexuality, immigration, same-sex marriage);
behavioral preferences (e.g., revenge, punishment, forgiveness);
political ideology and vaccination status;
additional preference measures (e.g., self-comparison, willingness to sacrifice for the future).

Randomization & masking:
Treatment assignment is implemented automatically by the survey platform’s randomizer. Participants are not informed about the existence or content of alternative messages.

Analysis (high-level):
We estimate intent-to-treat effects by comparing average outcomes across groups using two-sided tests at α = 0.05. The primary confirmatory contrast is the scientific framing relative to the control group. Secondary contrasts include religious vs. control and scientific vs. religious framing. Secondary outcomes are analyzed as exploratory with appropriate consideration of multiple testing.

Exposure & quality controls (summary):
A minimum on-screen exposure time is imposed for the message. A simple attention check is included to encourage data quality. Any exclusion criteria are prespecified elsewhere in the preregistration.

Design details

Randomization method
Treatment assignment is implemented automatically by the survey platform’s randomizer.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual participant. Each participant is independently assigned by the survey platform to one of the three treatment arms (religious framing, scientific framing, or control). There is no clustering or multi-level randomization.
Clusters
1,000 individuals.
Observations
1,000 individuals.
Arms
Approximately 333 individuals in the control group, 333 individuals in the religious framing group, and 334 individuals in the scientific framing group.
Primary outcomes
The study includes two primary outcomes capturing complementary dimensions of religiosity: Importance of God in life Continuous variable measured on a 0–10 scale (0 = Not at all important; 10 = Very important). Desire to pray often Binary indicator equal to 1 if the respondent reports praying at least once per day, and 0 otherwise. Derived from an ordinal question on desired prayer frequency.
Secondary outcomes
We collect a set of secondary (non-confirmatory) outcomes capturing religious beliefs, attitudes, behaviors, and broader social and behavioral preferences: Belief measures (binary indicators) Belief in: God, afterlife, hell, and heaven (yes/no). Religious attitudes (ordinal Likert variables) Agreement with statements on religion vs. science and exclusivity of religion. Religious behavior (ordinal variable) Frequency of church attendance. Moral attitudes (continuous variables) Perceived justification (0–10 scale) of: abortion, premarital sex, and homosexuality. Immigration attitudes (ordinal variable) Self-reported attitude toward immigrants. Same-sex marriage (ordinal variable) Position on legalizing same-sex marriage. Behavioral preferences (continuous variables) Willingness to take revenge, willingness to forgive unlawful acts, and willingness to punish unfair behavior (toward self and others). Political ideology (categorical variable) Self-placement on a left–right political spectrum. COVID-19 vaccination status (binary variable) Vaccinated vs. not vaccinated. Self-comparison tendencies (continuous variable) Degree of comparison with others in decision-making. Willingness to sacrifice for the future (continuous variable)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords