Conduct and Consequences: Behavioral Rank and Academic Outcomes

How to cite

Sartori, Tommaso; Megalokonomou, Rigissa. 2026. "Conduct and Consequences: Behavioral Rank and Academic Outcomes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018419. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18419-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tommaso Sartori* , Rigissa Megalokonomou

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018419
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18419-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-04-27 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
21, I28, C93, D91, J24
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18419

Abstract

Using administrative data from secondary schools in Greece, we document that students who stand out relative to their classmates in terms of disruptive behavior—measured by unexcused absences, which represent the number of hours that see a student removed from the class by the teacher—experience worse behavioral, academic, and higher education outcomes. However, once we account for students’ relative academic performance within the classroom, academic outcomes and subsequent exam results are more strongly associated with academic rank rather than behavioral rank. This pattern raises the question of which mechanisms translate relative standing into long-run outcomes.

To shed light on these mechanisms, we conduct a survey experiment with teachers. Participants are asked to evaluate anonymized student work based on short vignettes. In the first stage, teachers receive information about a student’s behavioral record and relative standing within the classroom. In a second stage, they are provided with additional information about the student’s academic performance and relative academic rank, with these dimensions experimentally varied across participants. We elicit grading decisions and expectations about students’ future academic and career outcomes, as well as whether teachers revise their evaluations when new information is introduced.

This design allows us to assess whether and how teachers’ evaluations and expectations respond to students’ relative behavioral and academic standing. By linking these responses to the patterns observed in the administrative data, the study aims to identify whether teacher behavior constitutes a key channel through which classroom rank effects shape student outcomes.

Intervention

The intervention consists of an online survey experiment administered to teachers. Participants are presented with short, anonymized vignettes describing a student and a piece of student work containing a mistake, and are asked to evaluate the work.

In the first stage, all participants receive identical student work and baseline profile information, along with information about the student’s GPA and behavioral record, including the number of unexcused absences and the student’s relative standing within their classroom (e.g., top or bottom of the class in terms of such behavior). Participants are asked to assign a grade, report their confidence in the evaluation, and provide expectations regarding the student’s future academic and career outcomes.

In the second stage, participants are shown the same student profile and work, augmented with additional information about the student’s relative academic rank within the classroom (e.g., top or bottom). The pairing between behavioral rank and academic rank is experimentally varied across participants. After receiving this information, participants are asked whether they would revise their initial evaluation and, if so, to provide an updated grade. Additional questions elicit the reasoning behind their decisions.

The intervention varies the information available to teachers about students’ relative behavioral and academic standing, allowing us to identify how such information affects grading decisions, confidence, and expectations.

Experimental design

The study uses an online survey experiment with teachers, in which participants evaluate anonymized student work based on short vignettes.

Each participant is shown a student profile and a piece of student work containing a mistake and is asked to assign a grade and provide related evaluations. In the first stage, the student profile includes information about the student’s behavioral record (number of unexcused absences), prior academic performance (GPA), and the student’s relative standing within the classroom in terms of behavior (high or low disruptiveness rank).

In a second stage, participants are shown the same student profile augmented with information about the student’s relative academic standing within the classroom (high or low academic rank), based on the previously reported GPA. No additional information on absolute academic performance is introduced.

The information about behavioral rank and academic rank is experimentally varied across participants.

The design allows us to examine how teachers’ evaluations and expectations respond to students’ relative behavioral and academic standing, holding constant absolute academic performance, as well as whether teachers revise their evaluations when new information on relative standing is provided.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is conducted automatically by the Qualtrics survey platform using its built-in randomization functions. Participants are randomly assigned to treatment conditions at the individual level by a computer algorithm at the time they access the survey link. Based on the broad field they choose (sciences or humanities), teachers will be asked to review either the mathematics or the literature test.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the individual participant (teacher). Each participant is independently assigned to a treatment condition by the survey platform. There is a single level of randomization, and no clustering is used.
Clusters
The unit of randomization is the individual teacher. The planned number of clusters is between 600 and 800 teachers, with the final number potentially exceeding this range depending on the success of the recruitment process.
Observations
The planned number of observations is between 600 and 800 teachers, with the final number potentially exceeding this range depending on the success of the recruitment process. Since the design is not clustered, the number of observations coincides with the number of clusters.
Arms
Participants will be randomized across the four treatment arms of the 2×2 design: High disruptiveness rank × High academic rank High disruptiveness rank × Low academic rank Low disruptiveness rank × High academic rank Low disruptiveness rank × Low academic rank Given the target sample size, this implies approximately 150 to 200 teachers per treatment arm overall, with the final number depending on recruitment success. Because the experiment also includes two subject-specific versions of the vignette (scientific fields and humanities), the effective number of observations per treatment arm within each field is expected to be approximately 75 to 100 teachers, assuming a roughly balanced composition across fields.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are teachers’ evaluations and expectations about the student, measured before and after additional information on relative academic standing is revealed. Stage 1: outcomes measured after the initial vignette After being shown a student profile containing baseline information, including the student’s number of unexcused absences, prior academic performance (GPA), and the student’s relative disruptiveness rank within the classroom (high or low), the primary outcomes are: the grade assigned to the student’s work on a 0–10 scale; whether the teacher reports that the mistake in the exercise is minor or substantial; whether the teacher reports that the student’s classroom behavior was an important factor in determining the grade; whether the teacher believes the student’s behavior will positively affect the student’s future academic performance; whether the teacher believes the student’s behavior will positively affect the student’s future career path; whether the teacher would encourage the student to pursue a competitive university degree; whether the teacher would encourage the student to pursue a challenging professional path; whether the teacher would encourage the student’s parents to push the student toward a competitive university degree; whether the teacher would encourage the student’s parents to push the student toward a challenging professional path. Stage 2: outcomes measured after academic rank information is added Participants are then shown the same student profile, augmented with information on the student’s relative academic standing within the classroom (high or low), based on the previously reported GPA. No additional information on absolute academic performance is introduced. The primary outcomes at this stage are: whether the teacher chooses to revise the initial grade; the updated grade assigned to the student’s work; whether the teacher believes the student’s behavior will affect the student’s future academic performance; whether the teacher believes the student’s behavior will affect the student’s future career path; whether the teacher would encourage the student to pursue a competitive university degree; whether the teacher would encourage the student to pursue a challenging professional path; whether the teacher would encourage the student’s parents to push the student toward a competitive university degree; whether the teacher would encourage the student’s parents to push the student toward a challenging professional path. The main comparisons of interest are how these outcomes vary with the student’s disruptiveness rank in the first stage, and how revision decisions and updated beliefs vary when relative academic standing is revealed while holding constant absolute academic performance.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords