Management consultants’ perceptions of the effectiveness of management consultancy across different types of organizations.
How to cite
Fenizia, Alessandra; Lemos, Renata Lemos. 2026. "Management consultants’ perceptions of the effectiveness of management consultancy across different types of organizations.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0018369. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.18369-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study aims to explore management consultants’ perceptions of the effectiveness of management consultancy across different types of organizations. While there is a substantial body of research on the impact of consultancy interventions—particularly in the private
sector—there is limited evidence on what consultants themselves view as important and impactful. To address this gap, we plan to conduct a survey of management consultants in Greece. Specifically, we seek to understand which organizational settings consultants consider most conducive to improvements in organizational outcomes, and whether there are perceived barriers to implementing such interventions in public sector institutions.
Intervention
This experiment survey consists of three components administered through an online survey to management consultants.
Discrete Choice Experiment: Participants are presented with 8 pairs of hypothetical organizations and asked to select which would experience greater performance improvement if both were to implement the recommendations of management consultants. Organizations are described across seven management practice attributes: frequency of performance tracking (annually vs. monthly), target horizon (short-term vs. short- and long-term), approach to problem handling (fix only vs. fix and prevent recurrence), manager performance bonuses (none vs. some), promotion method (merit-based vs. tenure/connections), speed of reassignment of poor performers (within 3–6 months vs. after 2 years), and manager training budget per employee (ranging from 30% below to 30% above average). Sector labels are omitted to avoid priming effects. Respondents are randomly assigned to one of four blocks of choice sets.
Ranking of Barriers: Participants are asked to rank perceived barriers to the use of management consultancy in public sector organizations.
Belief-Updating Experiment: All participants are first presented with a case study of a management consultancy intervention in Greek Vocational Training Institutions (VTIs) and asked to estimate its take-up rate and intention-to-treat (ITT) effects on dropout rates and apprenticeship assignments, eliciting their prior beliefs. Participants are then randomly assigned (50/50) to treatment or control. The treatment group is shown the actual results from the VTI intervention (Fenizia et al., 2026), while the control group is not. All participants then predict the effectiveness of a similar intervention in Greek hospital emergency rooms — specifically its take-up rate and effects on patient wait times — as well as their general beliefs about consultancy effectiveness in the public and private sectors more broadly.
Experimental design
Discrete Choice Experiment: Participants are randomly assigned to one of four blocks of choice sets (drawn from a D-efficient design of 32 choice sets). Participants are shown 8 pairs of hypothetical organizations with 7 attributes.
Belief-Updating Experiment: All participants are shown a case study of a management consultancy intervention in Greek Vocational Training Institutions (VTIs) and asked to estimate its effects (eliciting prior beliefs). Participants are then randomly assigned with equal probability to treatment or control. Randomization for the belief-updating experiment is conducted via Qualtrics with a 50/50 split. The treatment group is shown the actual results of the VTI intervention; the control group is not. All participants then predict the effectiveness of a similar intervention in Greek hospital emergency rooms (eliciting posterior beliefs).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.