Mandatory Protection: Survey Evidence on Internalities, Externalities, and Paternalistic Preferences

How to cite

Meemann, Christine; Simon, Sven A.. 2026. "Mandatory Protection: Survey Evidence on Internalities, Externalities, and Paternalistic Preferences." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018375. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18375-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Christine Meemann* , Sven A. Simon

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0018375
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18375-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2026-05-26 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C90, D62, D90, I38
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/18375

Abstract

This survey experiment studies demand for regulation in policy-relevant scenarios involving self-harming behavior (internalities) and externalities. We examine how individuals trade off the benefits of regulation (e.g., protection from negative consequences) against its costs (e.g., restrictions on freedom of choice). In order to do so, we measure perceptions of internal and external harms, as well as the subjective instrumental and intrinsic value of choice rights, and relate these to the acceptance of the latter. A key question is whether individuals are aware of the trade-off between protection and choice rights, and when regulation is regarded as paternalistic. In a between-subjects design (neutral, internality, externality), we also exogenously vary the salience of internalities and test the effect on the support for regulation.

Intervention

The survey study addresses the following research questions:

1. Is support for regulatory interventions shaped by perceived individual costs and benefits?
1a. Costs: Is support for regulation related to instrumental and/or intrinsic valuations of choice rights?
1b. Benefits: Is support for regulation related to individuals' perceptions of internalities and/or externalities?
1c. Trade off: How is the awareness of a trade off between restriction and protection related to individual costs and benefits?

2. Is acceptance of internal and external harms (i.e., tolerance for such harms) related to instrumental and/or intrinsic valuations of choice rights?

3. Are regulatory interventions perceived as paternalistic?

4. How does support for regulation vary with the salience of internalities and externalities?

We additionally conduct exploratory analyses to examine heterogeneity in preferences and trade-offs across individuals and conditions. These analyses are labeled as exploratory.

Experimental design

The survey consists of three parts, with Part 1 being the main component of the study:

Part 1. Participants are presented with short, hypothetical but realistic policy-relevant scenarios (vignettes) set in Germany. After each vignette, participants answer a set of questions measuring their support for regulation (regulatory preference), acceptance of internalities and externalities, perceived trade-offs between protection from internalities and externalities and freedom, and further related attitudes (see primary outcomes).

Each participant evaluates two scenarios. The order of scenarios and assignment to participants are randomized. We control for order effects in all analyses. We may restrict the analysis to the scenario on order first.

Part 2. General questions on attitudes toward freedom and regulation.

Part 3. Post-experimental questionnaire.

We include a set of scenarios covering different policy contexts (list provided below):
- Ban on cigarettes and tobacco products (physical health)
- Ban on the use of beauty filters on social media (mental health and society)
- Mandatory helmet use among cyclists (physical health and society)
- Ban on oil and gas heating systems (environment)

We implement a between-subjects design with three treatment conditions:

1. Neutral: Description of the status quo in different countries.
2. Internality: Description of the status quo plus information about potential internal harms.
3. Externality: Description of the status quo plus information about potential external harms.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by a computer (treatment and scenario).
Randomization unit
Individual level.
Clusters
No clustering.
Observations
Number of total observations: 2,400 participants x 2 scenarios = 4,800 observations.
Arms
Observations per scenario (first shown): 600 scenario I (cigarettes) 600 scenario II (beauty filters) 600 scenario III (helmets) 600 scenario IV (heating) Participants per treatment (scenario first shown): 800 Neutral 800 Internality 800 Externality
Primary outcomes
Primary outcomes: - Support for regulation (regulatory preference) - Perceived paternalism - Acceptance of internalities - Acceptance of externalities - Perceived general trade-off between protection and freedom Key explanatory variables (mechanisms): - Instrumental valuation - Intrinsic valuation - Perception of externalities - Perception of internalities - Scenario indicator (as control variable)
Secondary outcomes
- Sociodemographic characteristics (e.g., income, education, age, gender, religious affiliation) - General attitudes toward freedom and regulation - General control variables (e.g., trust)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords