From Information to Action: Using Evidence to Strengthen Primary Care in the SUS

How to cite

Borges, Bruna; Naritomi, Joana; Rocha, Rudi; Moreira, Diana. 2026. "From Information to Action: Using Evidence to Strengthen Primary Care in the SUS." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018382. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18382-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Bruna Borges* , Joana Naritomi , Rudi Rocha , Diana Moreira

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018382
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18382-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-06-23 – 2028-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I18; D83; C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18382

Abstract

This study evaluates if structured support for accessing, interpreting, and using data and evidence can improve decision-making and implementation among public managers. More broadly, the study examines how middle-level public managers incorporate evidence into organizational routines and translate information into administrative action. Its empirical application is municipal primary health care in Brazil, with a focus on maternal and child health.

Although public organizations generate large amounts of data, managers often face barriers to using this information in their daily work. Data may be fragmented, difficult to interpret and compare, or costly to access under time and resource constraints. Moreover, even when managers can identify and prioritize local bottlenecks, they may lack accessible and credible evidence about which practices are effective and feasible. The intervention aims to address both barriers: its data and diagnosis components provide structured training, curated indicators, comparisons with peer municipalities, and individualized municipal diagnoses, while its additional solutions component presents recommended practices supported by rigorous evidence and promotes peer discussion about their operational implementation.

Participants in the study are professionals involved in the management of municipal primary health care services. Eligible registrants will be randomly assigned to one of two treatment groups. Treatment 1 provides training on data and indicators, guided use of the IEPS Data platform, an individualized municipal maternal and child health diagnosis, and peer discussion. Treatment 2 includes all Treatment 1 components and adds a module presenting evidence-based recommended practices, followed by peer discussion focused on operational processes and implementation.

The experimental comparison is between Treatment 2 and Treatment 1 and identifies the incremental effect of adding the solutions module to the data-literacy and municipal-diagnosis components. Because all registered municipalities are assigned to one of the two workshop versions, the study does not include a randomized no-treatment control group. As a secondary analysis, the study may estimate the overall effect of access to the workshop by comparing participating municipalities with municipalities not represented among registrants using a difference-in-differences design. A causal interpretation of this comparison will depend on sufficient overlap between the groups and on evidence supporting the plausibility of parallel pre-intervention trends; if these conditions are not supported, the analysis will be treated as exploratory.

Outcomes include interpretation of indicators, updating of beliefs about municipal performance, use of data in management, and adoption of evidence-aligned practices. The study will also examine whether changes in managerial practices translate into improvements in service-delivery processes and, over a longer horizon, maternal and child health outcomes.

Intervention

Municipalities represented among eligible participants will be randomly assigned to one of two versions of an online workshop, and all participants from the same municipality will be assigned to the same version. The workshop focuses on the use of data and evidence in routine public management, with an empirical application to municipal primary health care and maternal and child health.

Both versions of the workshop introduce key concepts related to data literacy, including the interpretation of indicators, denominators, data limitations, trends over time, and comparisons across municipalities. Participants receive guidance on navigating the IEPS Data platform and an individualized report containing indicators for their municipality. They are then guided through a structured municipal diagnosis aimed at identifying and prioritizing relevant bottlenecks, followed by peer discussion.

Treatment 2 includes all the components offered in Treatment 1 and adds a solutions module. This module presents two recommended practices supported by rigorous causal evidence: WhatsApp groups for pregnant women, managed by primary health care teams to share maternal and child health information and facilitate communication; and reminder systems for prenatal appointments, diagnostic tests, postpartum follow-up, and childhood vaccination. Participants also discuss with peers the feasibility, operational processes, and implementation of these practices in municipal primary health care. This additional component is intended to reduce the cost of identifying effective and feasible responses and to help managers translate diagnosis and prioritization into action.

Experimental design

Public managers working in municipal primary health care who register for the study are the eligible participants. Treatment assignment will occur at the municipality level: municipalities represented in the eligible sample are randomly assigned to one of two versions of the remotely delivered training activity, and all eligible participants from the same municipality will receive the same assignment.

Both groups will receive structured support related to the use of data and evidence in public management. One group will receive a core version of the training, while the other will receive an expanded version containing additional evidence and implementation-related content. The primary experimental comparison will estimate the incremental effect of the expanded version relative to the core version.

Outcomes will be measured through baseline and follow-up surveys and, where feasible, municipality-level administrative data.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Municipality
Clusters
400 municipalities
Observations
800 primary health care managers
Arms
Randomization is at the municipality level, with municipalities allocated equally between the two treatment arms. Based on the minimum detectable effect calculations, the preferred target is 400–600 municipalities in total: Treatment 1: approximately 200–300 municipalities; Treatment 2: approximately 200–300 municipalities. The current pool for the first implementation wave includes approximately 300 participants from 180 municipalities, corresponding to approximately 90 municipalities and 150 participants per treatment arm under equal allocation. Additional workshop cohorts and recruitment rounds may be opened to increase the number of participating municipalities. The initial expression-of-interest and contact pool covers approximately 500 municipalities, although many have not yet confirmed participation or selected a workshop session. The final sample size will therefore depend on baseline completion and participation confirmation before randomization.
Primary outcomes
1. Incorporation of information into routine management 2. Prioritization of maternal and child health bottlenecks 3. Adoption of effective management practices
Secondary outcomes
4. Knowledge of health indicators 5. Assessment of relative performance and bottlenecks 6. Use of data systems and sources 7. Maternal and child health service delivery indicators

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords