Targeting Youth Entrepreneurs: Does the composition of targeting committee matter?

How to cite

Abay, Kibrom; Nigus, Halefom; Abate, Gashaw; Chamberlin, Jordan; Kahsay, Goytom; Mockshell, Jonathan. 2026. "Targeting Youth Entrepreneurs: Does the composition of targeting committee matter?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018432. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18432-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kibrom Abay* , Halefom Nigus , Gashaw Abate , Jordan Chamberlin , Goytom Kahsay , Jonathan Mockshell

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018432
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18432-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-04-26 – 2027-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18432

Abstract

Identifying high-ability micro-entrepreneurs remains a top policy agenda of governments and development partners aiming to create jobs for the youth. This is particularly important for Africa where governments struggle to allocate limited resources to where they are most impactful. In many data-scarce settings, decentralized committee-based targeting methods are widely used for identifying and screening beneficiaries, although how these committee functions remain poorly understood. This limits efforts to improve their performance and address some of their limitations, including potential elite capture. This project aims to answer three important questions: (i) Can increasing women’s representation improve women’s influence in collective and targeting decisions? (ii) Do women’s representation in targeting committees increase women’s and girl’s access to transfers? and (iii) Do women’s representation in targeting committees reduce elite-capture of transfers? To address these research questions, we exogenously vary the composition of committee members tasked to identify youth entrepreneurs among youth groups in Ethiopia.

Intervention

This intervention builds on and targets Youth Agricultural Innovation Groups (YAIGs) in Oromia region, which were part of the SAfA (Foundations Alliance for Africa) project implemented by the Hanns R. Neumann Stiftung (HRNS). The SAfA project aimed to enhance the livelihood prospects of young people in Ethiopia through an integrated and multi-sectoral approach. The target population for this intervention are YAIG leaders and YAIG members in two (Bedele and Gechi) districts in Oromia region.
Intervention: Identification of potential youth entrepreneurs and ranking by YAIG leaders
The main intervention in this study is to identify youth with relatively high entrepreneurial potential and test the performance of alternative community-based targeting methods. The CBT will be conducted by YAIG leaders in each YAIG, composed of chairman, secretary, cashier, auditor, and facilitator. We task YAIG leaders to rank about 20 YAIG members in their respective YAIG, from the one with the highest entrepreneurial potential (first) to the one with least entrepreneurial potential (last) based on a set of predefined criteria, which are handed to the committee by the researchers (see the experimental design selection below). YAIG leaders will be informed that the NGO conducting the YAIG-level survey aims to identify a small group of youth to support them with seed capital to start or expand a business or support livelihood activities. The transfer of the seed capital follows a two-stage process. First, beneficiary YAIG will be randomly selected. Next, within each selected YAIG, the NGO we are working with will transfer to the seed capital to the four highest-ranked youth members as determined by the committee members. If a YAIG is selected, we aim to award a 20,000 Birr seed capital to each of the four youth members with the highest potential within each YAIG.
We randomly assign the recruited YAIGs to two experimental arms: (i) conventional targeting (YAIG leaders select beneficiaries) and (ii) gender-balanced targeting (gender-balanced committee selects beneficiaries). This allows us to create an otherwise comparable group of youth and their YAIG. Prior to the ranking exercise, we administer a series of questions that aim to elicit YAIG leaders’ objective functions in allocating the seed capital transfers.

Research Objectives and Research Questions
This research project aims to address three broad research questions. The first question and objective relate to whether increasing women’s representation in targeting committees increase their voice and influence in collective decisions. This builds on previous evidence on the potential of increasing women’s representation in committees and leadership roles (Karpowitz et al., 2012; Clayton et al., 2025; Karpowitz et al., 2014; Leon et al., 2019; Kahsay et al., 2021). While some studies show that women leaders improve the provision of public goods (Chattopadhyay and Duflo, 2004; Agarwal, 2009a,b; Coleman and Mwangi, 2013; Leisher et al., 2016; Kahsay et al., 2021), others find the opposite (Gajwani and Zhang, 2015; Deininger et al., 2015; Ban and Rao, 2008; Bardhan et al., 2010). It also links to a broader literature on women decision making in politics (e.g., O'Brien and Rickne, 2016; Bagues and Campa, 2021) and company boards (e.g., Ferrari et al., 2022). Second, we investigate whether this ultimately leads to improved access to transfer for women and marginalized youth. Finally, we also aim to investigate whether women’s representation reduces elite capture of the transfer. Similarly, we also explore whether targeting priorities of the committee change because of the increase in women’s representation. For this purpose, we elicited YAIG leaders’ preferences and priorities in identifying and targeting youth with highest entrepreneurial potential. More specifically, we aim to address the following research questions:
1) Can increasing women’s representation improve their influence in collective and targeting decisions?
2) Do women’s representation in targeting committee increase women’s and girl’s access to transfer in targeted transfers?
3) Do women’s representation in targeting committees reduce elite-capture of transfers?

Experimental design

This section describes the experimental design of the leader-based targeting of potential entrepreneurs. The target group for this experiment are YAIG leaders assuming various roles within their youth groups. Thus, the key actors and target of our interventions are the four YAIG leaders recruited from each YAIG. As described earlier, the survey brings together four YAIG leaders assuming the following roles in their YAIG: (i) Chairperson, (ii) Secretary, (iii) Casher, (iv) Auditor, and (v) facilitator. In some cases when these leaders are not available or missing, we replace them by those who previously assumed these roles or other active members of the YAIG. We note that these members are commonly involved in some important decisions related to identification of beneficiaries for similar programs and interventions, both in Ethiopia and other parts of Africa. The intervention follows YAIG level clustered randomization in which the 185 YAIGs are randomly assigned into a control and treatment arm (see also Figure 1). The random assignment is stratified by kebele as we have multiple YAIGs in each kebele.

Infert Figure 1 Here (Figure 1. Random assignment of YAIG treatment and control arms)

(1) Conventional composition of YAIG leaders (C): YAIG leaders in this group are instructed to create a committee composed of their usual officers and then conduct the targeting process following the introductions. They are informed that their ranks and selection will have consequences. If their YAIG is lucky and identified to be in the group randomly selected for the seed capital (transfer), we will provide the top four candidates with a seed capital of 20,000 Birr each. All YAIG members ranked below will not receive any transfer. YAIG leaders are asked to rank all youth from the one with highest entrepreneurial potential to the one with the least entrepreneurial potential. They are given the following five criteria for ranking the youth with entrepreneurial potential within their YAIG. Specifically, the YAIG leaders are asked to prioritize and rank the YAIG members based on the following criteria:
(i) Youth who may have potential entrepreneurial qualities to succeed in business compared to other peers in the same group.
(ii) Youth who has or may have business ideas or are in the process of starting a business.
(iii) Youth who have know or experience running a business
(iv) Youth who have the potential to turn a seed capital into in a profitable business with high potential returns.
(2) Gender-balanced YAIG leader composition (T): Another group of YAIG leaders are asked to ensure gender-balance of the committee and strictly satisfy that at least half (two) of the committee members should be female. This is motivated by our interest to understand the implications of bringing women and girls in major decision-making roles. Previous studies show that women’s inclusion in deliberation and committee-based decision improve their voice and associated outcomes (Karpowitz et al., 2012; Clayton et al., 2025; Karpowitz et al., 2014; Kahsay et al., 2021). Except for the composition of the committee, YAIG leaders in this group are asked to accomplish identical tasks and they are required to rank YAIG members based on the five pre-determined targeting criteria described above.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is done at the YAIG level using the list of YAIGs available to us. The YAIGs were created and established by another project. The 185 YAIG are then randomly assigned into the two groups, with stratification at kebele level.
Randomization unit
Youth Agricultural Innovation Group (YAIG)
Clusters
185 YAIG and about 740 YAIG leaders (and associated YAIG members). C (Control : conventional committee): 93 YAIGs T (Gender-balanced committee): 92 YAIGs
Observations
185 YAIG and about 740 YAIG leaders (and associated YAIG members). C (Control : conventional committee): 93 YAIGs T (Gender-balanced committee): 92 YAIGs
Arms
185 YAIG and about 740 YAIG leaders (and associated YAIG members). C (Control : conventional committee): 93 YAIGs T (Gender-balanced committee): 92 YAIGs
Primary outcomes
1. Women’s access to seed capital: proxied by the gender of selected youth members 2. Elite capture: proxied by the link between the committee and selected youth members ( (selecting oneself, family member, relative, friend, etc.) 3. Women and girls voice and influence in collective decisions 4. Cooperation among committee members 5. Targeting effectiveness: proxied by the comparison of selected youth members and average group member in terms of ability (education, business experience).
Secondary outcomes
1. Concordance with data-driven and peer targeting 2. Decision-making processes: consensus-based, voting or a combination of both 3. YAIG-level performance indicators 4. Targeting priorities and preferences

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords