Measuring Personality Traits and Predicting Loan Default with Experiments and Surveys
How to cite
Karlan, Dean; Mullainathan, Sendhill; Robles, Omar. 2017. "Measuring Personality Traits and Predicting Loan Default with Experiments and Surveys." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001840. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1840-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We use two natural field experiments and surveys to identify character elements, and test whether these traits can be used to predict the likelihood of loan default. In the first experiment we identify subjects with high psychosomatic moral costs by observing their reactions when a bank error is made in their favor. In the second experiment we identify subjects that were less naïve about their own ability to meet future commitments. We found that both individuals with higher moral costs and individuals who were the least naïve displayed lower default rates than other groups. We also explore the relationship between qualitative survey-based social capital measures and loan default. We find that survey-based social capital measures are not predictive of loan default for these individual loans, contrary to the results from a prior study -with group loans. Lastly, we examine whether more general personality index measures predict default, and we find that they do not. Overall, the lessons present evidence of moral hazard in microentrepreneurial credit markets to the extent that they reflect choice by the borrower about whether to repay. They also show the potential for adverse selection insofar as these personality measures are typically unobservable to the lender.
Intervention
In this project, the researchers tested whether personal character traits can predict the probability of loan default among microfinance borrowers in the Philippines. They used two field experiments and two surveys to identify subsets of borrowers with certain character traits. Then, the researchers tested whether the default rate for these borrowers was significantly different from the default rate of the rest of the sample borrowers and whether these traits are predictive of default. In the first experiment, researchers identified sample borrowers with high psychosomatic moral costs. In the second, researchers identified sample borrowers that were less naïve about their ability to meet future commitments. The researchers then used surveys to measure sample borrowers' social capital and Big Five personality index score.
The researchers found that sample borrowers with high psychosomatic moral costs and borrowers that were less naïve about their ability to repay were less likely to default than other sample borrowers. Survey measures of social capital was not predictive of default, nor was a borrower's Big Five personality index score.
Experimental design
In the first experiment, sample borrowers were offered a cash reward for completing a baseline survey. While redeeming their reward, the bank cashiers intentionally gave the recipients too much cash. Those who left the bank with the excess cash and later returned it were hypothesized to have high moral standards, or a high psychosomatic cost of immoral behavior, and thus would be less likely to default. In the second experiment, borrowers were randomized into one of two groups: those asked to respond to a short survey in seven days via text message in order to win a cash reward, and those given a choice to either answer the survey in seven days via text message or to complete the survey the same day for a smaller cash reward. Those who chose to complete the survey the same day were hypothesized to be rationally self-aware and less likely to default, while those who chose the option to text in seven days but failed to do so were hypothesized to be naïvely over-optimistic and thus more likely to default. In the social capital survey, participants answered questions from the General Social Survey on trust, fairness, and helpfulness. Borrowers that indicated higher levels of social capital were hypothesized to have lower default rates than the remainder of the sample participants. In the Big Five personality survey, participants responded to the Ten-Item-Personality-Index.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.